As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE APRIL 14, 2003
HEALTH: SARS
Mass Attack
As the panic spread by a mysterious killer virus
triggers a global alert, India too takes preventive measures. But the
identity of the virus remains as difficult to verify as the
treatment.
On
February 26 this year, a 48-year-old American businessman boarded a routine
flight from the Guangdong province of China to Hanoi in Vietnam. It was
not a comfortable flight-his head ached, his body ached. By the time he
reached Hanoi, he could no longer ignore the raging fever and relentless
dry cough that racked his body. He was admitted to the hospital, where
he died.
AIR OF UNEASINESS: People in Hong Kong wear
surgical masks to protect themselves from the possible spread of SARS
infection
Nobody knew why. But they soon realised that his killer was at large
and had attacked all those who had been close to him during his illness.
Suspicious of the number of medical staff who soon reported similar pneumonia-like
symptoms, Carlo Urbani, a 46-year-old Italian doctor working for the World
Health Organisation (WHO), duly reported to it that something serious
was amiss. And so began a real-life saga whose script could give the best
Hollywood screenwriters a run for their money.
By March 15, when five people were dead and over 150 affected worldwide,
WHO issued a rare global emergency alert. India was unaffected, but took
note. Union Health Minister Sushma Swaraj, who was in Hyderabad when the
first reports arrived, immediately called S.P. Aggarwal, director-general
of health services, and Health Secretary S.K. Naik. A high-level official
meeting was convened to discuss the best course of action for India.
The mysterious new killer disease, for want of a better name, was called
"Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome" (SARS) by WHO. Its tentacles
quickly spread across the globe. The initial victims were from neighbouring
areas-Hong Kong, China, Singapore and Vietnam. Soon, thanks to air travel,
reports of SARS began to read like a geography lesson. One of the first
victims was reported in Toronto, Canada-a passenger who had flown in from
Hong Kong. The scare spread. One by one, nations from all corners of the
globe-Romania to Australia-began reporting cases of SARS.
Each day, the toll of victims rose as steadily as those in Iraq. There
was no doubt about who was winning in this war. By April 2, WHO reported
over 2,200 cases of SARS and 78 deaths in 13 countries. Among the victims
was Urbani, the doctor who first brought SARS to the world's attention
in Hanoi. WHO took the drastic step of effectively quarantining the worst-hit
areas-Hong Kong and Guangdong. The killer was on the rampage and its identity
still a mystery.
Meanwhile, the race is on in the scientific community to identify the
cause of what could be the biggest health epidemic of the 21st century.
Fairly early on, scientists were convinced that the agent was a virus.
The symptoms associated with SARS resemble atypical pneumonia, usually
associated with viruses such as the influenza virus, ADENO virus and other
viruses.
EXTRA CAUTIOUS: Airlines staff worldwide are
viewing the SARS scare seriously
Meanwhile, reports from Germany and Hong Kong suggested that the agent
was a new member of a family of viruses that also cause measles and mumps,
called paramyxovirus. But scientists at the US-based Center for Disease
Control, the key agency for any communicable disease, reported that they
had detected a previously unrecognised strain of "coronavirus"-a
family of viruses also responsible for the common cold. Under electron
microscopy, the virus showed the characteristic "crown like"
appearance that gives the coronavirus its name.
The conflicting reports have only added to the uncertainty, raising
several theories. The first is that the actual killer is a coronavirus
and the paramyxovirus a harmless one that's just there. The second is
the reverse-the paramyxovirus is the "bad one" and the coronavirus,
the innocent bystander. The third hypothesis talks of a viral teamwork-coronaviruses
are known to live in the body's immune cells and weaken a patient's immunity.
The paramyxovirus than walks in and goes on the rampage, unchallenged.
There is also the possibility that these viruses are not the culprits
and the actual killer remains undetected.
How did the virus originate? It is reported that Guangdong in China
was the epicentre of the disease. Cases of typical pneumonia had been
reported there as early as November 2002, and this has been linked to
the current SARS outbreak. Many questions remain unanswered. Scientists
in Hong Kong and of WHO suspect that the virus most likely originated
in animals there, mutated and crossed species.
Once inside human beings, it is "a war of attrition between the
human immune system and the virus", says J.C. Suri, head of respiratory
diseases at Delhi's Safdarjung Hospital. In those with a weaker immune
system or higher exposure to the virus, the virus wins. It then finds
its way to the lungs where it attacks and kills the tissues, causing respiratory
problems. The symptoms appear within two to 10 days. The virus spreads
through close contact with an infected person and is also airborne through
aerosol droplets, such as a cough. The symptoms are dangerously common
making it difficult to distinguish from flu. The good news is, it's less
infectious than the influenza virus. Only 5 per cent of its victims die.
While there is no specific treatment-doctors treat the symptoms instead
of keeping them under control-a cocktail of the anti-viral drug ribavirin
and steroids has been used in Hong Kong apparently to good effect.
CHECKED IN: Passengers are being screened for
signs of SARS at all airports
The biggest victim has been the region's travel and tourism industry.
Countries like Hong Kong and Singapore rely heavily on tourism for their
economy. Says Subhash Goyal, chairman, STIC Group: "Tourism to India
has not been affected. But outbound traffic to Hong Kong and Singapore
has decreased by 40 per cent, and to China by 50 per cent." Following
the new WHO advisory, travel to Hong Kong is expected to decline sharply.
There were some predictions in the industry that due to the Gulf War,
trouble-free south-east Asia would be the world's tourist hot spot. SARS,
however, has put paid to that. In a recently concluded meeting at Kathmandu,
Nepal, the World Tourism Organisation (WTO) agreed that the fear of the
virus would stop people from travelling and significantly affect tourist
flow across south and south-east Asia in the peak season.
Airline companies, however, are more cautious in their analysis. On
being asked how badly SARS could affect outbound travel from India, Cathay
Pacific Country Manager Tom Owen says, "India has seen a recent softening
in passenger demand. However, it is difficult to attribute the drop in
demand to any single source as the situation is further complicated by
other external factors, including the war in the Middle East."
Cathay Pacific, like many other airlines, has alerted staff posted at
check-in counters at Hong Kong and other countries to be extra vigilant
about passengers who appear ill. Cabin crews have also been given guidelines
on dealing with passengers suspected of having SARS.
Many countries have started taking precautions. Thailand has gone to
the length of invoking an emergency regulation to give health officials
the authority to quarantine suspected SARS-infected passengers for up
to two weeks.
INDIA'S INITIATIVES
All incoming passengers are being monitored by immigration officials
at international airports and ports. Indian embassies have been
told to warn those applying for visas that they would be denied
entry if suspected of SARS.
Disembarking passengers have to fill up prescribed forms designed
by the Health Ministry on SARS which will help trace suspected victims.
All hospitals in the country have been placed on alert to prepare
for the unexpected.
The National Institute of Communicable Diseases has been designated
the nodal agency for monitoring all possible cases.
The Government will import diagnostic kits from
Germany, via WHO, for detection of SARS.
In India, the Health Ministry has posted medical officers on duty on
24-hour alert at all international airports. Immigration authorities initially
had instructions to closely observe passengers on flights from SARS-affected
areas for any symptoms. This has now been extended to all flights. Whether
that will really stop SARS from entering the country is questionable.
Ask Monisha Dulharamani, 38. Flying in from Singapore last week with
a cold, she braced herself to be checked by doctors at Mumbai's international
airport or even be held up at the immigration counter. But she walked
in easily, without any checks for SARS. "In fact, the airlines were
more worried about spraying the aircraft with some vile-smelling medicinal
spray to make sure we didn't carry any bacteria with us. There were no
doctors, no security and absolutely no fuss," she says.
So far there have been no reported cases of SARS in India. But has adequate
precaution been taken for it to remain that way? The Health Ministry thinks
so. They have taken several steps. International airports and ports are
under observation. Prescribed forms on SARS will be distributed to all
disembarking passengers. All hospitals have been alerted. State governments
have been asked to take suitable measures. "We are creating awareness
of the disease and taking adequate precautions," says Bhawani Thyagarajan,
joint secretary in the ministry.
But it is a fine line between being alert and causing panic. Minister
Swaraj emphasises the point. "While the medical authorities should
be on full alert, we should not cause panic among the general public especially
when no SARS cases have been reported in India," she says. The National
Institute of Communicable Diseases, Delhi, has been designated as the
nodal authority. Suspect cases will have to be reported to state governments,
the NICD and Health Ministry. Ministry officials say that diagnostic kits
for detecting the virus will be imported from Germany via WHO and will
be distributed to NICD and the National Institute of Virology, Pune. In
Delhi, the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Safdarjung Hospital
and Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital have been designated the nodal hospitals.
"We are well prepared," says R.N. Salhan, medical superintendent
at RML.
Doctors and nurses have been made aware through workshops and circulars.
While it is impossible to screen all patients with pneumonia-like symptoms,
any suspect case will be asked about foreign travel and placed in isolation,
he says. For any possible SARS patients with severe breathing difficulties,
ventilators are available in all 15 operating theatres and emergency rooms
in the hospital. As for protection of doctors and nurses, he says it is
routine for them to take precautions like masks when examining potential
patients.
But SARS is not just another killer disease. "We are always prepared
for the unexpected," says N. Gupta, head, medical division, RML.
Alternatively, we could just pray.