As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE APRIL 14, 2003
COVER STORY: INSIDE BAGHDAD THE IRAQ WAR
Beacon of Grief
As the civillian deaths
in Iraq continue to rise, so do the questions about the war aims of Washington
and London
By
Craig Nelson in Baghdad
From
outside on the dirt street, the wailing was like a beacon of grief, arcing
across the cloudless, star-lit night. Inside, a dozen women clad in full-length
black cloaks sat huddled on the floor of a living room, bobbing back and
forth and sending piercing high-pitched screams into the night. What they
were weeping over lay next door, in the blue-painted anteroom decorated
with a dusty picture of an alpine stream in Europe that people of this
poor Shiite Muslim neighbourhood in northwestern Baghdad are unlikely
to ever see.
COFFIN COUNT: Razzaq Kazem al-Khajaf lost 15
family members, including six children, to coalition bombardment in
southern Babylon
Under the orange glow of a single kerosene lamp, three rough-hewn wooden
caskets lay neatly in line on the floor of the waiting room. Inside the
caskets were the bodies of the boys of the al-Hamdani family, ages 20,
18 and 12, wrapped in white sheets and tied in bows at the knees, waist
and chest with scraps of matching white cloth.
Neighbours said the boys were killed when a bomb or missile struck a
crowded, open-air market about 50 ft away from their home. The crater
gouged out of the hard dirt street wasn't large-3 m wide and 2 m deep-but
hot shrapnel peeling from the ordnance hit two of the boys in the chest
and one in the head, killing them instantly, the neighbours said.
The boys of the al-Hamdani family weren't alone. Officials at the nearby
al-Noor Hospital said up to 51 people were killed and 50 wounded in the
weekend blast in Baghdad's al-Shu'la district. The civilian death toll
in Iraq continues to rise and predictably so do the questions about the
war aims of Washington and London.
The modest crater appeared more consistent with the signature of an
Iraqi surface-to-surface missile. That didn't matter. The explosion was
immediately blamed on a US bomb or missile that no one here described
as "errant." Both ordinary Iraqis and officials alike say the
United States and Britain, frustrated with their progress in the war,
have deliberately taken the fight to Iraq's civilians.
Salama Zaki al-Said is one of those Iraqis and, civilian or not, he
has grown increasingly sure that Iraq would prevail as its war with the
US and Britain entered its third week. He confidently ventured from his
home on the Muslim day of prayer and was shopping for a television in
al-Shu'la's market when he heard jets high overhead and looked up in the
sky. Seconds later, he said, a blast shook the street, demolishing shop
stalls and ripping gaping holes in a parked red Volkswagen sedan.
"I was stunned," he said. "I couldn't believe it would
happen here." A few feet away, the father of the three dead boys
stood stiffly, as if in daze, while the weeping swirled around him. He
would not speak.
PROPAGANDA WAR: Information Minister Mohammed
Saeed al-Sahhaf plays on the media's need for gore and emotion; (below)
an Iraqi runs past a car destroyed in a Baghdad raid
Shiite Muslims make up about 70 per cent of Iraq's 24 million people,
but they have been the downtrodden majority under Saddam Hussein's regime,
getting the short end of the stick in favour of the Sunni Muslim minority
and the Iraqi leader's tribe belonging to the north.
Bush Administration officials had hoped the US-led invasion of Iraq
would trigger anti-government rebellions in Shiite neighbourhoods like
al-Shu'la, but so far none has broken out. Incidents like this blast will
do little to boost American hopes.
Asked about the nature of the injuries he had been treating, Dr Ahmed
Sufian, a resident at Al-Noor Hospital, grew increasingly distraught.
They were "severe", he repeated, then described a one-year-old
girl with open intestinal wounds. Finally, he could contain himself no
longer and the condemnation of America poured forth. "I'm a doctor
and I can't understand this. They come to free us? This is freedom?"
It has become increasingly difficult in Baghdad for foreign reporters
to answer the doctor's question, let alone ferret out who is responsible
for the mounting toll of civilian casualties.
There are only about 300 foreign reporters remaining in Baghdad, and
rather than risk expulsion we have become obedient participants in what
one reporter has dubbed the "magical mystery tour" after the
Beatles' recording of the same name. Actually, the Iraqi Government's
daily bus excursions for journalists spark very little magic and more
than a few mysteries. The name has stuck, though.
Each day, three or four 45-seat buses pull up to the front of the Palestine
Hotel, which houses all foreign reporters in Baghdad. Journalists trundle
aboard for the trips to sites of bombings against purportedly civilian
targets that the Iraqi Government says were committed by US and British
forces.
The Palestine Hotel where all foreign journalists
are housed
When the buses stop, reporters pour out and scurry toward the demolished
building to find a quote, while photographers and television cameramen
search for a fresh angle in what has become for the Iraqis a one-note
story: the deliberate targeting of civilians and non-military installations
by "hysterical" American and British forces frustrated with
their lack of progress in ousting Saddam's Government. This is a government
that at the moment is "on-message," as they say in the public-relations
game.
The media-saavy Iraqi authorities know that the appetite for news from
Baghdad is voracious. They also know that journalism's lowest common denominator
is gore and red-hot emotion.
One day last week, 10 photographers and television cameras and government
chaperones circled the small remnants of a missile that rested on the
curb in front of the destroyed al-Salhiya telephone exchange in central
Baghdad. A Japanese photographer pulled a miniature Geiger counter from
his bag and took readings from the shard of metal to determine if it contained
uranium.
Then like impatient shepherds herding cattle, a government chaperone
yelled at reporters in cryptic English, "Move. You will be happy.
There's a lot of damage at the next stop."
There was. And sitting in the rubble of the Adamiyah telephone exchange
was 70-year-old Abel Rashid Asen, smoking a cigarette and shouting, "We
will sacrifice for Saddam Hussein. If Bush is a brave man, let him fight
us face-to-face in Baghdad." The cameras and notebook-toting reporters
lapped it up.
The "magical mystery tour" is only part of the new regimen
for Baghdad reporters. At the Palestine Hotel, now also the office for
the foreign press corps after the bombing of the Information Ministry,
reporters are treated to a procession of government officials who tout
Iraqi battlefield successes and spout ritual denunciations of alleged
American and British excesses.
INNOCENT VICTIMS: A father holds his injured
child in a Baghdad hospital
Over the weekend, Information Minister Mohammed Saeed al-Sahhaf condemned
the killing of a defenceless Iraqi woman by the American "assassins"
and "mercenaries". Al-Sahhaf failed to mention reports that
indicated the woman was being used as a human shield by an Iraqi fighter.
As the war intensifies, controls on journalists have tightened. Under
the new rules, reporters must have a government-approved minder and driver.
Reporters are not permitted to travel in Baghdad without them. Want to
walk alone to the corner to shop for groceries or go to a restaurant to
eat? Forget it. Take a government chaperone. Even drivers are reminded
of their duty to prevent reporters, especially Americans, from straying.
What has complicated coverage of this war further is the Iraqi Government's
outright admission that it will use any subterfuge to defend the nation.
"We reserve the right to cheat the enemy. They are invading our
country," Deputy Prime Minister Tariq Aziz told one interviewer recently.
The impresario overseeing foreign journalists in Baghdad is the urbane
and avuncular Uday al-Ta'e, the Information Ministry's director-general.
In setting down the new guidelines for foreign journalists on March 29
evening, al-Ta'e addressed every questioner, both male and female, with
a feline "dear".
The regulations are for your own good, al-Ta'e told reporters. "We
use 'guides' not 'minders'... They will solve your problems, wherever
you go."
The director-general assured the gathered press corps that Iraq was
interested only in the truth business, rejecting its opposite with a scowl
as though he had smelled a rotten onion. "We don't sell propaganda.
We hate propaganda. We don't need propaganda," he said.
Given these restrictions, the sceptic might well ask whether foreign
reporters still in Baghdad are merely shills for the Iraqi Government.
The answer is that while some might well be, most are not.
On the critical issue of civilian casualties, for instance, journalists
are not experts in munitions. Few have served in the military. Yet among
some foreign journalists still in Baghdad are reporters who between them
have covered every major armed conflict of the past 40 years. Cluster
bombs, Tomahawk cruise missiles and Iraqi surface-to-surface missiles
leave distinct signatures in buildings, asphalt and flesh. That is a basis
for scepticism about the customary claims of innocence made by both sides
in this war.
Even with tight government control around the locations of alleged civilian
casualties, there are stories to be told and hints of important truths
about Saddam Hussein and his grip on power. There was the doctor in the
al-Noor Hospital who, frustrated by his inability to treat the victims
from the al-Shu'la blast, admitted the hospital had no supplies and had
been forced to conduct amputations without anaesthesia.
Then, back in the neighbourhood where the blast that killed 51 people
occurred, there was a notable absence of pro-Saddam demonstrations that
have been typical at every other blast site. These were Shiite Muslims
who had benefited little from Saddam's rule yet were suffering just the
same.
Even al-Ta'e slips up, tellingly describing the al-Shu'la blast as an
"accident, an incident, a crime", all in the same sentence.
There are, of course, outright lies by Iraqi officials. Mostly, however,
we work in a crucible of half-truths. Even al-Ta'e offered one unvarnished
truth about the predicament of journalists in Baghdad.
"This is war. This is not tourism. This is not a picnic."