As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The VHP's grand foray into Tamil
Nadu begins with more just rhetoric. The huge following it has already managed
to build up shows that it is well on its way to striking deeper roots, writes
India Today's Arun Ram. SOUTHERN
SAFFRON
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE MARCH 03, 2003
ECONOMY: BUDGET 2003
Beginner's LUCK
The finance
minister has already opened budget proposals to the public. Here's how daring
he can be on February 28.
By Rohit Saran
One of India's least secret budgets is likely to
come from one of the country's most reclusive finance ministers. In a
major break from the budget speeches of the 1990s, Finance Minister Jaswant
Singh's speech on February 28 is likely to be more exciting in the second
half than in the first part. That is, the core of the budget will be its
tax and expenditure proposals rather than the elaborate policy proposals
which in the past have ranged from new labour laws to a new power bill.
MR BIG PICTURE: Jaswant has the
vision. Now he has show the will.
In doing so, Jaswant will restore the annual budget to what it should
be-an expense and income account of the government. And as is clear now,
it is in the government's balance-sheet accounting that some of the most
critical economic reforms are still pending. By design or by default,
Jaswant seems to be seized with at least one part of it-government's tax
revenue. There too, thanks to the two task forces that he appointed, the
finance minister's options are no secret. "Having floated the reports
of the two task forces and a mid-year review of the economy to public
discourse, Jaswant has gauged the pulse of what people want. He now has
to distill proposals from it," says FICCI Secretary-General Amit
Mitra.
Despite being reclusive-Jaswant didn't hold the customary pre-budget
meeting with industry chambers and is not known to interact with junior
bureaucrats of his ministry-many in India Inc. say he is more open to
suggestions. He has sought opinions and suggestions from everybody in
writing through post and e-mail, virtually opening the ministry to the
whole world. "The process of consultation has been very good and
the minister has personally written to us acknowledging our suggestions,"
confirms Mitra.
JASWANT'S
COMFORTS ...
Proximity to the PM.
Stronger political backing than his predecessor.
Reviving Indian economy.
His instincts as a reformer.
... AND HIS
CONCERNS
Uncomfortable with numbers and details.
The impending assembly elections.
Soaring government expenditure.
But being open isn't the same as being effective. How daring can the
finance minister be when the economy and politics are pulling him in different
directions? His political friends feel that Jaswant's first budget is
either five years too late (he narrowly missed the North Block job in
1998) or 1-2 years too early. It comes so close to the impending assembly
and Lok Sabha elections that it will have to be more populist than pragmatic-a
package that directly helps the BJP (or the NDA)-win elections. Then,
after one or two years, as finance minister of the next government, Jaswant
could present a budget unfettered with demands of electoral politics.
"The finance minister's biggest constraint could be the timing of
the budget," admits Jagdish Shettigar, member of the BJP's National
Executive.
Yet Jaswant's friends in the Finance Ministry say he is not a timeserver.
Though not a trained economist like Manmohan Singh or a stickler for details
like P. Chidambaram or a seasoned administrator like Yashwant Sinha, Jaswant's
strength is his being an instinctive reformer with the big picture of
the economy. More importantly, he is a political heavyweight and has the
ears of the prime minister. That should help Jaswant keep politics from
distorting his picture of the economy.
What is his picture of the economy? How much of it will be visible in
Budget 2003? Right now, the following things seem certain about the budget:
Taxation will be the overarching theme in the budget. Tax administration
will be simplified and rates reduced.
Reductions and simplifications will be most pronounced for excise and
customs duties-cuts in taxes on cars, soft drinks, air conditioners are
most likely.
A new social security scheme to soften the impact of removal of some
tax exemptions will be introduced.
Foreign investment limits in some sectors will be liberalised on the
lines of the N.K. Singh panel's suggestions.
Capital markets will be boosted by removing the tax on long-term capital
gains and dividends.
Expenditure control on the lines of the much-diluted Fiscal Responsibility
Bill.
These disparate elements do add up to some sort of an economic philosophy-a
modern, world-class fiscal system, small government and reforms by choice
rather than by compulsion. In different forums, Jaswant has mentioned
these as his priorities. Sure, none of these sound very new or daringly
different from the philosophy of his predecessor. But then, it needn't
be. For Jaswant's choice is not what to do for the economy, but how to
do it.
That taxation will be his signature reform is certain. "I will
be very surprised if Jaswant doesn't make taxation the underlying theme
for this year's budget," says Jairam Ramesh, economist and coordinator
of the Board of India Today Economists (BITE). So what happens to other
key pending economic reforms like change in labour laws, the electricity
bill, downsizing of the government and privatisation?
Thankfully for Jaswant, the Government has already expressed intentions
of doing all this several times over. He can repeat them, announce tentative
deadlines for some of them or just avoid any mention on operational grounds-shifting
the emphasis of the budget from Part A of the speech (policy changes)
to Part B (tax and expenditure issues). That's because implementing his
tax proposals alone will need all the support he can get from A.B. Vajpayee
and all the mileage he can extract from being a political heavyweight.
Attempting more than that may be shooting for the moon.
Jaswant can also draw cold comfort from the fact that the Indian economy
is reviving, even if in fits and starts. The BITE expects GDP growth in
2003-4 to be higher than the 4.4 per cent in 2002-3 (see graphic). A healthier
economy can make up for some compromises made for political reasons. For
his first budget, Jaswant will count on such beginner's luck.