|  HOME      

  IN THIS ISSUE

SEE COVER IMAGE

COVER STORY


Ratan Tata

 
OTHER STORIES


Spy Mission
Party Poopers
Laloo on Trial
Can he make us rich?
Terror's Mask
Hostile Mentor
Soul Curry
Cricket in Chaos
Flying Start
Trunk Call
Show Business
Dissenting Motif
Ram Unbound

 
 
METRO TODAY

Diary of Events

 

As land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.

 

 
WEB ONLY FEATURES
The VHP's grand foray into Tamil Nadu begins with more just rhetoric. The huge following it has already managed to build up shows that it is well on its way to striking deeper roots, writes India Today's Arun Ram.
SOUTHERN SAFFRON
 
INDIA TODAY CONCLAVE

The Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights.
Take me to Conclave now
 
CARE TODAY
 
INDIA TODAY HINDI
 
 
 
 CURRENT ISSUE FEBRUARY 24, 2003  

LETTERS

Fluctuating Fortunes
"A wave is only a momentary surge on the surface of the ocean. Whether or not it brings treasures-votes-from the deep seas-voters-is what ultimately counts."
Bedashruti Mitra, Raigarh
 
Flip Side
The findings of your "Mood of the Nation" poll may come as good news for the BJP and the Sangh Parivar but is bad news for India ("BJP's Finest Hour", February 10). Our hopes lie with the Congress forming a suitable coalition of like-minded secular parties to counter the hate campaign of the BJP and its communal allies. The Congress has to drop its ego if it really wants the country to be released from the grip of the communal and hate politics of the Sangh Parivar.
Kalyan Ghosh, Kolkata
 
The BJP is basking in glory today thanks to Hindutva and Moditva. What happened to Gan-dhitva? The secular status of this country is facing a grave threat.
K. Chidanand Kumar, Bangalore
 
The desperation of the Opposition is highlighted by their having to rely heavily and repeatedly on "spent political forces" like V.P. Singh, H.D. Deve Gowda, I.K. Gujral and their ilk. The severe absence of issues and achievements is striking, while the Congress is busy strengthening the Hindutva forces by taking a soft Hindutva line.
L.Y. Rao, Mumbai
 
The sudden spurt in the NDA's popularity should be attributed to the innumerable deficiencies and drawbacks of the Congress. Whether it is secularism, privatisation, disinvestment, terrorism or any other issue, all that the Congress has to offer is doublespeak and double standards. If the NDA is bad, the Congress is worse. It seems the people prefer the lesser evil.
T.S. Pattabhi Raman, Coimbatore
 
Public Relations
Your story was a well balanced analysis of the current situation in the subcontinent ("A Neighbourhood of Trouble", February 10). How well India deals with its saarc neighbours will determine the future of South Asia. We need not apologise for our size. India should nurture economic and cultural ties with neighbours other than Pakistan. If we are able to lead and facilitate other neighbours along the path of economic progress, a struggling Pakistan will eventually fall in line.
C.P. Belliappa, Coorg, Karnataka
 
One way of building good neighbourly relations is through joint army adventure training activities. The Indo-Bangladesh white water rafting expedition conducted last year and the forthcoming Indo-Nepal mountaineering expedition are a good beginning in this direction.
Amarpreet Sachar, on e-mail
 
Tax Haven
Just making the filling of income-tax forms simple is not enough ("Simply Saral", February 10). The confidence of taxpayers of not being put to unnecessary trouble is more important. Most taxpayers fear the scrutiny of the returns they file. In addition, the general impression about scrutiny is the harassment to taxpayers and increased possibilities for corruption. This reminds me of a joke: "If you don't file your income-tax return you will go to hell but if you file your income-tax return it will be worse than hell."
Mahesh Kapasi, on e-mail
Saga of the Times

It is a sorry state of affairs-one for which pa-rents are squarely to be blamed-that nowadays children have to be sensitised and induced into reading ("Spinning a Tale", February 10). When we were growing up there was no clamour on the part of our parents to prove themselves at the cost of their children, as is happening these days. Besides, television was still in its infancy. While we looked up a dictionary for the meaning of a word, the present generation uses a search engine. More such efforts at storytelling need to be made.

Nalin K. Rai, on e-mail
 
On a Limb
I was shocked by the news of Mayawati receiving the Paul Harris Fellowship awarded by Rotary International for her initiative in polio eradication because Uttar Pradesh has the worst record of polio eradication in India ("Signposts", February 3).
Siddhartha Raj Guha, Jabalpur
 
Missing Persons
You missed the name of Lata Mangeshkar in your list of the powerful ("The High and Mighty", February 3). She deserves a mention "because she is the uncrowned queen of the Indian music industry. Because she does not have any political commitment and still manages a fan following that includes Jawaharlal Nehru and A.B. Vajpayee. Because everyone in India feels honoured to meet her. Because the prime minister can come all the way from Delhi to Pune only for the inauguration of her hospital."
Atul Godhamgaonkar, Bangalore
 
The inclusion of Amitabh Bachchan, Shah Rukh Khan and Shekhar Kapur in your list is incongruous. After all, what is the contribution of the three men if your criteria in compiling the list was that the person could tailor national policy and move government files? Including them in an otherwise credible and creditable list mitigated the earnestness of the ratings and made it more like People magazine's populist, America-centric, "50 most beautiful people in the world".
Bragadeesh Srinivasan, Chennai
 
The list makes no mention of any writer or novelist. Can we ignore the power of the pen?
Dr Rajiv Chopra, Dehradun
 
Unchastity Belt
Your story presents a bleak picture of Mumbai at nights ("Men on Call", January 27). Men who trade in sex only reflect the degenerating status of Indian culture which glorifies sex as "sacred".
R. Rajanganapathy,
Kovilpatti, Tamil Nadu
 

Our chairperson Ashok Row Kavi has been quoted as saying that the "commodification of sex has reached a crescendo". It would be pertinent to add that this "commodification" leads to very high risk behaviour. The Humsafar Trust works with this segment of males precisely because the sexual behaviour involved may lead to increased transmission of both sexually transmitted infections and HIV.

The trade in sex indulged in by men is sordid, disempowering and prone to violence. Male sex work, unlike female sex work, has different dynamics and leads to very fast burnout as males seem to deteriorate faster in this profession. We would like to place it on record so that more people are not encouraged to get into such work.

Vivek Anand, Chief Executive Officer, The Humsafar Trust, on e-mail
 
"While Second Lieutenant Arun Khetrapal will always inspire patriotism in our youth, his father will remain the epitome of humanity."
 
 
Navneet Dhawan, Delhi
 
Taking a New Road
"Ram Gopal Varma deserves credit for being a director who boldly encourages newcomers."
Onkar Chopra, Delhi
 
 
"Why is it that Varma gives a chance to new men but is steadfast on his female stars?"
Shraddha Rungta on e-mail
 
Still Waters
You have credited Dr L.K. Rao, former Union minister of irrigation and power, for envisaging the plan to link rivers ("Changing the Course", January 20). However, the original blueprint for linking the rivers was drafted by Sir Arthur Cotton, a British engineer, in 1854. The scheme had the full backing of the then Governor-General Lord Dalhousie, who lobbied with the East India Company for the project. It would probably have materialised but for the railways project of East India Company.
D.R. Nayak,
Mumbai Frontiers Men
 
Those critical of NRIs must look at ground realities ("Rooting for Change", January 20). They went abroad because they found abundant capital, superb infrastructure, a professional work culture, minimal red tape and a free lifestyle-none of which could be found in India. The same Indians who are successful abroad would probably have never been half as successful had they remained in India. Also it is because of this successful community that we have been able to prove to the world that Indians are hard working and have superb entrepreneurial skills.
Vinod V., Mumbai
 
Case in Point

Your story states that during the tenure of my father, Justice A.M. Ahmadi, as the chief justice of India (CJI), I had a roaring practice; that the committee on judicial accountability alleged that I was using my connection to get favourable rulings, that I got special treatment from certain judges and that my father got members to defeat the resolution to ban relatives of judges from staying in the same house ("Rot in the System", January 20). As far as I recall no committee made the allegation or moved the resolution for banning relatives from living with judges-it was moved by a member of the bar, an independent body, that discussed and rejected an obviously biased motion by an overwhelming majority, near unanimity.

Apart from being false, the allegation that I got favourable rulings from judges of the High Court is unfair to the judges-you have not mentioned a single ruling or the setting aside of any such ruling after my father's retirement. As regards my practice, "roaring" is a relative term. The income from my practice during my father's tenure did not exceed Rs 1.5 lakh p.a.-a fact that could be verified from my income-tax returns.

Tasneem Ahmadi,
Advocate, Delhi
 
Senior Editor Sumit Mitra replies:

We stand by our story. Tasneem Ahmadi does not deny that she lived at the residence of her father, the then CJI, while carrying out her legal practice in Delhi High Court. She confirms that some members of the bar objected to it. She also does not deny that the committee on judicial accountability had demanded she not live in the same house as her father. There was undoubted misuse of judicial office to defeat a bar association motion prohibiting the children of judges with legal practice from staying at their father's residence. That the spirit of the move was correct is borne out by the fact that the Supreme Court judges adopted shortly thereafter, in 1997, a similar resolution in "Restatement of Values". Ms Ahmadi points to her tax returns to deny she had a roaring practice but whether it is roaring or not is not determined by income disclosed.

 

Index
[an error occurred while processing this directive]