As
clubbers fall in rhythm with the beats of electronic music, bands
like Midival Punditz find takers worldwide.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The pathetic condition of roads
in Madhya Pradesh acts a severe bottleneck to its progress. India Today's
Neeraj Mishra takes a drive and to find out exactly how bad they are. BUMPY
RIDE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE DECEMBER 23, 2002
LIVING: WOMEN
AND SUICIDE
Young Affluent and Depressed
Small-town sexual mores undergo a subtle shift
as housewives and girls trade bodies for favours and fun
by Shefalee VASUDEV
For some tragic reason, this has been a year of
suicides among young, successful, urban women. On December 10 when the
2002 Gladrags Megamodel winner Rakhee Choudhari was found dead in her
Mumbai apartment, she added yet another number to a growing list of depressed
young women who had everything to live for and yet chose death. Barely
two months ago, 18-year-old Delhi-based singer Saumya Sharma had jumped
to death from the 22nd floor of a building. Earlier this year, Delhi socialite
Natasha Singh, her sister-in-law, model Ritu Singh, former Lok Sabha speaker
Shivraj Patil's daughter Sapna Patil and 21-year-old Tamil actress Monal
all committed suicide within a span of two months. The common elements
in these cases are too obvious to ignore. All were young, affluent and
had a lot going for them in life. Yet, all suffered from bouts of depression,
eventually leading to their premature deaths. Depression is the biggest
underlying cause behind the extreme step of suicide; according to mental
health professionals, there are five depressed women for every one such
man in affluent sections of the society.
Lack of strong emotional
support makes you NG, successful women prime candidates for Suicide
Young, ambitious, well-to-do women are becoming prime candidates for
depression, suggest clinics of urban psychotherapists. As many cases indicate,
lack of consistent emotional support is the primary cause. Patil feels
that his daughter's suicide could have been averted if his wife had been
alive. "I am not close to my children," he confesses. "In
our family, we never spoke to our father. Everything was conveyed through
my mother." Similarly, one of the causes behind Choudhari's suicide
was debatedly her inability to cope with her parents' divorce.
Traditionally, depression has been linked with women. But as the role
of women changed, depression began to affect the younger 15-44 age group.
"The gap between aspiration and reality is very prominent in women
as compared with men. This leads to constant turmoil," says Dr Nimesh
Desai, medical superintendent at Delhi's Institute of Human Behaviour
and Allied Sciences. Across the world, the male-female depression ratio
is 1:2 and in some societies, 1:3. Recent studies suggest that now depression
strikes early in life and that young women are at maximum risk.
Not surprisingly, what was once loosely termed as melancholia in mental
health and is now labelled clinical depression, has become a hot topic
of research. In fact, warns the World Health Organisation (who), depression
will become the biggest killer disease of women in the coming decade.
For every suicide, there are 20 others who attempt it and 40 more who
contemplate it. A World Mental Health report published last year found
that unipolar depressive disorder (consistent, long-term sadness) was
the largest malady afflicting women between 15 and 44, disabling 18.6
per cent globally. This toll is higher than that for heart disease and
of breast/cervical cancers.
These are not exaggerated claims. Social and behavioural barometers
support them. Young, affluent Indian women are paying the price for "being
there, doing that". They haven't had to brave hardship, hunger, domestic
violence or dowry threats. On the contrary, they fit a profile: they are
bold, smart, fun-loving, even prodigal. Also, dominating, calculating
and ruthlessly ambitious. What they want, they often get. But these things-designer
lingerie, expensive perfumes, sleek cars and top jobs-don't offer the
solace that a close-knit family bonding did in the past. Experts feel
that busy parents who nurture by remote control contribute to this state.
In some families, fathers are absent over long periods chasing their money-oriented
dreams, while mothers are straddling, often unsuccessfully, the gigantic
gap between the modern and the conservative.
DEPRESSION
SYMPTOMS
Mothers are still straddling
the gap between the modern and the conservative.
Helplessness
Fatigue Low appetite Changes in weight
Altered sleep
pattern Heightened agitation
Lack of concentration Social withdrawal Diminished sex
drive Worthlessness
or guilt Suicidal thoughts
The traditional symbols of ultimate accomplishment-name and fame or husbands,
diamonds and servants-are obviously not the antidotes for the pressures
of an affluent life. "There is a lot of pressure on the youth, more
so on women, to prove that despite odds they are high achievers,"
says Dr Jitendra Nagpal of Delhi's Vidyasagar Institute of Mental Health
and Neurosciences. Instant kicks, instant highs, instant fame and an almost
blind race to get rich and famous tempt girls more than boys. But they
are not able to shed the traditional roles of "nurturers" on
the one hand and wanting to be "looked after" on the other.
Naturally, there is a conflict.
Take Choudhari. This 23-year-old had already made her place in the modelling
world. She had also stood fourth in the Miss International contest in
Germany and was looking forward to going to Malaysia on December 20 for
another beauty pageant. "She had a great future going for her,"
commented Maureen Wadia, managing editor of Gladrags.
That women in glamorous professions are prone to depression is catching
attention. Fashion photographer Rony Kaula, who works in Delhi and Mumbai,
says the claustrophobic and insensitive attitude of the glamour world
is like a noose around the necks of the aspirants. "Girls base their
emotional and social security on their shortlived careers, unlike men
who invest in a number of back-up plans," says Kaula.
SUICIDE
STREET Driven
to Death
Few realities are as chillingly compelling and as morbidly intriguing
as suicide. This ultimate desperation undermines, overwhelms, outwits
and devastates not just the people who commit it but also the people
who are left behind. "The cause is essentially social,"
said French sociologist Emile Durkheim in his 1897 seminal analysis
of suicide. Worldwide, most psychiatrists accept Durkheim's hypothesis
that pressures of modern living, and not just a person's genetic
predisposition, are behind the dramatic rise in suicides.
In India, for every person who commits suicide, there are 20 others
who attempt it and 35 who contemplated killing themselves. The National
Crime Records Bureau logs the country's suicide rate at 10 in every
one lakh, of which at least five are women.
In the past decade, a number of young and talented women, who
were also dominating, aspiring and excellent communicators, have
taken their own lives. They were all believed to have been gregarious
women who "loved life". The most recent case of Rakhee
Choudhari follows this script. "I believe in living life to
the fullest and am not afraid of treading on the wild side,"
she had said in the final round of the 2002 Megamodel contest which
won her the crown. But truth and perception are widely at odds as
this list indicates.
1993:
Nineteen-year-old Telugu and Hindi film actress Divya Bharati, who
won the 1992 Filmfare Award for best newcomer, fell from the window
of her fifth floor apartment in Mumbai. Investigations indicated
suicide.
1996:
Silk Smitha, 33, the Tamil film dancer, was found dead in a Mumbai
apartment. Her suicide note indicated disillusionment in love.
1999:
The body of Kolkata dancer Ranjabati Sircar, 36, was found hanging
in a room in a friend's house in Mumbai. Sircar, who had had an
unsuccessful marriage and had lost her mother, renowned Kathak dancer
Manjushree Chaki-Sircar, to cancer, suffered from depression.
2000:
Anju Ilyasi, 30, wife of TV producer Suhaib Ilyasi, died due to
stab wounds. Despite speculation, the post-mortem reports confirmed
suicide. Anju's personal diary, discovered by the police after her
death, revealed she had gone through several phases of acute depression.
2000:
Viji, 27, Kannada actress, hanged herself. Her suicide note blamed
a failed love affair with A.R. Ramesh, director of Tamil film Independence
Day, for her death.
March 2002:
Thirty-one-year-old model and socialite Natasha Singh, mother of
two, jumped to death from Delhi's Hyatt Regency Hotel. Singh had
earlier talked of a difficult marriage, an abusive husband, a messy
divorce and a painful custody case. Speculation about a terminal
illness could also have been a cause of depression.
April 2002:
Tamil cinema actress Monal, 21, ended her life by hanging herself.
She allegedly had a relationship with choreographer Prasanna that
met with strong disapproval from her family.
May 2002:
Thirty-five-year-old Sapna Patil, daughter of former Lok Sabha Speaker
Shivraj Patil and mother of two, killed herself by hanging. She
was depressed over post-natal complications of her newborn son.
She had also suffered from depression in the past.
May 2002:
Ritu Singh, 31, model, socialite and daughter of MP Natwar Singh,
hanged herself from a cupboard. Singh was reportedly a victim of
depression and was addicted to certain anti-depressant drugs.
October
2002: Saumya Sharma, Eighteen-year-old Delhi student, singer
and aspiring actor jumped to death from the 22nd floor of the building
she lived in. Sharma who had become quiet and preoccupied some months
before her death had consumed alcohol before killing herself.
December 2002: The 23-year-old Rakhee Choudhari, Gladrags
Megamodel 2002, hanged herself from a ceiling fan in her Mumbai apartment.
Choudhari was reportedly depressed over her parents' recent divorce.
Speculations that she was upset due to a medical problem and had been
gaining weight as a result are also doing the rounds as one of the
reasons behind her suicide.
Delhi-based model Amrita Nurie, 24, who has featured in the Hercules
jeans and Neva innerwear ads, would agree. "One-and-a-half inch more
on my waist gives me sleepless nights," says the 5 ft 6 in tall Nurie
who weighs only 48 kg. Similarly, Deepti Gujral, 29, who left her home
in Delhi to work as a hospitality executive in Mumbai, became seriously
depressed and was given to frequent bouts of crying because she suffered
from anorexia. Anorexia nervosa, the eating disorder that makes people
go off food, is a manifestation of an anxious mind and primarily a woman's
problem.
Women don't feel comfortable when they abuse power or manipulate relationships
for advancing their careers because they have been taught it is not "good".
But they still do it. "Upon introspection, they begin doubting their
own capabilities and often end up feeling ashamed," explains Nagpal.
Girls are also more vulnerable to vagaries of mood. So those who are
in love with love and confuse it with the loyalty of one man, often feel
let down. The buxom Malayalam film sex symbol Shakeela attempted suicide
in her early 20s because the man she was in love with did not marry her.
"Among women depression is often due to relationships issues, unlike
men for whom financial conditions or loss of social status is the reason,"
says psychiatrist Sudhir Khandelwal of aiims, Delhi.
Girls are mostly brought up in a protected and pampered environment
and then suddenly thrust into a world of fierce competition that emphasises
materialism. The office or the ramp and the real harsh world are very
different, each with varying expectations. Girls feel pressurised to outperform
themselves as well as the boys all the time which leads to an early cracking
up. Many also feel that the urge of young people to be noticed as bold
and beautiful is fed by the growing Page Three culture. Mumbai psychiatrist
Dr Harish Shetty believes that the voyeuristic media that follows glamorous
women to their bedrooms is also to be blamed.
Moreover, peer pressure controls behaviour at this age-if you don't
drink or sniff coke you are not with it, say friends. But girls who do
so are usually shunned by their parents. Often, urban, independent girls
choose the "liberated lifestyle", living away from home, triggering
off another set of pressures.
The ambition to be rich, affluent and hence powerful also creates in
girls a "need to belong", some of whom find an upper class kitty
party circle fascinating. But this too is a mirage. "I belonged to
the elite club of lunching divas, where decimating people during power
lunches was a favourite sport," says Bindu Dalmia, wife of a successful
industrialist. "But this power is that of a social parasite. Young
people need lessons in inverse snobbery, otherwise they will keep choosing
between instant wealth and instant death."
Neurologists find that while psycho-social stressors are the biggest
factors of depression, it could also be a result of neurological changes
in the brain (see box). Genetic and biological factors also play a role.
Anxious moods initiate a cascade of adverse changes in endocrine and
immune functioning, creating a susceptibility to physical illnesses. Studies
report that women, despite being bigger victims of minor aches and pains,
show only 50 per cent adherence to medical advice. "The stigma attached
to psychological conditions makes them shy away from taking timely clinical
help," says Desai.
Nagpal feels women should be realistic when they interpret relationships
and their roles in today's society while Dalmia believes that the young
need idealistic and socialist role models and not MTV icons to hitch their
dreams to. Natasha, Rakhee and the others are only a reminder for the
Indian woman that her leap into a life of emotional, financial and sexual
freedom could come at a harsh price.