As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE APRIL 14, 2003
STATES: CHATTISGARH
False Step
Jogi produces an IB document to suggest a political
witchhunt but the Vajpayee Government says it is forged and ropes in the
CBI to nail the chief minister
By Lakshmi Iyer
Shortly
after noon on Sunday, March 30, N.C. Padhi, special director, Intelligence
Bureau, received a surprise phone call from his 1968 Madhya Pradesh cadre
IPS batchmate, Ajit Jogi, now Chhattisgarh chief minister. Jogi invited
his old friend for a cup of tea at the Chhattisgarh Bhavan in Delhi and
Padhi gladly accepted it.
MISDEED: Jogi's docudrama may have alienated
even the top Congress leadership
Less than 24 hours later, Padhi was rueing his decision. He discovered
to his utter disbelief that Jogi's invitation had nothing to do with rekindling
old memories. It was a trap Padhi's old friend had laid for him. At a
press conference at the Congress party headquarters on March 31, Jogi
released copies of a letter he had written to Prime Minister Atal Bihari
Vajpayee to protest against "the IB's deliberate attempt to target him
under a plan code-named Operation Black Sea". He also enclosed copies
of a "Top Secret/Confidential" document allegedly prepared by the IB's
"special directorate" on among other things, his Swiss bank accounts,
properties and other assets that he is supposed to have amassed after
he became the chief minister of the new state, which came into being on
November 1, 2001.
The allegations were the kind that would make any politician run for
cover if they were true, or react in furious indignation if it was just
muck-raking. Jogi did neither. If that was not enough to raise eyebrows,
the fact that Jogi himself was giving publicity to the alleged charges
certainly did. In less than a day, the pieces began to fall into place.
Vajpayee reacted to Jogi's charges by ordering a CBI probe into the authenticity
of the document that Jogi had circulated. Such a probe, government sources
say, would force Jogi to disclose how he acquired a "secret document"
of the IB; the CBI also had registered a case for the offence of forging
a government document.
Obviously taken aback by the Centre's swift response, Jogi dispatched
a second letter to Vajpayee, this one harping on technicalities about
"one investigating agency of the Government of India inquiring into another".
While insisting that the ib document in his possession should not be prejudged
as forged, he demanded that an independent joint parliamentary committee
be set up to look into the matter.
IB officials are intrigued by the document-drama and cited a number
of reasons to explain why the item was faked (see box). "Obviously whoever
forged the document was not familiar with the Official Secrets Act. But
Jogi being a former civil servant should have been observant," points
out an IB special director. The prime minister as well as IB officials
have denied the existence of Operation Black Sea. "Such an operation is
outside the IB's charter. Corruption falls within the ambit of the vigilance
wing of the CBI," says an IB official.
Jogi avoids any public reference to his meeting with Padhi. To pointed
queries, his stock answer is: "I meet so many people that I can't remember
the names of all of them." But as the document saga began to boomerang,
Jogi's spin doctors worked overtime trying to link the leak to the premier
intelligence agency. They dropped hints about his Sunday engagement with
Padhi to suggest that the "top secret/confidential" IB document circulated
by Jogi was indeed handed to him by the official. They also said that
as a former IPS officer, Jogi has extensive contacts in the IB, even with
its director K.P. Singh, a Chhattisgarh cadre officer.
However, there are few takers for Jogi's arguments, even within the Congress.
Senior leaders admit the whole drama could have been scripted by Jogi
to pre-empt the disclosure of wealth amassed by his family. State Congress
leaders feel the BJP may use the corruption charges against Jogi in the
state assembly election this year-end the same way the Congress did against
the Prem Kumar Dhumal government in the Himachal Pradesh assembly elections
last month.
Senior AICC functionaries fear that the CBI probe could land both Jogi
and the party in trouble. They are livid at Jogi's misadventure, coming
as it did within a day after the hugely successful two-day Block Congress
Committee convention in Delhi addressed by Sonia Gandhi. "At the Desh
Bachao rally in Delhi, we had railed against NDA's corruption. By protesting
against a CBI probe, Jogi has undone all the gains made over the weekend,"
said a leader. Sonia's aides distanced her from the IB document, saying
she had not seen nor asked for it, but Ambika Soni, Sonia's political
secretary, was willing to give Jogi the benefit of doubt. "I am sure the
chief minister has enough reasons to vouch for its authenticity," she
said.
Jogi, of course, is no stranger to controversy. Though he claims to be
a tribal, the SC/ST Commission declared him a Scheduled Caste in 2001;
the case questioning his tribal status is still pending in the Bilaspur
High Court. In February 1999, Jogi did the unthinkable in Parliament-when
he cast a ballot on behalf of A.B.A. Ghani Khan Choudhary, MP from Malda,
in a crucial vote in the Lok Sabha relating to the ratification of President's
rule in Bihar. The Lok Sabha Speaker ordered an inquiry when the matter
was brought to his notice. Jogi was saved the blushes-and perhaps worse-only
by the premature dissolution of Parliament in April that year.
The wager in political circles is that this time Jogi may not be so lucky.
While he has friends in the BJP, it is difficult to see them bailing him
out in an election year. Even before the IB fiasco, Jogi had a sackful
of troubles. And since the scene of the latest adventure is the capital,
the Centre did not even have to seek the mandatory permission from the
state Government to ask CBI to get cracking. Jogi's martyr game has come
unstuck and left him with very little room for manoeuvring. When the CBI
comes calling, he will have few options left. He is damned if he cooperates
with the probe. And damned if he doesn't.