As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The VHP's grand foray into Tamil
Nadu begins with more just rhetoric. The huge following it has already managed
to build up shows that it is well on its way to striking deeper roots, writes
India Today's Arun Ram. SOUTHERN
SAFFRON
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE MARCH 03, 2003
LIVING: SUPERCYCLONE WIDOWS
Double Jeopardy
For women who survived the supercyclone in Orissa,
the compensation money has become a bait for tricksters rather than a
means of succour
DeThree years
ago, Jayanti Mondal lost her husband, son and cattle to the super-cyclone
in Orissa. She survived by clinging on to a fallen tree. Her life had
been shattered again, and this time there seems to be nothing she can
hold on to for support.
Like the other survivors of the cyclone, Jayanti received compensation
for the death of her family members. With Rs 1.5 lakh in the bank, she
tried to begin life anew in Bagadhi village in the Ersama block of Jagatsinghpur
district. The compensation may have helped her get back on her feet, but
it did not mitigate Jayanti's grief or end her loneliness. Then Swapan
Samal came into her life with the promise of a life-long companionship.
They got married and Samal persuaded her to take a bank loan against her
fixed deposit. Soon after she gave him the money, he deserted her, returning
richer to his first wife and children. Jayanti, deep in debt and six months
pregnant, sits hunched in front of her thatched hut, sobbing, "I
am ruined."
SARASWATI ROUT, Gholpada Her husband
ran off with the loan she took against her Rs 3.5 lakh deposit. She
has complained to the police.
It is a familiar situation for many of the widowed survivors in Ersama.
Grief-stricken, lonely and helpless, unable to forget the horror of that
October 1999 night when nature battered their lives, they sought companions
who would help them out of their nightmares. Instead, they attracted men
whose romantic sensibilities leaned towards the commercial.
In a largely conservative and poor Orissa, widow remarriage is not a
common occurrence. Yet in the aftermath of the cyclone, there was a flurry
of marriages in Ersama-the region that took the worst pounding and took
8,000 lives. Death had left filial voids that needed to be filled. And
many devastated people-widows, widowers, orphans-rushed into unholy matrimony.
"Disasters affect insights and this results in serious impairment
of judgmental faculties," explains Dr Gopal Chandra Kar, principal
and head of the department of psychiatry, SCB Medical College, Cuttack.
Some marriages have worked. Rula Maity of Padampur, who lost her husband
and children in the supercyclone, and Bhagirathi, who lost his wife, are
happily married today. "But a majority of these marriages were certainly
not made in heaven," says Debabrata Patro of Action Aid, one of the
few NGOs that have stayed behind to help in the region's reconstruction.
For every successful marriage, there are half a dozen that have ended
in betrayal and separation. "It is as if the women survivors are
being victimised twice over," laments Sibabrata Kar of Sneha Abhijan,
an NGO initiative that seeks to provide psycho-social help to victims
of the supercyclone. The high toll (10,000 deaths across the state), ironically,
brought hefty compensations. A woman in Sankha village who lost nine members
of her family was awarded Rs 6.75 lakh, a prodigious fund in a perennially
poor region. It wasn't surprising that there was soon a line of suitors
outside her door. It wasn't surprising either that she chose wrongly.
SANDHYA DAS, Kendumatha Took a loan
against her bank deposit and gave her much-married second husband
Rs 50,000. He has since returned to his other wives.
By conservative estimates, at least Rs 65 crore in compensation money
has been pumped into the region. The women traditionally left all financial
dealings to their husbands, concerning themselves only with household
expenses. The rash of marriages was also, therefore, the panicky reaction
of women left with the task of managing accounts worth lakhs of rupees.
Saraswati Rout of Gholpada, for instance, got Rs 3.5 lakh on the deaths
of her husband and four children. She spent many sleepless nights wondering
what to do with the money. She was relieved when Laxmidhar Khatua promised
marriage and started living with her. She realised her folly only when,
convinced by her companion's financial savvy, she took out a loan against
her deposit. She has seen neither him nor her money since.
To her credit, Saraswati has hit back by registering a complaint of
fraud against Khatua with the Ersama police. "More than financially,
he pauperised me emotionally," she says. The episode has left deep
wounds, with her son from her first husband blaming her for the loss of
the money. The two frequently quarrel over the issue.
Other tales are just as depressing. After Manju Das, 27, of Baghadi
village lost her husband in the calamity, her neighbour Basudeb Mondal
proposed marriage. Today, Manju shares her second husband's home with
his first wife and a loan taken against her deposit has gone into repaying
his debts. She has taken another loan of Rs 40,000 to invest in his prawn
business.
After Sandhya Das of Kendumatha married Ananta Mondal-who had been married
a few times-she gave him the Rs 50,000 that she borrowed. Though the reticent
Sandhya says little, her neighbours say Ananta has gone back to his other
wives with gifts bought out of Sandhya's largesse.
Such chicanery has left women facing daunting debts. Since banks were
adjusting the interest on deposits against the loan repayments, interest
income has almost dried up. For the banks, it was sound business, with
the fixed deposits serving as collateral. But for the women, the money
brought nothing but sorrow and heartbreak.
MANJU DAS, Baghadi Married to and
living with her neighbour and his first wife. Paid his dues and took
a loan of Rs 40,000 to invest in his prawn business.
This might have been easily avoided. But with the focus firmly on brick-and-mortar
reconstruction, trauma care and counselling of the victims were generally
ignored. "The social aspect of the rehabilitation has not found as
much favour as it should have," admits Saroj Kumar Jha of the United
Nations Development Programme engaged in disaster mitigation in the region.
The results are evident. A study undertaken last year by the National
Institute for Mental Health and Neuro-Sciences, Bangalore, on the mental
health of the women who survived the cyclone in Ersama found that 15 per
cent of those diagnosed with post-trauma stress were heading for major
depressive disorders.
The authorities apparently believed that their task ended with physical
reconstruction and granting compensation. That the banks would give out
loans and the beneficiaries could be cheated was never considered. No
one even thought of instructing banks to exercise caution in giving out
loans against the compensation deposits.
In the absence of such measures, the women of Ersama are paying dearly.
There are horror stories to be heard from every village of the vast region
on the coastline. A 60-year-old man of Dahibar has got himself a 14-year-old
wife. Two orphaned sisters with fat bank balances have been married off
to a father and his son in Jhatibari. And distant relations of orphaned
Dolon Bera of Siali are planning to marry her off, together with her bank
deposit, to the man who greases their palms the most. Born of such ulterior
intentions, there is little doubt that a majority of marriages in Ersama
are being made in hell.