As
clubbers fall in rhythm with the beats of electronic music, bands
like Midival Punditz find takers worldwide.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The pathetic condition of roads
in Madhya Pradesh acts a severe bottleneck to its progress. India Today's
Neeraj Mishra takes a drive and to find out exactly how bad they are. BUMPY
RIDE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE DECEMBER 23, 2002
COVER STORY: DEFENCE
When India Came Close To War
Twice this
year, in January and June, India was on the verge of striking against Pakistan.
Here's why it didn't.
By Shishir Gupta
Last Christmas, fighter pilots of the Indian Air
Force's No. 1 Tiger Squadron of Mirage-2000 H aircraft were not in celebratory
mode. Moved a week earlier from home base Gwalior to the forward base
Adampur near Jalandhar, the Tigers packed pistols, high-protein Swiss
chocolates and a quarter-inch map of Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir (PoK).
These would come in handy in case any of them was shot down behind enemy
lines.
When India came close to
Key to the Indian plans were army commando raids
inside PoK
Their comrades in arms, the Indian Army's para-commandos, looked like
the US marines with war paint, MP-5 sub-machine guns, infrared night-vision
devices, Kevlar bulletproof jackets and hi-tech frequency-hopping radio
sets. For the past week, the two elite forces had been secretly conducting
mock raids in the hills of Jammu and Kashmir. This was not a routine exercise.
It was preparation for war. Just how close India actually came to war,
not once but twice, is emerging only now, and India Today was able to
piece together key details.
It all began on December 13, 2001, when Pakistan-based terrorists of
the Lashkar-e-Toiba (LeT) and the Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) attacked the
Indian Parliament, killing nine people. As the real intent of the strike
sunk in and evidence of Pakistan's involvement mounted, Prime Minister
A.B. Vajpayee made it clear that India's patience had worn thin. At a
meeting of the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) and the three service
chiefs on December 15, Vajpayee asked the service chiefs, "Can we
do something quickly?" All three responded in the affirmative. The
CCS-comprising Deputy Prime Minister L.K. Advani, the then external affairs
minister Jaswant Singh, finance minister Yashwant Sinha, Defence Minister
George Fernandes, Planning Commission Chairman K.C. Pant and National
Security Adviser Brajesh Mishra-agreed on a strike against PoK-based terrorists.
Vajpayee
wanted strikes on PoK-based terrorists, but Pakistan cleverly
shifted their camps, limiting India's options
THE
CAUSE
THE
BUILD-UP
THE
D-DAY PLAN
>
The December 13 attack on Indian Parliament by Pakistan-based LeT
and JeM jehadis that left nine dead. > Pakistan's use of cross-border
terrorism as state policy and ISI's abetment of terrorist groups in
Jammu and Kashmir. > The extremely low post-9/11
global tolerance for terrorists posing as freedom fighters.
>
Government directs force mobilisation on December 18, 2001. > Defensive
corps in the western and southern sectors mobilised by December 28,
2001, the largest build-up since the 1971 war. > IAF deploys 272 jets in the
western sector; the navy moves its eastern fleet to the Arabian Sea.
A Mirage-2000 H, MiG-27 fighters to hit PoK-based terror camps
with precision munition.
B Artillery guns to fire across
the LoC targeting Pakistani troop bunkers and terrorist launch pads
with laser-guided bombs.
C Under cover of artillery fire
and air support, special forces to be para-dropped behind enemy lines
to destroy terrorists and camps.
INDIA'S
OFFENSIVE
PAKISTAN'S
COUNTER
THE
US FACTOR
>
To use air-land battle to open various fronts on the LoC and stretch
Pakistani forces in PoK. > To push in a brigade of army
commandos into PoK while regular troop formations retain tactical
heights on the LoC against enemy offensive. > To gain control over terrorist
infiltration routes in PoK, destroy terrorist communication network
and launch pads near the LoC. > To stretch Pakistani forces
at strategic Haji Pir pass and try to link up the Uri-Poonch axis. > To occupy dominant heights
on the LoC in Siachen, Kargil and in Poonch-Rajouri sectors. > To hold on to PoK territory
near the LoC and use it for future talks on Kashmir.
>
Packs the eastern sector with troops by moving two Peshawar-Corps
divisions to Muzaffarabad and Punjab. Beefs up the Lahore area to
counter the Indian attack in PoK. > Places the Mangla-based Army
Reserve North on red alert. Plans to launch a counter-offensive in
Akhnoor sector. > The focus of the Pakistani
Air Force is on the Indian Western Command with 200 jets ready to
counter the IAF fighters. > The Pakistani Navy moves
its key war assets from Karachi to Omara, Gwadar and Pasni ports.
>
Called for Indian restraint but conceded Delhi's right to respond
to Islamist terrorist attacks. > In case of a war by Pakistan,
India would be hampered by the US forces in Pakistan and in north
Arabian Sea. > Declared LeT and JeM as terrorist
outfits and put the heat on Musharraf to publicly renounce terrorism
in Kashmir. > Feared Musharraf would go
nuclear after the Indian strike.
WHY
THE STRIKE WAS CALLED OFF
>
Indian war planes would have to cross international borders as Pakistan,
fearing strikes, moved terrorist camps from PoK to northern areas
in Pakistan. > The global community aligned
firmly with India, realising for the first time that Kashmir was facing
Pakistan-sponsored terrorism and not a freedom struggle. > On January 12, Musharraf
banned LeT and JeM and announced regulation of madarsas in his speech. > Delhi's fear that Pakistan
would launch full-scale war and call for global intervention in Kashmir.
January 14, 2002 First Chance
Orders were immediately issued to mobilise troops-more than those in
the runup to the 1971 war. Considering that it would take three to four
weeks for deployment on the western borders, the armed forces planned
action for the second week of January 2002. After much debate, the service
chiefs opted for a limited offensive against the terrorists' training
camps in PoK. It would essentially entail air force strikes to pulverise
zones with a high concentration of camps-that's where the Tiger Squadron
came in. A limited ground offensive by special forces of the army would
further neutralise the camps and help occupy dominant positions on the
loc (see graphic on previous page). D-day was tentatively fixed for January
14.
The Mirage fighters were tasked with pulverising the
PoK zones that had a high concentration of terrorist camps
In Delhi's war calculus, limited action in PoK made sense as it would
not only convey the Indian resolve to Pakistan but also keep international
retribution to manageable levels. India, after all, was only taking a
leaf out of the ongoing US action against Osama bin Laden's Al-Qaida terrorists
in Afghanistan. The daunting prospect of Pakistan launching an all-out
offensive in response to the Indian action weighed heavily on the CCS.
But the intelligence assessment that the Pakistani Army was not well prepared
loaded the dice in India's favour. This meant that the chances of Pakistan
launching a full-scale war were minimal. The Indian plans were also backed
by a sound economy that was bolstered by low inflation, high forex and
petroleum reserves. Sinha went on record saying the economy was prepared
for war even though it was the last option.
A limited strike was a clever tactical option. The build-up indicated
to the world, especially the US, that India was serious. If Pakistan wasn't
reined in, India would have no option. Delhi also stepped up the diplomatic
offensive, recalling its high commissioner and banning civilian flights
from Pakistan. Picking up the war signals, Pakistan went into hypermode:
it began mobilising forces and exchanged frantic calls with the US, getting
President George W. Bush into the act. Secretary of State Colin Powell
called India and Pakistan to cool down temperatures. British Prime Minister
Tony Blair even flew to India in the first week of January to say that
they were leaning on Pakistani President General Pervez Musharraf. As
proof, the US declared LeT and JeM as terrorist groups. Advani, meanwhile,
flew to the US on January 8, where he was briefed on the contents of Musharraf's
impending landmark speech. The speech finally came on January 12, when
Musharraf declared that terrorism in the name of Kashmir was unjustified.
Practically giving in to Indian demands, he also announced plans to regulate
madarsas and ban known terrorist groups operating out of Pakistan.
Besides Musharraf's speech, there was another factor that shot down
the CCS plans of an immediate war when it met on January 13. Satellite
imagery revealed that Pakistan had moved out most terrorist training camps
from PoK in January, implying that the Indian forces would have to cross
the international borders to achieve militarily significant results. This
was risky as it would show India as an aggressor and could invite global
intervention on Kashmir. So the CCS decided to give Musharraf another
chance but keep the armed forces fully mobilised for war. And in a symbolic
gesture on January 14, the Tiger Squadron destroyed an "enemy"
bunker at Pokhran in Rajasthan with a laser-guided bomb.
Vajpayee
wanted stikes on PoK-based terrorists, but Pakistan cleverly shifted
their camps, limiting India's options
THE CAUSE
THE BUILD-UP
THE D-DAY PLAN
>
Terrorists attack an army camp at Kaluchak on May 14, leaving 22 dead. > Cross-border infiltration
rises after a low spell in February and March. > Musharraf fails to deliver
on his January 12 speech. > Pakistan-based jehadis become
active in Kashmir, PoK camps return.
>
CCS favours action against terrorists at its May 18 meeting. >
Plans to move Strike Corps I at Northern Command by June 3; Corps
II moves between Suratgarh and Punjab; Corps XXI from Barmer to Rann
of Kutch. > Contingency plans firmed
up by May 27 for second-strike against Pakistan's nuke attack.
A
Backed by IAF jets, Stirke Corps 1 to launch attack from Akhnoor-Pathankot
secotr.
B Simultaneous division-level
hits in Kargil, Uri and Rajouri.
C Strike Corps II and XXI to
engage the Pakistani counter-offensive from Multan-based Army Reserve
South and target Pakistani economic assets in Singh if needed.
INDIA'S OFFENSIVE
PAKISTAN'S COUNTER
THE US FACTOR
>
Synergised attack by the Northern Command to split Pakistan's Army
Reserve North and provide an opening in PoK. > The Indian Navy fleet led
by aircraft carrier INS Viraat to engage Pakistani warships and target
economic assets. Karachi harbour to be blockaded if Pakistan launches
a war.
>
To block Indian thrust in PoK, launch counter-offensive in Punjab
and Rajasthan. > Cause maximum attrition in
the Indian forces and wait for monsoon stalemate. > Use Agosta submarines to
delay the Indian flotilla.
>
A full-scale India-Pakistan conflict could hamper the US operations
against bin Laden's Al-Qaida terrorists in Afghanistan. > The US told India it was
putting pressure on Musharraf to permanently end cross-border infiltration
in Kashmir. > War could damage the growing
Indo-US cooperation in nuclear energy, space, hi-tech equipment and
defence.
THE NUCLEAR FACTOR
WHY THE STRIKE
WAS CALLED OFF
>
The US conveyed to India it was unsure about Pakistani
nuclear threshold, particularly after Musharraf and his UN representative
Munir Akram threatened to use nukes against India. > India began exploring its
second-strike options after Pakistan tested
N-capable Ghauri missile on May 25. > Intelligence reports indicated
that Pakistan had mobilised strategic
assets post-Kaluchak. Despite Indian military's assurance, the nuke
threat bothered Delhi.
>
Musharraf's May 27 speech assuring nothing was happening on the LoC;
infiltration dipped to a new low in May and June. > A big complication was the
oncoming monsoons that could bog down the forces. > US Deputy Secretary of State
Richard Armitage assured India on June 6 that Musharraf would end
infiltration in Kashmir and dismantle terrorist infrastructure in
PoK. > Nuclear blackmail by Musharraf
raised Indian fears that in case of war, the global community would
intervene in Kashmir.
June 10, 2002 Second Shot
The readiness strategy paid off when Pakistan's terrorist groups struck
again on May 14. Storming into the army residential quarters at Kaluchak
cantonment in Jammu, they killed 22 women and children. Even before the
killings, India had accused Pakistan of failing to keep its promise on
ending cross-border terrorism. A day after the massacre, a visibly tense
Vajpayee told Parliament, "Hamein pratikar karna hoga (We will have
to counter it)." On May 18, Vajpayee, along with Fernandes, was briefed
on military preparedness by Director-General Military Operations Lt-General
S.S. Chahal and Military Intelligence Chief Lt-General O.S. Lochab. Later,
after a two-hour meeting, the ccs favoured military action against terrorists
in Pakistan.
Vajpayee (above) in Kupwara warned of the impending
battle even as Musharraf (below, centre) played on the world's nuclear
fears
The political leadership apparently wanted limited action similar to
the one in January. But after evaluating various military options, it
was decided that action in PoK was not viable as Pakistan had beefed up
its forces across the loc. Any action limited to forays across the loc
would translate into minimum military gains and would risk attrition in
the Indian forces. The military, however, favoured an all-out offensive
that would stretch Pakistani troops across the international borders and
give India an opening in PoK. So the armed forces came up with a daring
plan: destroy Pakistan's war-waging potential and pulverise the terror
factories in PoK. The June canvas was bigger than the January one, since
Pakistan had packed areas north of Chenab with forces and military logic
dictated the battle should not be confined to the loc. But there were
serious limitations to the plans that worried the political bosses. With
the monsoons imminent, the armed forces warned that the window for attack
was extremely narrow. Any miscalculation could see the offensive bogged
down with disastrous consequences.
Even as the debate raged, the military made its plans. The launch of
the offensive was entrusted to Strike Corps I led by Lt-General J.J. Singh,
who had directed military operations in Kargil war. The IAF, along with
Strike Corps I, would initiate action in the Shakargarh bulge and engage
Pakistan's Army Reserve North (ARN) spread from Muzaffarabad in PoK to
the Shekhopura-Lahore area. The idea was to lock Pakistan's key strike
corp in battle that was essentially a boxer's feint. The real offensive
would be in PoK by strike formations moved in from the east and tasked
to capture strategic points used by Pakistan to push in terrorists (see
graphic).
The period considered for limited strikes was between May 23 and June
10. On May 22, at Kupwara brigade headquarters near the loc Vajpayee declared
that "it was time for a decisive battle". A day later, the CCS
met to assess the readiness of the country's key sectors in the event
of a war. An economic review was also undertaken: Sinha said India's economy
was a hundred times stronger than Pakistan's to bear hostilities, and
RBI Governor Bimal Jalan pointed to a low inflation rate of 1.56 per cent
and all-time high forex reserves of $55 billion (Rs 2,64,000 crore) to
tide over the crisis. The crude oil and petroleum stock reserves, which
should sustain the country for more than a month in a war, were also sufficient.
With the CCS endorsing a strike, Vajpayee wrote to Bush, Blair, Russian
President Vladimir Putin and French President Jacques Chirac, saying Musharraf
had failed to deliver on his January 12 speech and that India's patience
was running out. Hectic diplomacy followed as Bush, Putin, Blair and even
Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi called and pleaded with Vajpayee
not to take the extreme step. The global community conveyed to Delhi that
it would impress on Musharraf to clarify his promise on stopping cross-border
infiltration.
That June was an option considered seriously by the Vajpayee Government
is borne out by the Defence Ministry's SOS for defence supplies to Israel
during the month. But the global community urged restraint as it was worried
Pakistan would use the nuclear card to address its conventional asymmetry
against the Indian armed forces. Musharraf had already played the nuclear
brinkmanship-hinting he would use nukes against India-in an interview
to German magazine Der Spiegel in April. Pakistan had even tested three
missiles-Ghauri (N-capable), Ghaznavi and Abdali-between May 25 and 28
as a deterrent to India's posture.
The war committee, including Fernandes, Vajpayee and
Advani, wanted action in May but coercive diplomacy prevailed
This belligerence forced India to review its N-capability to strike back-Atomic
Energy Commission (AEC) Chairman Anil Kakodkar and Defence Research and
Development Organisation Secretary V.K. Aatre reportedly participated
in a CCS meeting in late May. In the absence of any formalised strategic
force command, the nuclear strategy was handled on a need-to-know basis
by Mishra, who reportedly attended an AEC meeting on May 24 in Chennai
and later flew to Manali to brief Vajpayee.
Pakistan's nuclear theatrics also led to Powell calling Musharraf five
times in the last week of May and reading the riot act to him. Bush sent
Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage to Pakistan on June 5. He apparently
asked Musharraf three times whether he would "permanently" end
cross-border infiltration and help dismantle the terrorist infrastructure.
He conveyed Musharraf's commitment to Powell while flying to Delhi on
June 6, and to India, on arriving. On June 10, Powell disclosed Musharraf's
promise to the world, by which time India had already called off its strike
plans. The political logic was understandable as a full-frontal attack
would translate into war. It was better to give Musharraf another chance.
Or perhaps, the build-up was a shrewd ploy by India, not only in June
but also in January, to force Pakistan as well as the world community
into action.
Last week, Fernandes denied (to India Today) that India had been on
the brink of war, claiming that at no point had the ccs given directions
to the armed forces to take action against Pakistan. He, however, did
not put it beyond the army generals to prepare for contingency plans.
Mishra, on the other hand, reiterated that India had indeed been "close
to war" in January and May. While refusing to disclose dates, he
pointed out that on June 23, Vajpayee had said in an interview to the
Washington Post that it was a "touch and go affair".
The Tiger Squadron, on its part, did have its share of action. On August
2, four Mirage fighters evicted Pakistani intruders 800 m across the loc
in Machhil sector of Kashmir. In Washington, it was dubbed Kargil II.
The Tigers know that given the murky Indo-Pak relations, all it will take
is another carnage for them to be back in air, in action.