METRO FEATURE
The Death of Hope
With the exam season looming, counsellors gear up for
another rash of fatal performance anxiety. It wasn't meant to be this way. Nishikant Agarwal, 24, was a smart
kid with a bright future. An engineering student at the Bhabha Atomic Research Centre in
Mumbai, Agarwal failed to turn up for an examination at the institute one morning last
month. When his roommate returned that afternoon, he found his friend's body hanging from
the ceiling. Investigators believe that performance anxiety was the probable cause of
Agarwal's suicide.
The incident, like a number of others over the past year,
has shocked Mumbai out of its indifference. All at once, worried parents and teachers are
waking up to the pressures of modern living that youngsters have to cope with. In Delhi,
the family and friends of a Class VIII student are still reeling under the shock of her
suicide attempt. Just days after reports surfaced of the 13-year-old jumping from the
third storey of her school building, the principal points out
that she didn't fare well in a science test, the results of which were announced that day.
What made this child give up on life? "Youngsters these days have to cope with
incessant social changes and their own changing psychological profile," says Dr Achal
Bhagat, head of the department of psychiatry at Delhi's Apollo Hospital. "The love of
many parents has become conditional, there is an opportunity divide, elders are not
listening enough. The youth themselves have a lower threshold of boredom and have become
more sensation seeking, wanting results to be bigger and better each time."
Studies and statistics support this view. Figures show that
leading the country's death-wish brigade are those below 30, quitting the rat race almost
as soon as they've entered it. An ongoing study among college students in Mumbai involving
Jaslok Hospital, St Xavier's College, the Tata Institute of Social Sciences and Harvard
Medical College has made the startling revelation that a fifth of the students at Xavier's
were depressed, with some showing suicidal tendencies. This research is particularly
relevant as counsellors and helplines in Delhi and Mumbai gear up for what experts call a
"risk period" -- January to March, the run-up to school and college
examinations. During these months, and again from May to June when results are declared,
helplines report a sharp rise in crisis calls.
Fear of being
seen keeps people away from counselling centres |
"Exams are a major source of stress for
students," says Snehlata Deshmukh, vice-chancellor of Mumbai University. Operation
Hope, a Delhi helpline, received 5,000 calls from troubled students over 15 days in May
and June last year. During the higher secondary exams last year, Prerana, a
crisis-intervention centre in Mumbai, received as many as 150 such cries for help in a
day.
It was a call to Operation Hope that saved Sapna Kumar's
life. The 17-year-old from Delhi had just consumed some sleeping tablets on receiving her
examination results and was planning to slash her wrists. Counsellors convinced her that
there were alternatives to the career in medicine that she had planned for herself and
coaxed her to vomit out the tablets. Today, Kumar is doing a course in computer
applications and those moments of despair are well behind her.
Like her, Samresh Salunke is living proof of the need for
more such tele-counsellors. On the third day after his disappearance from home in Mumbai,
22-year-old Salunke resurfaced in November 1997 to place a "highly suicidal"
call to Prerana. Probing by the counsellor revealed that he had already made six attempts
on his life, succumbing to a combination of academic pressures, an absentee father and an
alcoholic mother. Counselling has now taught him to cope with his problems. Prerana's
efforts probably thwarted his seventh suicide attempt.
Salunke and Kumar owe their lives to the small but
determined band of organisations and individuals trying to draw attention to the problem
and the remedies at hand. Alarmed by the rising incidents of suicide among the youth,
Bangalore's National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (nimhans) kicked off a
study in December 1998 entitled "Epidemiology of Suicide". Over the coming year,
researchers will do a psychological post-mortem of victims through responses from their
families, teachers, police and the media with the hope of preventing similar cases. Artist
Rama Rawat's exhibition of sculptures -- "Woman and Child and Educational Pressures
on Children" -- that's on in Mumbai right now, is another such effort. Saarthak, the
NGO that runs Operation Hope, is holding an exhibition called "Hope Shots" in
Delhi this month with photographs by young people to give them a "creative means of
self-expression" and help them "redefine success for themselves",
accompanied by stress-management workshops for students. In March, Saarthak will set up
Hope Centres near Jamia Millia Islamia and Delhi University to provide low-cost
counselling among other things.
They've set themselves a tough task. As Dr Amaresh
Shrivastava, founder of Prerana, points out, "It is very difficult to convince crisis
callers to even come to the centres for counselling. They are petrified of being seen or
identified." If it isn't the stigma, it is the fear of the law. "The judiciary
has been playing see-saw with suicide laws in this country," says Dr Mohan Issacs of
nimhans. While suicide is illegal in most countries of the world, the prevention and
control mechanism in India is such that the law "leaves room for harassment of the
victim and family", adds Issacs. Psychologists further argue that the police should
be made answerable if they fail to ensure psychiatric help for victims while proceeding
with the law.
While the government cites lack of resources for its
failure to widen the counselling network for students and introduce sensitisation
programmes for teachers, social and academic pressures are chipping away at thousands of
already frayed young minds. According to the National Crime Records Bureau, over 40 per
cent of all suicides in this country are in the 15-29 age group. For most people, that's
when the future is taking shape and things are beginning to work out. When they don't,
it's time to step in. Counsellors and helplines are hoping that they'll get there before
it's too late.
-- Nandita Chowdhury with
Anna M Vetticad |