Sonia
Gandhi brushes aside critics to make her speech at the Oxford Centre
for Islamic Studies.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
Having discarded the AIADMK's Dravidian
roots, Jayalalithaa is out to overshadow the MGR legacy. India Today's Arun
Ram traces the path of her untiring ambition. Iconic
Change
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE DECEMBER 16, 2002
THE NATION: PARLIAMENT
The Householders
After two deadlocked sessions Parliament is brought
on track by its presiding officers
by Lakshmi Iyer
Politics
in Delhi has of late begun to resemble the weather in the capital. Into
the second week of December, yet there is only a nip in the air. In politics
too, the frostiness is missing. Nowhere is this more visible than in Parliament
which halfway through the winter session is yet to witness what newspaper
headline writers call "pandemonium". There have been no dramatic
disruption of proceedings, no repeated adjournments, no sharp exchanges
between members on the treasury and opposition benches. And, surprisingly,
the well of either House-into which members troop when the bell signals
the end of question hour every working day in Parliament-remains untransgressed.
For the record, in the first 13 working days of the ongoing winter session,
the Lok Sabha passed 19 bills and the Rajya Sabha 14. Even the decade-long
ritual of a December 6 protest-against the demolition of the Babri Masjid
in 1992-was minimal in both Houses. A token protest was recorded by opposition
members in the Rajya Sabha on December 5, since the anniversary fell on
a holiday; in the Lok Sabha the members made a feeble attempt to disrupt
the question hour. They needed little persuasion from the chair to get
back to their seats. The Opposition has virtually mocked at political
pundits who had predicted Parliament would be the battleground for the
Gujarat polls. Venomous speeches were reserved for public rallies in Ahmedabad
and Vadodara. In Parliament, the support that the nda Government received
from across the aisle made the dividing line between the treasury and
the Opposition almost invisible. It even made up for all the time lost
during the two raucous previous sessions. Four key financial laws-the
Securitisation & Reconstruction of Financial Assets Bill, the Negotiable
Instruments (Amendment) Bill, the uti (Transfer of Undertaking and Repeal)
Bill and the sebi Bill-were passed.
MANHOAR JOSHI
Speaker, Lok Sabha
B.S. SHEKHAWAT Chairman, Rajya Sabha
"Ministers should take questions seriously.
Everyone must come prepared."
"Question Hour is sacrosanct. Lots
of effort goes into preparing answers."
Q. The previous session, your first
as Speaker, ended abruptly.
A. The House can run smoothly if leaders agree. You also have
to be lucky. The petrol pump issue had erupted suddenly during the
last session.
Q. It has been smooth so far during the winter session. How
come?
A. Before the session, I met Sonia Gandhi and other leaders.
I assured them I would allow any discussion. Media disapproval of
frequent adjournments must have influenced the floor strategy of
all political parties.
Q. You are keeping ministers on their toes.
A. Ministers should take questions seriously. So should the
officers. The Union Cabinet is responsible to the Lok Sabha. Everyone
must come fully prepared.
Q. You are placing a lot of emphasis
on question hour.
A. I wanted to improve attendance during question hour. A lot
of effort and resources go into preparing answers. That should not
go waste.
Q. You have introduced a lot of changes in the functioning of
the House.
A. I have restricted the number of supplementary questions so
that more questions can be taken up during question hour. Absenteeism
was high during question hour because not more than two questions
were taken up.
Q. You have been cracking the whip on ministers.
A. I found that ministers were not answering questions directly.
Like opposition MPs, many of them waste time prefacing their replies
with political statements.
It's not that the honourable MPs have suddenly been through a crash course
in parliamentary behaviour and etiquette. Both the Government and the
Opposition credit the smooth ride in Parliament to a large extent to the
two new presiding officers-Vice-President and Rajya Sabha Chairman Bhairon
Singh Shekhawat and Lok Sabha Speaker Manohar Joshi. As Parliamentary
Affairs Minister Pramod Mahajan says, "Both of them are former chief
ministers and have spent nearly four decades in state legislatures, politics
and the government. In conducting the business of the two Houses, they
have brought with them their vast, vast experience." Congress Deputy
Leader in the Lok Sabha Shivraj Patil, himself a former Speaker of the
Lower House, agrees. About Joshi, a rival in Maharashtra politics, he
says, "By nature he is very composed. He is a very seasoned politician.
He has been both leader of the Maharashtra Assembly as well as leader
of its Opposition. He tries to be impartial." Echoes Margaret Alva,
"He takes quick, on-the-spot decisions."
In the Upper House, Congress members are liberal in their praise of the
chairman for his non-partisan approach. "He gives us all the time
to speak and even puts ministers on the mat on our behalf," says
MP Mabel Rebello. Her party colleague Karnendu Bhattacharjee, who was
recently pulled up for absenting himself from the House, says, "I
could not attend the House because of a family emergency. However, I still
feel the chairman was not unjustified in upbraiding me." To avoid
questions lapsing due to absence of members, Shekhawat has now instructed
MPs to give him prior notice about their absence or alternatively to authorise
some other member to put the question.
MPs long used to treating the House as their house would normally have
treated such directives with disdain, but Shekhawat is actually winning
friends from across the political spectrum. Says the vice-president: "I
primarily wanted to improve attendance during question hour. A lot of
effort and resources go into preparing answers. I did not want that to
go waste. It is in people's interest that the ministers give oral replies
to more questions," he says. To achieve this he has restricted the
number of supplementary questions to two.
In step: Lack of threat to the NDA made Mahajan
concede Opposition demands
Getting down
to work In 13 working days, Parliament passed 14 bills. Prominent
ones among them are:
Securitisation BILL: Enables banks and financial institutions
to recover bad debts by selling the assets of defaulters.
UTI Bifurcation Bill: Splits Unit Trust of India into two
separate companies.
SEBI BILL: aimed at enhancing powers of stock market regulator.
Negotiable Instruments: The bill doubles punishment for
bouncing of cheques.
Money-Laundering Bill: Pending for three years, adds teeth
to laws against financial crimes.
Ordinarily, 20 questions are listed for oral answers during question
hour which set off business in both Houses each working day. "Absenteeism
was high during question hour because not more than one or two questions
could be taken up. Too many supplementary questions took up the entire
hour. So members, ministers and officials took the remaining 18 questions
lightly," he says. None of the members is complaining about the curbs
on the number of supplementary questions. "It is for our larger good.
If more questions are being taken, why should we complain?" asks
cpi(m) member Nilotpal Basu.
Shekhawat's enthusiasm for question time is palpable in his personal
office at Parliament House. The wager among his staff every day is about
the House one day setting a record by securing replies for oral questions.
Of course, the eagerness to improve question tally is not Shekhawat's
alone. His enthusiasm is shared by his Lok Sabha counterpart. On December
4, while wrapping up the question hour, an overwhelmed Joshi thanked the
members for enabling him to take up as many as 15 questions listed for
the day. And this he manages to do without putting curbs on any member
who seeks any kind of supplementary information on listed questions. "I
cannot set any limit for supplementary questions since the Lok Sabha is
a large House. I would be happy if we can take up as many as six to eight
questions every day," he says. He snatches time for questions by
discouraging members from prefacing their question with long-winded speeches.
Members are particularly happy with the manner in which he pays attention
to competition among rival regional parties. Recalls dmk member Adhi Shankar:
"During question hour, our Thanjavur MP, S.S. Palanimanickam, made
a point about the Cauvery water issue. He extended the question hour by
a minute just to enable another MP to have his say too."
It is not as if the two presiding officers share an interest in improving
question hour alone. Even ministers are told they have to be more accountable
to the elected representatives. Every morning, Joshi goes through written
submissions made by ministers to see if they have answered the questions
adequately. At least two ministers have been upbraided for attending the
House without adequate preparations.
Shekhawat has gone a step ahead in keeping a vigilant eye on ministers.
He once put an evasive Civil Supplies Minister Sharad Yadav on the mat
on the issue of starvation deaths by asking him why the Government was
not doing anything when its own godowns were overflowing with foodgrains.
His intervention forced Prime Minister A.B. Vajpayee to offer to convene
an all-party meeting on the issue.
Leaders of major political parties say a number of factors beside the
two amiable presiding officers have contributed to the smooth running
of the winter session. "Media flak as well as a marked shift in government
tactics are responsible for the smooth running of Parliament," says
cpi(m) leader Somnath Chatterjee. Congress Chief Whip in the Lok Sabha
Priya Ranjan Das Munshi says important bills had to be passed since ordinances
had been issued twice on securitisation and uti bifurcation. But his colleagues
admit that the Congress did not make too much fuss about the divisive
politics of the ruling bjp as it feared it would become a double-edged
weapon in Gujarat.
It was not just the Congress that was worried about Gujarat. The Government
too had an eye on the election-bound state. "In the first two days
of the winter session, the Government surprised the Opposition by agreeing
to two Opposition-sponsored motions. That is why we too helped in the
passage of the bills," says rjd's Raghuvansh Prasad Singh. Mahajan
admits the decision to give in to the Opposition demand for adjournment
motions was taken since the Government did not see any threat to the nda
coalition.
The Government's readiness to accede to virtually every demand has robbed
the Opposition of enthusiasm to mount any offensive. Besides, with the
election fever in high pitch in Gujarat, senior leaders from both sides
were reserving their lung power for the campaign. If the Gujarat polls
helped the MPs shift the battleground from Parliament, will its conclusion
see Parliament getting back to its old ways? The five days that Parliament
sits after the elections in Gujarat are over on December 12 should provide
the answer to that question.