As
clubbers fall in rhythm with the beats of electronic music, bands
like Midival Punditz find takers worldwide.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The pathetic condition of roads
in Madhya Pradesh acts a severe bottleneck to its progress. India Today's
Neeraj Mishra takes a drive and to find out exactly how bad they are. BUMPY
RIDE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE DECEMBER 23, 2002
SOCIETY AND
TRENDS: WINE CULTURE
Grape Growth
Foreign winemakers deluge the upper crust with
a range of products. But will the market grow?
By Kaveree Bamzai
Thursday, 7.30 p.m. It's a busy day for Wine India
Inc. At Delhi's spiffy Imperial Hotel, guests sip Beaujolais Nouveau,
the first wine of the harvest from Albert Bichot, one of the top wine
houses in Burgundy, France. At the Taj Mahal Hotel, another group raises
a toast with Beaujolais Nouveau from wine merchant Georges Duboeuf, while
an equally fortunate lot of beginners and connoisseurs says "Sante"
with a Duboeuf at The Oberoi.
VINTAGE INDIA: Francoise Bichot with her company's
export director Ariff Jamal
In well-heeled, metropolitan India, wine dinners have become the hottest
events of the social season. Convivial evenings, where names like finicky
wine critic Robert Parker and legendary Napa Valley winemaker Robert Mondavi
are dropped with deliberate carelessness, are now becoming de rigueur.
So is conversation that borders on the RISQUE: a Cabernet Sauvignon is
described as having "legs", while a Shiraz is approvingly called
"full-bodied". And if you want to justify drinking a cheap Chianti,
you can, especially if you are a man, say it is "young and sexy".
The guest list often reads like a must-have social register: pedigreed
royals (from Richard Holkar of Indore to Jyotiraditya Scindia of Gwalior);
captains of industry like Dhruv Sawhney of Triveni Engineering and Anand
Mahindra of Mahindra & Mahindra; food and wine journalists (a well-fed
but very competitive breed) and arbiters of social elegance such as Shobhaa
De and Sabira Merchant.
CHATEAU CHIC: Thienpont (right) of Vieux Chateau
Certan
In the past 15 months, Aman Dhall, one of the largest wine importers
in the country, has organised 56 dinners. Sanjay Menon, an equally large
importer, has arranged 97 in the past three years. That's not all. From
the days when serving a vin de table (got from your local bootlegger for
Rs 200) was a badge of honour to now when home-grown epicures can distinguish
between a Riesling and a Sauvignon Blanc, upper crust India has travelled
a long way on the wine route. Whether it is a wine and cheese opening
of a store, the gift of a Chateau Latour during Diwali or even a mid-market
Orvieto as an accompaniment to kebabs and curries, wine is becoming more
visible and also, socially, a chic alternative to spirits.
So much so that it is spawning societies to promote wine culture: Bangalore
has an informal wine society anchored by biotechnologist Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw
as well as a wine club started last year by wine consultant Alok Chandra.
Delhi also has two: the Delhi Wine Society, the first in the country,
was started by travel consultant Ghulam Naqshband in 1996, while the Delhi
Wine Club was registered in March by it entrepreneur Subhash Arora. Even
Chandigarh wants one-a group of wine lovers has invited Arora to set up
a club there-while Nagpur has already acquired one, with help from Chandra.
For winemakers, patience is a virtue. We'll wait for
our turn. Alexandre Thienpont, French winemaker
Yet the incipient wine culture in India is not only about knowing which
collector has the to-die-for Sori San Lorenzo, awarded 100 points by Parker.
Or about dropping the name of Emile Peynaud, the world's finest oenologist
from the University of Bordeaux. Or even knowing how many wines writer
Hugh Johnson tastes in a year-10,000, if you must know. Ultimately it
is about hardheaded business as winemakers discover India, the last frontier.
WINE TASTER
WHY IS IT EXPENSIVE?
The import duties vary from 220 per cent to 265 per cent.
So even a $2 Cuvee Giraud can cost Rs 350 in a retail outlet.
IS Customs clearance easy?
No way. There are 23 formalities between the wine docking in the
country and reaching the retail outlet.
IS WHISKY MORE ECONOMICAL?
Most certainly. A bottle of wine yields five glasses at Rs 100 each,
a whisky bottle yields 12 pegs at Rs 40 each. But wine isn't just
alcohol. It indicates a sophisticated drinking repertoire and suggests
a chic lifestyle.
CAN WE HAVE WINE BARS?
Not very likely. A licence to serve alcohol costs Rs 5 lakh a year.
The bar needs to make Rs 3,000 a day to break even.
Or shall we say the lost frontier? As Jean-Guillame Prats, the 31-year-old
English-speaking French chairman of Bordeaux's Chateau Cos d'Estournel,
put it at a wine-tasting in Delhi: "Beginning with Louis-Gaspard
d'Estournel in the early 19th century, 90 per cent of the wine made at
the chateau was sold to India's nobility." It's a habit-like the
purchase of Louis Vuitton luggage by India's maharajas-that we hope to
revive among an estimated 2,00,000 upper middle-class consumers in India.
Despite the duties on wine rising to 265 per cent even though quantitative
restrictions were lifted in April 2001, winemakers are looking at India
as the new Japan, or at least China. While the appetite for wine took
off in 1993 among Japan's eight million consumers with an annual disposable
income of at least $20,000 (Rs 9.6 lakh) after reports about the cardiovascular
advantages of red wine (the so-called French paradox), in China, a cognac-drinking
habit and lower duties have led to a rise in wine consumption. As Carlos
Soriano, the international business development head of Miguel Torres,
an international wine house, says, "We had no presence in Japan 15
years ago. Now we sell 60,000 cases (of 12 bottles each). In China, which
is as big and heterogeneous as India, without its English-speaking advantage,
we sell a little over 5,000 cases." In India, he says he'll be lucky
if he sells 2,000 cases this year after eight years of investment.
The figures are quite dispiriting. Only 70,000 cases of foreign wines
are sold in India while the tiny nation of Maldives buys 4,00,000 cases
a year. Albert Bichot's export director Ariff Jamal gives another comparison:
his company sells 3,000 cases in India every year while in Sri Lanka it
sells 30,000 cases. It doesn't help that India is traditionally a whisky-drinking
market-of the 73 million cases of spirits sold in the domestic market,
50 per cent is whisky which costs less than Rs 200 a bottle. Wine suffers
in comparison: a glass of a Rs 500 table wine costs Rs 100 while a peg
of Royal Challenge costs Rs 40.
HOPE FERMENTS: Soriano (left) of Miguel Torres
has been doing business in India for eight years
Yet foreign winemakers persevere because they have to. For France, exports
sustain the industry (last year, wines and spirits made for 83 per cent
of the country's agricultural exports). For the New World, it's the only
way to offset tiny domestic markets (Australia exports more wine now than
it produced 10 years ago). Which is why the visitors' book of Destination
Wine India is brimming with names. In the past two months alone, Mumbai,
Delhi and Bangalore have seen a series of visits by representatives from
celebrated wineries-Rupert & Rothschild, a partnership between the
sons of the reclusive South African baron Anton Rupert and the late Baron
Edmond de Rothschild of France; Kendall-Jackson, California's most-awarded
winery; the wine label Henri Bourgeois which sells some fine Sancerres
and Poilly-Fumes; Vieux Chateau Certan, a Bordeaux family which has been
making wines since 1842; Chateau Cos d'Estournel; Miguel Torres, a Spanish
vineyard whose eponymous owner has been named Decanter's winemaker of
2002; and Albert Bichot. For all of them, investment in India is a tiny
speck in the vineyard: for instance, the net worth of the privately owned
Kendall-Jackson is $400 million. The amount most winemakers spend on one
visit, including a wine dinner, is $6,000-8,000.
Ultimately, even if the wines are good, as at Indigo, the trendy Asian-European
restaurant in Mumbai, they're just too expensive-one of the reasons why
its owner Rahul Akerkar has dropped the prices on his wine list by 25
per cent over last year. The prices are simply a function of ferociously
high duties and complicated import conditions. Thanks to that, an Indian
restaurant will price a bottle of an entry level wine like Sito Moresco
from the fourth generation Piedmont winery Gaja at $100 while it will
be available at an Italian supermarket for $18-20. In five-star hotels,
the mark-up is higher. A Santa Christina, an Antinori (made by an old
Florentine wine family), that costs $8 in a supermarket is $30 in a five-star
restaurant.
If duties aren't lowered, there will be no free dinners
in 2003. Amrit Kiran Singh, director, Brown-Forman
For those who have acquired a taste for drinking free wine, Amrit Kiran
Singh, director of Brown-Forman, which produces Fetzer, George W. Bush
Jr's favourite wine, sounds a warning, "If the Government doesn't
reduce duties on wine, there won't be any free dinners in 2003. These
dinners happened in the past two years only because the wine houses had
sent cases to India in anticipation of lower duties after April 2001.
When that didn't happen, they were forced to pass them on to the distributors
on a pay-as-able basis.''
The still-evolving wine culture can have its comic moments. Like the
time a journalist went prepared to meet the Chilean minister of wines
but found himself discussing his favourite Chardonnay Curico Valley from
Montes with the minister of mines. Or even when a city supplement identified
two unfortunate guests at an E&J Gallo dinner as Mr Ernest Gallo and
Ms Julio Gallo (unmindful of the fact that the latter was a man who is
no longer alive).
As winemakers initiate upper middle-class India into the correct wine
manner, they hope when duties are lowered, they will be right there to
take advantage. And maybe the next time Akerkar goes to his bank to ask
for an overdraft of Rs 30 lakh because he wants to augment his 4,000-bottle
cellar, they will not choke on their chai.