As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE APRIL 21, 2003
COVER STORY: ESSAYTHE IRAQ WAR
Farewell, Fear
Saddam Hussein begins his
journey to the souvenir shop
By
S. Prasannarajan
Even
in his fall, Saddam Hussein was not real. It was his metallic double,
for so long a soaring figure of fear and power, now chained and broken,
who fell, in operatic slow motion, into the liberated ground, to be dragged
through the streets of joy towards the final destination of every dictator:
the souvenir shop. It doesn't matter whether the original one is alive
in a bunker or lying dead in the rubble. Saddam, in the true tradition
of dictators, sought immortality in monumental fantasies, in painted mythology,
and on April 9, it was his moment of mortality-the bathetic farewell of
the last action hero among dictators.
Like a true dictator, Saddam sought immortality
in monumental fantasies.
The Saddam story, just another one of revolutionary conceit morphing
into absolute terror, was perhaps waiting for such a finale. And in Iraq,
it has a historical resonance: in 1958, when the Hashemite dynasty was
overthrown in a military coup, the mob dragged the regent's body through
the streets of Baghdad. Five years later, when the coup master of 1958
was killed by the Baa'thists, his bullet-ridden body was a televised item
worthy of national celebration. Saddam, one of the original Baa'thist
thugs, if he is still alive, must be trembling in nightmares for there
are so many ghosts to conspire against him.
He was, after all, one of the most ingenious architects of terror in
modern history-and graveyards are his legacy. Like his predecessors elsewhere
in the world, he too was the wayward child of a dream: Baa'thism. In the
beginning it was the slogan of an Arab renaissance and, at its idealistic
best, it was pan-Arabism with love, sort of, very much an ideology born
out of the poetic sensibility of one of its founding fathers, Michel Aflaq,
a Christian from Damascus. When the ideology assumed power, in military
uniform, what happened was a familiar transformation: from romance to
terror. Wasn't there a text that dreamed of heaven on earth and of the
creation of a Brand New Man behind the Great Terror of Stalin? Somewhere
in Saddamised Iraq, too, beyond the newly emptied torture cells and prisons,
there is an orphaned narrative of a great Arabian dream-"One Arab
Nation with an Eternal Mission".
Saddam turned Baa'thism into a theology of violence and Iraq into what
Kanan Makiya, a dissident Iraqi intellectual in exile, calls the Republic
of Fear. Fear is the most effective weapon of mass destruction. Hitler
used it, Stalin used it, Mao used it, Pol Pot used it and every liberator-turned-tyrant
in Latin America and Africa used it for survival. In classical dictatorships,
the ruler, permanently haunted by the phantom enemy, transfers private
fears into the public arena. According to his co-biographers Efraim Karsh
and Inari Rautsi, Saddam's outlook on life neatly fits into the bleak
vision of the philosopher Thomas Hobbes: "He perceives the world
as a violent, hostile environment in which the will to self-preservation
rules. In such a setting, as Hobbes says, the war of 'all against all'
is constant and a man is condemned to a life that is 'solitary, poor,
nasty, brutish, and short'."
Self-preservation here means the annihilation of the enemy-if there
is not one, one will have to be manufactured. And that explains the Baa'thist
bloodlust-also Saddam's legitimate status as a desert Caligula. He was
quoted as saying soon after taking up the presidency in 1979: "I
am far cleverer than they are. I know they are conspiring to kill me long
before they actually start planning to do it. This enables me to get them
before they have the faintest chance of striking at me." That was
Saddam's own version of pre-emption. At home, it was a purge equalling
the Great Terror of Stalinism. The decade-long war with Iran and the conquest
of Kuwait were the extra-territorial extension of the Mesopotamian horror
show.
Saddam thought the show would be eternal, for he had long ago taken
leave from reality. He was simulated Saladin, the slayer of Crusaders,
and he was reborn Nebuchadnezzar, the ideal king of Babylon. He needed
the protection of fantasy as he went on to expand the dominion of fear
and terror. As it happened, elsewhere, the dictator was a jaded museum
piece, as in Havana, or a comic strip villain, as in Pyongyang, or a tin-pot
looter, as in one of those African capitals; he alone was the hyperactive
butcher, daring to strike, within and without, and willing to seek an
Arab final solution-all for the eternity of the paranoid.
In Baghdad today, it is the demolition of the fear apparatus of the
paranoid. In the liberated streets-the Arab version of Moscow or Berlin
in the evening of the 20th century-it is the funeral rites of Saddamism.
At this moment the man himself is worthless anyway, his exaggerated metallic
copies will have some value at the junk market-or in the souvenir shop.