As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
As the BJP gets revived in Madhya
Pradesh and Chhattisgarh, the Congress knows it has more than a fight on
hand in the coming assembly polls. India Today's Neeraj Mishra anayses
the party's shaky position in the two states. ROUGH
RIDE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE FEBRUARY 10, 2003
SOCIETY AND TRENDS: SEXUAL HARASSMENT
Indecent Proposals
With gender crimes becoming a serious menace in
universities across the country, the campus is no longer what it used
to be-safe
By Shefalee Vasudev
For most
students entering university, the only physical threat was over-the-top
ragging by seniors. Not any more. The campus is a dangerous place. Seema
Sharma, a student of J.V. Jain College in Saharanpur, was allegedly raped
during a college tour to Mussoorie. She later succumbed to her injuries.
A Delhi University (DU) student was reportedly gangraped in a moving vehicle.
Complaints of sexual harassment have been registered against the director
of the National Law Institute (NLI) in Bhopal. A college principal in
Indore and a former director-general of the Tripura Police are facing
similar charges. Over 300 students of Patiala's Government College of
Physical Education (GCPE) have been holding protest rallies, demanding
action against those guilty of sexual harassment. These are only a few
instances of gender crimes that have surfaced in the media recently. Yet
none of them have been legally put to ground or the guilty convicted.
Following a furore over the gangrape of a student of the Maulana Azad
Medical College, Delhi, former Union law minister Jana Krishnamurthy announced
a new law last week for speedy disposal of sexual harassment cases in
special courts. The Sexual Offences (Special Courts) Bill, 2003, is likely
to be tabled in the budget session of Parliament. But that is cold comfort
to millions of girls studying in universities across the country. Most
often the offenders are those entrusted with the task of providing them
the proverbial guidance. Like NLI Director V.S. Rekhi, who took perverse
pleasure in calling girl students to his office, cracking vulgar jokes
or asking them sexually suggestive questions. Or Professor Nasser of the
Tamil Nadu Dental College, Chennai, who would lace his comments with sexual
innuendos in and outside the classroom. Or a former director-general of
police who took to asking a decoy woman constable in Delhi, "What
is your rate?"
Rajni Thakur, a 24-year-old second-year student of GCPE opened a Pandora's
box when she accused her judo coach Kulraj Singh Gill of making overtures
to her. "I decided to fight back as it became too much to handle,"
she says. Thakur blew the whistle in December 2002 after being denied
permission by the college authorities to participate in an inter-state
judo competition. The college authorities set up a committee to look into
the case but Thakur refused to appear before it. "The committee was
an eyewash because it included teachers close to the accused," she
says. Subsequently, a high-level committee set up by the Director of Public
Instructions (colleges) recommended suspension of Gill and Kulwant Kaur,
another teacher who had allegedly been cooperating with Gill. Reiterating
Thakur's allegations, 60-odd girl students complained of harassment by
teachers saying they were often asked to exchange modesty for marks. "The
discretion of marks in the internal assessment is used as a bait for sexual
exploitation," says Surinder Kaur Grewal, chairperson, Punjab Women's
Commission.
Sexual harassment ranges from making vulgar comments or physical advances,
displaying pornographic material to stalking and, in extreme cases, rape.
These are overtures most girls have to contend with virtually every day.
"Most of us have been approached by men who offer us money to go
out with them," says Priyani Roychoudhury, a final-year student of
Delhi's Miranda House. No wonder then that a passing mention of gender
crimes can reveal a painful immediacy for redressal. A report by the Gender
Study Group of DU some years ago reported that 91.7 per cent of the girls
living in hostels had been harassed at sometime or the other. In Jawaharlal
Nehru University (JNU), Delhi, 45 cases were recorded in the past three
years. "It is very rampant in the colleges of Uttar Pradesh as well,"
says Professor Surendra Nischal of J.V. Jain College. Or Tamil Nadu. Punjab.
Madhya Pradesh.
A four-month study on patterns of sexual harassment conducted by the
Delhi Police (north district) during their special drive in 2002 reveals
that most offenders are in the age group of 31 to 40 years (see box).
"Good education and sound family background do not work as deterrents,"
says Sanjay Beniwal, DCP (north), Delhi Police.
CLEAN CAMPUS DRIVE
Universities should have clear policies to combat sexual harassment
in accordance with the apex court's 1997 Vishaka guidelines. Counselling/interim
panels must be gender neutral. Boys must be empowered to lodge complaints. Universities
and the police should work in tandem to put redressal mechanisms in
place. Campuses should
be well-lit, have traffic regulations, more PCOs and complaint boxes. Private hostels
and paying-guest accommodations should be under the purview of a university.
But the quirky equations of power do not limit sexual harassment to students.
Late last year, senior lecturers Poonam Bhatnagar and Mayarani Jain of
the premier Holkar College, Indore, filed a complaint of sexual harassment
against Principal Narendra Dhakkad. Similarly, Anita Tamarkar, a 38-year-old
lecturer in the department of physical education at Guru Nanak Dev University,
Amritsar, accused her PhD guide, Kanwaljit Singh.
Eight years ago, the Supreme Court made it mandatory for all institutions
to have committees to address the problem of sexual harassment. Yet there
are no combative mechanisms in place, barring one in JNU. The Delhi-based
Forum Against Sexual Harassment (FASH) presented a draft policy to the
DU authorities in 1998. "But a formal report on it was submitted
only in July 2002," says Janaki Abraham, a lecturer and member of
FASH. In the meantime, dharnas and street plays organised by DU students
have resulted in interim committees being set up and pamphlets and posters
being circulated. But elsewhere, there still is no policy on gender crimes.
University authorities are yet to be sensitised to the need for such
a policy. Some of them even oppose the word "sexual" in sexual
harassment for moral reasons. But Diksha Gupta, a Miranda House student
and president of DU's Women's Development Cell, says, "Labelling
the issue as eve-teasing undermines the gravity." Concurs Suman Bisht,
a PhD student and member of FASH: "Sexual harassment needs full-time
attention." Shyam Menon, proctor, DU, says ever since the university
joined hands with the police, there have been progressive results. Beniwal
is also planning to post plainclothes police personnel on the University
Special buses.
What also needs redressal is the way complaints are registered. Reporting
a sexual crime gets complicated because of the possible effect on academic
results if the offender is a professor. Take Saru Rana's case. As a post-graduate
student of Punjabi University in Patiala, this gritty girl took up cudgels
against the vice-chancellor, Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia, who allegedly asked
students to serve guests at his residence. The head of her department,
Saroj Rani, and other teachers reportedly turned hostile when she refused
to keep quiet about it. After her written complaint, Ahluwalia summoned
Rana to his office, where he allegedly tried to molest her. It was the
Amarinder Singh Government which promptly sacked Ahluwalia in April 2002
after an fir was lodged against him. "I am the victim of a politically
motivated frame-up," says Ahluwalia, one-time close confidante of
Parkash Singh Badal, former chief minister of Punjab. Rana, who has been
given security cover by the Punjab Police, will now appear as a private
candidate for her second-year examinations. She was declared "failed"
last year.
TRACKING THE OFFENDER
383 Total number of offenders studied. 92 were graduates,
5 post-graduates, 71 had studied up to Class XII, only 24 were illiterate. 286 passed verbal
comments, 69 made lewd gestures. 200 said the
reason was the girl's looks, 10 said it was dress sense.
129 stalked on scooters.
Despite the fact that the reporting of sexual harassment cases has gone
up tremendously in the past decade, action is iffy if the offenders are
university staff. And authorities even try to cover up such crimes. "The
principal of J.V. Jain College forced the two teachers, who accompanied
the students to Mussoorie, to give false statements," alleges Nischal.
So far, neither has an fir been registered nor has the post-mortem report
been made public. The Madhya Pradesh Government did not concur with the
state Women's Commission, which along with the Human Rights Commission
had validated the complaint against Rekhi. Holkar College Principal Dhakkad
also got away scot-free. Students allege that complaints against him to
senior officials of the state's Education Department fell on deaf ears
because of his contacts in the administrative and political circles. Meanwhile,
the two complainants-Bhatnagar and Jain-have been transferred out of Indore.
"We were asked to withdraw the cases by whoever we met in the Government,"
they say.
In Tamarkar's case, the Punjab and Haryana High Court took a suo moto
notice of her complaint and Kanwaljit Singh was relieved of his charge
as director (sports) even before the first court hearing. But Tamarkar
says that instead of words of encouragement, she is getting jeers. Amritsar-based
veteran social activist Satyapal Dang believes that the powerful teacher's
union in Amritsar University has prevented "punitive action"
based on Tamarkar's complaint.
There is an additional problem that has surfaced recently-homosexual
harassment in the hostels. "In our meetings, many boys have spoken
about the problem," says Abraham. "Male authority over younger
men also is being exercised through sexual violence," says Radhika
Chopra, a DU reader who has been researching and writing on sexual harassment
for more than a decade. While more girls feel empowered to report against
sexual crimes, adds Chopra, few boys have the nerve to do the same. That's
another iceberg the police, law officials and the civil society have to
contend with to make life on the campus freer, enjoyable, more meaningful
and academically nurturing. The way it is meant to be.
-with Ramesh Vinayak, Neeraj Mishra
and Kavitha Muralidharan