|

|
"I fell in love with him and left my teenaged
husband."
Mukri, 20, from Chittorgarh, was a bride at four and a widow at 10.
Remarried to her three-year-old brother-in-law, Mukri fell in love
with Ram Karan (left) when she was 18. Two years later, she eloped
with him. |
Looking at
her dimunitive frame, you can hardly tell that Mukri, 20, has shouldered
so much burden at such a young age. At four, when girls her age are playing
with dolls, she was married to another toddler, Prehlad Meena, of Kalaru
village in Jaipur district. At age 10, when she had not even learnt the
meaning of marriage, she was a widow. On the 13th day ritual of her husband's
death, she was remarried to her younger brother-in-law, three-year-old
Prakash.
Nature has strange ways of correcting man's mistakes. When she was 18,
Mukri fell in love with her husband's cousin, Ram Karan, a final year
BA student who was sympathetic, intelligent and had a keen sense of humour.
More importantly, he was 20 and Mukri found it easier to relate to him
than to the childish banter of 11-year-old Prakash. In April last year,
Mukri eloped with Karan. Her family lodged a case of kidnapping against
Karan but it was dropped when Mukri told the magistrate that she had accompanied
Karan willingly. The couple is now living happily on the outskirts of
Jaipur.
Abu Bai of Kelukhera village of Chittorgarh was also married off as
a child to Ramesh Balai, who was four years younger than his bride. When
she reached 18, Abu Bai went to stay with her husband. "I spent a
month with him but wasn't happy," she says. So she ran away with
Manohar Lal Salvi, a farmer friend. The couple recently had a son.
|

|
"I was not happy living
with my husband."
Abu Bai of Kelukhera village in Chittorgarh was a child bride. When
she grew up she went to live with him, only to run away with a man
she preferred. |
Such stories are common in Rajasthan. The state police registers an average
of seven cases every day in which a woman or a girl is "kidnapped".
The latest report of the National Crime Record Bureau says that Rajasthan
has the highest number of such cases per lakh of population among Indian
states. The predominantly rural districts of Chittorgarh and Bhilwara
and the urbanised Jaipur district account for the bulk of these-almost
30 per cent of the estimated 2,600 kidnapping cases registered in the
state in a year.
Most of the time, however, the girls have not been abducted but-like
Mukri and Abu Bai-have run away on their own. An analysis of 401 of the
570 cases registered in Bhilwara, Chittorgarh and Jaipur till September
2001 reveals interesting statistics: almost 60 per cent of the women who
left home were married, almost 70 per cent of them were adults and, significantly,
95 per cent had gone of their own volition.
The answer to why so many women run away from their husbands' homes
cannot come from a sweeping generalisation of as complex a thing as human
nature. But one aspect of this social phenomenon is apparent: the mismatch
arising from child marriage, the medieval scourge that is still prevalent
in Rajasthan, is the root of marital discord and the motive for women
to leave their husbands. These days a bride comes to live with her husband
when she is around 16 years. Her childhood leaves her open to liberal
tribal influences-like being able to choose one's spouse. This creates
a problem when she begins living with a stranger of a husband and often
leads to serious problems.
Bhanwar Rawat, 20, a marginal farmer from Chittorgarh district was allegedly
assaulted by his wife. Manju, 18, had made her dislike for him apparent
from the very beginning, spending just 10 days in the first year of marriage
with him. Last month, after Rawat brought her back from her parent's house,
she injured his genitals. Charged with assault, she is now out on bail
and lives with her parents. "I am waiting for the case to be over
so that I can settle down with someone I like," says an unrepentant
Manju.
Frustration may have forced Manju to take an extreme step, but every
year thousands of women in Rajasthan prefer the simpler-and quieter-route
of eloping with their lovers. Their husbands lodge cases of kidnapping
but even if the police manage to trace the couple, the runaway bride declines
to return. Santosh, 20, and Durga Regar, 35, of Sabalpur village in Bhilwara
had been married for three years but the considerable difference in their
age made Santosh seek a younger soulmate. She found one in their neighbour,
26-year-old Hemraj Meena, and the two left for Jaipur. After Durga lodged
an fir against Meena for kidnapping his wife, the police managed to trace
them to the state capital. In her statement to the judicial magistrate,
Santosh said she had gone with Meena of her free will and wanted to stay
with him. "I am happy now," she told india today, caressing
her eight-month-old daughter fathered by Meena.
|

|
"I am waiting to settle down with a man of
my choice."
Manju, 18, from Chittorgarh, has been charged with assaulting and
injuring her husband, Bhanwar Rawat. Rawat says she was unhappy with
the marriage and wanted to live with someone of her choice. |
These cases seem to show that women are no longer willing to tolerate
mismatches. "Many women come to me and categorically say that their
husbands are not sexually fit for them and so they want to look for alternatives,"
discloses Tara Ahluwalia, Bhilwara-based social activist. And since it
is difficult for a woman to remarry once she bears a child, there are
many who want to leave their husbands at the first opportunity. The high
number of elopements in the state could also be explained by the feudal
mindset in rural Rajasthan. Registration of marriages is unheard of. Instead,
many depend on their caste panchyats to solve marital problems. Says Ajit
Singh Shekhawat, dig of Police, Jaipur: "Caste panchyats have evolved
different customs and practises at different places and enforce these
through threats of social boycott." Says Anil Paliwal, sp, Chittorgarh:
"Community panchayats encourage promiscuity through easy remarriages."
Indeed, the ease with which these quasi-judicial panchayats approve
separations and remarriages make a fast-track court appear slow. Panchayats
allow women the freedom to dissolve a marriage if she is not happy. Srinivas
Rao Janga, sp, Bhilwara, is shocked by this libertarian trend: "I
find an advanced state of Americanised society prevalent in our rural
areas."
All panchayats practise customs called the nata (relationship) and jhagda
(remuneration to end disputes). In these the man with whom the woman chooses
to stay pays her husband compensation. The husband also gets back jewellery
he has given his wife. However, in places like Devli in Tonk, this tradition
is freely used to allow a man to trade his wife to a man of his liking.
The girl's parents also get a share of the jhagda amount-usually Rs 10,000
to Rs 1 lakh-putting marriages at risk of manipulation by greedy relatives.
When Kamla, 18, of Keria Kheri village in Bhilwara eloped with Bhanwar
Jat, her parents lodged a case of kidnapping against him. Ultimately,
Bhanwar Jat gave Rs 1 lakh to her parents as jhagda. But when Kamla left
Bhanwar Jat for Radheyshyam a month later, her parents gave that money
to Radheyshyam to enable him to pay Bhanwar Jat the jhagda.
|

|
"My husband couldn't stop his brother and
wife from harassing me."
Unable to stand the ill treatment meted out to her, Mangi Bai from
Bhilwara district, left her husband and started living with her sister's
brother-in-law, Shankar Jat (right). |
The whole affair can sometimes reach ridiculous levels. Lad, 23, a child
bride of Bagore village in Bhilwara deserted by her husband, ran away
with her younger sister's father-in-law, Shiv Lal Jat. Her father Ram
Lal Jat lodged a complaint. When the couple was traced, Lad told the police
that after her failed child marriage, she did not want to marry anyone
of her father's choice. A settlement was arrived at in which her father
got Rs 30,000 and her first husband, Rs 45,000. Gangapur dsp Rajkumar
witnessed the amusing spectacle of the charged atmosphere suddenly turning
cordial after the agreement had been reached.
|

|
"I ran away when my father wanted me to marry
someone else."
Jani Bai, 20, from Chittorgarh was engaged to Onkar Lal (right), who
had paid her father Rs 5,000. She ran away with Onkar when her father
got greedy and wanted her to marry a richer man. |
Not surprisingly, most cases registered in the state say the girls are
minors. Often greedy parents get their daughters to give a false testimony
to extract money from her paramour. Lad Kumari of Soji Khera village in
Bhilwara, was engaged to Lahru, who paid Rs 60,000 to her widowed mother.
Even before the nuptials could be performed, Lad started staying with
Lahru and became pregnant. Her mother lodged a case of kidnapping against
Lahru. Lad told the police she had stayed with Lahru on her own but retracted
when she met her mother. A medical examination put her age below 18 and
if the court judges her a minor, Lahru may end up facing a rape charge.
"The fragility of relations is affecting the concept of the family,"
says Janga. He suggests making registration of marriages compulsory, not
only to make them harder to dissolve but also to dilute the role of caste
panchayats. Love, deceit and revenge could then be less of a social menace
in Rajasthan.
|