|
|
| BACKING INDIA: US Ambassador Robert Blackwill
(left) and Rumsfeld with Vajpayee and Jaswant Singh |
This is,
in every sense of the phrase, a defining moment in the history of India's
decade-old war against cross-border terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir. Admittedly,
it has come with considerable help from Washington. Even so, it has the
potential to permanently end infiltration of Pakistan-backed terror groups.
Or, in a worst-case scenario, keep them penned up till the October elections
in Jammu and Kashmir are over, in itself a major victory for Indian diplomacy.
No wonder External Affairs Minister Jaswant Singh looked tired but elated
after the visits of US Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage and
Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. While Armitage had conveyed the unambiguous
message that Pakistan President General Pervez Musharraf has decided to
"permanently" end infiltration into Jammu and Kashmir, Rumsfeld
declared, "I have seen indications that the Al-Qaida is operating
near the Line of Control (LoC) in Jammu and Kashmir."
In effect, the international community is now substantiating the Indian
stand that Pakistan is squarely behind the wave of terrorism in Jammu
and Kashmir. South Block has other reasons to celebrate. Since the Kaluchak
massacre, the External Affairs Ministry and the Prime Minister's Office
(PMO) have shown remarkable synergy in handling the international community
and the diplomatic-military offensive against Pakistan. For the past month,
Jaswant and the man widely perceived as his bete noire, Brajesh Mishra,
national security adviser and principal secretary to the prime minister,
have marched in step and consulted each other on the Indian response to
Pakistani actions and pressure from the international community almost
on a daily basis. The duo gambled on coercive diplomacy rather than the
military option against Pakistan and it appears to have paid off, at least
for the present.
|
|
| THE HEAVYWEIGHTS: Armitage and Advani in broad
agreement |
Shortly after returning from a visit to the subcontinent, UK's Foreign
Secretary Jack Straw told the House of Commons on June 10 that Britain
was convinced there was a "clear link" between the Pakistani
Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) and terrorist groups such as the Lashkar-e-Toiba
(LeT), Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) and Harkat-ul-Mujahideen. More significantly,
Straw added that there was no point in getting involved in the "historiographical
exercise" of UN Security Council resolutions on Kashmir. Instead,
it was important to find a way out to resolve the "bilateral dispute
that has international implications".
For Islamabad and General Pervez Musharraf-till recently the poster boy
of the global coalition against terror-the irony could not have been starker
and the message more explicit. Straw's House of Commons statement and
Rumsfeld's comments are clear indicators that the major global players
now side with Delhi on its stand that de-escalation on the India-Pakistan
borders and a dialogue with Islamabad is only possible after a visible
end of cross-border terrorism in Kashmir and dismantling of the terrorist
infrastructure in Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir (PoK). Addressing the Asia
Society on June 10, US Secretary of State Colin Powell said: "Musharraf
has assured us the cessation of activity would be visible and would be
permanent and would be followed by other activities that had to do with
the dismantling of camps that led to the capacity to conduct these kind
of operations." This is precisely the response India was hoping for.
|
THE NEXT MOVES
|
|
INDIA
» Could resize
its mission in Pakistan and grant landing rights for aircraft ...
» May pull back
troops from the international border and the LoC...
» May initiate
talks with Pakistan on all issues, including Kashmir...
if
PAKISTAN
» Dismantles
terrorist infrastructure and removes launch pads near the LoC.
» Does not engineer
terrorist violence during Assembly polls in Kashmir.
» Abandons cross-border
terrorism as state policy and acts on the list of 20.
|
In diplomacy, there are no free lunches. The US and UK want both India
and Pakistan to undertake a cycle of mutually reinforced actions that
lead to de-escalation of tensions and finally a dialogue on all outstanding
issues, including Jammu and Kashmir. That process is already in motion.
Last week, Delhi lifted the January 1 ban on Pakistani aircraft and airlines
using Indian airspace, recalled the operationally deployed Indian Navy's
warships from the Arabian Sea and decided "in principle" to
send its high commissioner back to Islamabad.
India's actions are based on its assessment that infiltration into Jammu
and Kashmir is visibly on the decline. Intelligence reports say that only
40-45 infiltrators had crossed the LoC since Musharraf's aggressive May
27 speech and satellite imagery has shown tents housing terrorists near
Muzaffarabad in PoK being taken down. During his recent visit, Russian
Deputy Foreign Minister Anatoly Safanov had been taken to PoK by the Pakistani
Army in order to convince Moscow of steps Islamabad had taken against
Kashmir terrorists and their infrastructure. This information was later
conveyed to Delhi by the Russians.
Further, India is no longer making an issue of the list of 20 terrorists
whose extradition it has been demanding. Armitage, during his visit, had
told his Indian counterpart that while Musharraf was committed to ending
infiltration, he had cited "Pakistan honour and dignity" to
justify Islamabad's refusal to act on the list. The Indian Government
has also selected Harsh Bhasin as India's high commissioner to Pakistan
though his name has not yet been sent to Islamabad for formal accreditation.
On other issues raised by the Americans, India has dug in its heels. One
was that India should withdraw its strike aircraft from the forward bases
near the India-Pakistan border. India says it wants Musharraf to not only
turn off "the tap of infiltration but drain the reservoir feeding
Kashmir terrorism" before it will agree to any such step. Delhi has
pointed out that as late as June 8, six terrorists tried to cross the
LoC in Mendhar sector in Jammu and Kashmir despite the presence of a Pakistani
Army picket on their route. Delhi told Rumsfeld that terrorists are still
waiting to infiltrate into Jammu and Kashmir from "launch pads"
in PoK. The Indian assessment is that more than 2,500 terrorists are massed
along the LoC in Gurez, Kupwara, Baramullah, Uri and Poonch sectors.
|
|
| STAYING ALERT: Indian troops will stay put
till after the Kashmir elections |
Further, radio intercepts prove that PoK-based terrorists are still in
touch with their fellow jehadis in Jammu and Kashmir, exhorting them to
keep their powder dry for another day. The Indian leadership made it clear
to Rumsfeld that the US could not "segment" its fight against
terrorism by restricting its anti-Al-Qaida operations to Afghanistan and
Pakistan tribal areas. Implicit in this was the suggestion that the US
should also take action against terrorist groups such as LeT and JeM in
Pakistan, the support base of the global Al-Qaida network.
The key issue now is a mechanism to patrol the LoC and monitor activities
in PoK. Delhi has proposed joint patrolling of the LoC by troops from
both sides while Islamabad wants international observers. Home Minister
L.K. Advani told a British newspaper that India would prefer international
observers in PoK instead, since terrorists were infiltrating from the
Pakistani side.
The bottom line, as far as Delhi is concerned, is that once tension
is reduced and infiltration visibly ended, India would like a joint patrolling
mechanism with Pakistani troops. Both sides would be equipped with sophisticated
electronic sensors to detect infiltration. In fact, during his trip to
the US in January, Advani was specially briefed by Kent Biringer, director,
Sandia National Laboratories, New Mexico, on how electronic sensors can
be used to make infiltration difficult for PoK-based terrorists. The US
may be willing to sell underground sensors to India as part of the direct
military sales under the ongoing bilateral defence cooperation though
Rumsfeld said that the proposal for sensors "did not reach any conclusion".
Washington, however, has indicated its willingness to share technical
and human intelligence on terrorists and terror groups with both India
and Pakistan.
The Indian perception is that Pakistan will check infiltration but at
the same time ask its jehadis operating inside Jammu and Kashmir to raise
the level of violence close to the assembly elections in the state. Islamabad
can then claim that the violence is part of the indigenous "freedom
struggle" and not terrorism. Islamabad is hoping its current moves
to stop infiltration will give it the leverage to exert international
pressure on Delhi to resolve the Kashmir dispute on a priority basis.
On a visit to the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia last week, Musharraf
termed the recent Indian steps to defuse tensions "cosmetic"
and reiterated his three-point formula for peace in the region: de-nuclearisation
of South Asia, strengthening of deterrents and resolution of the Kashmir
issue.
The Indian government is fully aware that the Americans are planning
some action against Iraq, possibly by September. Hence, American pressure
for the start of a dialogue on Kashmir and de-escalation of forces can
only get stronger. However, Delhi is taking no chances. Indian Army commanders
met last week and decided that there will be no change in force "posturing"
or withdrawal of troops along the western borders at least till the Jammu
and Kashmir elections since it would be difficult to mobilise again if
there is another terrorist strike. The commanders decided to undertake
"cost cutting measures" (it costs Rs 33 lakh per day to operationally
maintain a strike corps near the border). The Indian Air Force has already
stopped augmenting its forward air bases with more personnel last week
but there is no change in its operational status. Even though the navy
has pulled back, it has the capability to re-deploy within 12 hours.
All this is to convey to Washington and Islamabad that the threat of
war may be receding but Delhi will need a lot more evidence before Prime
Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee finally agrees to shake Musharraf's hand.
|