As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
Digvijay's friends continue to
benefit from his generosity as they are allotted prime land for peanuts.
India Today's Neeraj Mishra reports. UNQUESTIONED
LARGESSE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE MARCH 24, 2003
CONTROVERSY: CHARITY FUNDING
Fund Fracas
The Indian community in the UK and US get into
a dispute over charity money being allegedly used to fund Hindu sectarian
organisations in India
By
Anil Padmanabhan in New York and Ishara Bhasi in London
It
started as an ideological spat last November between two sections of the
Indian-American community. It turned ugly very soon and has so far embroiled
a host of players, including several blue-chip corporates and the US Department
of Justice. At the prodding of the US State Department, the Justice Department
has launched an investigation into charges that millions of dollars raised
by the Maryland-based India Development and Relief Fund (IDRF) were used
to fund Hindu fundamentalism in India. The investigations are to be part
of the wider scrutiny into allegations of US-based charities funding terror
activities worldwide.
NEW AGE MOTIF: Tahiliani's
Tees (right); and Sabina Singh's embellished kurtis
For the BJP-led Government at the Centre, it is the kind of publicity
it could do without. For the Americans, the controversy is a potential
embarrassment involving what it believes could be a long-term ally. So
far, the Bush Administration has steered clear of the controversy even
though the media has focused on it.
Across the Atlantic, a damning report by Britain's Channel 4 in December
2002 has put the spotlight on Sewa International, an NGO which did commendable
work in Gujarat after the January 2001 earthquake. According to the TV
report, Sewa borrowed the registration number of the RSS' overseas body,
the Hindu Swayamsevak Sangh (HSS), to obtain the status of a charity outfit
in Britain. In August 2002, the Charity Commission launched an investigation
after concerns over Sewa's dubious links were raised by Lord Adam Patel
of Blackburn, a Sewa patron in Britain who resigned subsequently. According
to a commission spokesperson, an inquiry was opened on November 5.
In the US, the issue came to light last November when the Campaign to
Stop Funding Hate, comprising a motley group of people, alleged in a report
titled "Foreign Exchange of Hate" that the IDRF had misrepresented
its aims to raise funds. The IDRF was founded in 1989 by Vinod Prakash,
a former World Bank staffer, as a non-profit, non-political, non-religious
and tax-exempt body. It focuses on five key areas-education, healthcare,
women, children and tribal welfare-besides relief and rehabilitation.
So far, the IDRF has raised about $10 million (Rs 48 crore), $3.8 million
was raised as quake relief alone. In the past decade, the IDRF has remitted
$1.75 million to charitable organisations in India.
IDRF officials admit some of its members are affiliated to Sangh constituents
but reject charges that funds are diverted to finance sectarian activities.
"The accusations are falsehoods packaged by propagandists masquerading
as concerned citizens," says Vijay Pallod, a Houston-based IDRF official.
By virtue of its tax-exempt status, individual contributions to the
IDRF are often matched by corporates. With the strong presence of Indian-Americans
in it, some software giants are among the donors. Microsoft, for instance,
has provided $55,000 since 1999. Others include Oracle, Sun Microsystems
and Ciscobut. Now firms like Oracle suspended their contributions, while
some like Microsoft stood their ground.
THE IDRF
SLANGING MATCH
CHARGES
COUNTERS
> Misrepresented its objectives to
raise funds from unsuspecting individuals to fund sectarian organisations
in India.
> Since its inception 13 years ago, IDRF's goal is to support RSS
affiliates in India.
> Seventy per cent of its funds diverted to fund Hindu extremism
activities in India though a quarter of IDRF corpus is in donor-designated
funds.
> The charity didn't raise funds to support victims of the 2002
communal riots in Gujarat.
> Charges yet to be proved. The US
Internal Revenue Service retains its tax-exempt status.
> Its founder Vinod Prakash is an RSS member but there is no formal
relationship between the two organisations.
> It selects NGOs with proven track records and they do not stand
up to any such claim.
> IDRF doesn't raise funds for victims of communal violence. Funds
for Bangladeshi-Hindus came through donor-designated window, over
which it has no control.
"We had no reason to believe funds would be used for any purpose
other than relief," says Jennifer Glass, vice-president, corporate
public relations, Oracle Corporation. The company had matched donations
made by employees for the Gujarat quake relief. "Oracle has now put
all funds to the IDRF on hold pending investigations," adds Glass.
Though the charges have choked up resource inflow from some quarters,
IDRF is yet to take recourse to legal action. "We will take appropriate
action at the right time," says an IDRF official. On the flip side,
mounting criticism has actually acted as a catalyst for enhanced contributions.
"In February alone we raised $45,000," says Pallod. The IDRF
has also found a new ally: a group that calls itself Friends of India
and comprises, among others, several academics. "There are anti-Hindu
Marxist, Christian evangelical and Islamic fundamentalist forces behind
the campaign against IDRF," says a Friends spokesman. " The
IDRF-funded projects are exemplary and non-discriminatory approach to
all."
In Britain though, Sewa has denied the Channel 4 report revealing it
as the funder of the Vanvasi Kalyan Ashram in Gujarat, which is implicated
in the riots. It offered "forensic" evidence (by way of an fir)
that implicates a leading member of Vanvasi, who is currently "on
the run from the police". It also showed how respectable organisations
have unwittingly aided Sewa and, through it, the activities of the Parivar.
A 30-member team of NRIs comprising members of Sewa and IDRF visited
Gujarat recently to verify the charges. Says Somnath Khedkar, who heads
Sewa Bharati, which received about Rs 22 crore from Sewa for quake-related
work, "The charges are completely motivated. It is a conspiracy to
defame Sewa International and Sewa Bharati."
In the US, a Justice Department spokesman declined to comment on the
investigations. The Indian missions in both London and Washington have
downplayed the issue, preferring to treat it as a conflict within the
community. But as the investigation proceeds, it is clear that what is
so far an intra-community issue will assume far greater significance.