|
This season
the venerable Mohun Bagan club of Kolkata enjoyed many triumphs on the
football field: it won the Federation Cup and followed it up with the
top spot in the National Football League to emerge as the best team in
the country. But celebrations and activities at the club have suddenly
come to a standstill. Even though it is India's national champion side,
Mohun Bagan will not be participating in an event designed for Asia's
champion club sides, the Asian Football Confederation Champions League.
The reason: Mohun Bagan is unable to sign up players for the coming
season due to internal wranglings and is, therefore, incapable of fielding
a team. If the problem persists, the club, an institution of Bengal's
pride ever since its barefoot players won-Lagaan style-the 1911 IFA Shield
against the East Yorkshire Regiment, will be relegated to the lower divisions.
For the club's estimated eight million supporters, that will be a dishonour
beyond their worst fears.
| SPORTS
|
  |
BONES OF CONTENTION |
 |
» Mohun
Bagan is unable to sign players for the coming season. It has
had to give a prestigious Asian club championship a miss.
» The club
is in danger of missing out on player purchases during the transfers
period later this month.
» A dispute
over a deal with the UB Group which required a name-change is
cited as the reason.
» The UB
Group has given an ultimatum: the name-change must happen by
June.
» Dissenting
members accuse the current management of violating club rules,
seizing power with a bogus election. |
|
The reason the club cannot line up a team at the end of a glorious season
has nothing to do with money; the club is not cash-strapped, having won
over Rs 50 lakh in prizes. At the heart of its dilemma is the ongoing
battle for its soul following a five-year-old sponsorship deal.
In the second half of May, Mohun Bagan was to have launched its costly
player-signing drive but the plans ran aground when a section of its members
began to push the cases they had filed earlier against the existing management
for, among other things, "surrendering" the club's "title".
The reference is to the emotive issue of the troubled joint venture with
the liquor firm McDowell's under which the name of the club was to have
been changed to McDowell's Mohun Bagan. The JV, United Breweries Mohun
Bagan Football Team (UBMBFT) Private Limited, was formed at the initiative
of Vijay Mallya, promoter of McDowell's as well as beer major United Breweries
(UB), race-horse owner and now Rajya Sabha member. A section of Bagan
members took the matter of the name-change to court and in May 1998 the
Calcutta High Court stayed the change.
 |
"Our side won't play until the cases against
us are withdrawn."
Anjan Mitra, General Secretary, Mohun Bagan |
Five years after the signing of the deal, the directors of McDowell's
are now running out of patience. Upset at the impasse over the name-change
after having pumped in around Rs 8 crore, McDowell's directors on the
board of UBMBFT have reportedly demanded the problem be fixed before the
new season begins in June. Mohun Bagan General Secretary Anjan Mitra,
who is a director of UBMBFT, is now wary of dipping his hand in the joint
venture's fund for signing on players. "We must sort out the legal
problem first," he says. "No one from our side will let his
boot touch the ball until the cases against us are withdrawn."
He may have calculated that in a year of the club's blazing on-field
successes, "fan pressure" on the litigant members would be enough
to force them to withdraw the suits. Bagan fans mill around the club's
tent every day, screaming, "We want the team." But Mitra's calculation
seems to have gone wrong so far.
The dissidents come from the cream of the club's 7,500-odd regular members,
many of them high court judges, top lawyers, leading doctors, captains
of the state's industries and scions of old landlord families. They think
of themselves as a class apart from those associated with rivals East
Bengal. So far they have been successful in stalling the Executive Committee's
decision.
|
|
 |
| DEADLOCK: The arrival of Mallya (above, bearded)
at Mohun Bagan has snowballed into a crisis that has left fans furious |
In the matter of bowing to sponsors' demands, the dissidents among the
Bagan "barristocray" could not have been more contrary to their
arch enemies at East Bengal. UB had formed a similar joint venture with
East Bengal club at the same time as Bagan. While the deal has worked
out well with East Bengal, which has agreed to rename its football team,
the Executive Committee of Mohun Bagan was beset with an avalanche of
court cases filed by its own members. Amal Sen, a solicitor and trustee
member of the club, accuses Mitra of "turning upside down the laws
and rules of the club, not to speak of the values it stands for".
Already there have been two contempt and two criminal cases initiated
against officials.
But it is not only Mohun Bagan which is in a spot. So is UB, over the
increasingly difficult business of football sponsorship. McDowell's had
earlier sponsored Mohammedan Sporting in exchange for the club's players
wearing its Bagpiper logo on their jerseys. This year, however, the majority
Muslim patrons of the club complained about the association with liquor.
McDowell's had no option other than terminating its sponsorship contract
with the club. Down south, the relegation of FC Kochin following its miserable
performance has also destroyed McDowell's hopes of profiting from football
sponsorship.
Even in the bizarre business of football, UB's attempt to own a large
share of three rival clubs was unusual and drew adverse comment. Mallya
had sound commercial reasons though. While his liquor products cannot
be advertised in the print media and on many television channels, they
gain enough visibility on players' jerseys, or in association with the
local trophy-winning clubs. The problem with Mohun Bagan is sure to affect
his investments in East Bengal too. If the Mohun Bagan deal comes unstuck,
Mallya must mix his business with something other than football.
The deadlock appears unbreakable now but as the beginning of the new
football season in June draws close, temperatures on the maidans are only
bound to rise.
|