As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE APRIL 28, 2003
STATES: UTTAR PRADESH
Untamed Shrew
With a legal assault on Mulayam, a political assault
on the BJP and an ideological assault on caste Hindus, Mayawati is rampant
as ever.
By Subhash Mishra
On
April 14, the familiar Uttar Pradesh cocktail of low politics and high
drama swirled its way into the headlines again. At the Pardafaash (literally:
Remove the Veil) rally in Lucknow, Chief Minister Mayawati announced a
whopping 136 criminal cases against her arch-rival, former chief minister
Mulayam Singh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party. The cases largely related
to Mulayam's alleged misuse of the chief minister's discretionary fund
while in power in 1994.
FINGER POINTING: Mayawati at the April 14 rally
The public meeting had ostensibly been called to mark the birth anniversary
of Bhimrao Ambedkar, India's first law minister and best-known Dalit political
thinker. Instead it became the occasion to try out the cow belt's equivalent
of shock and awe tactics. Much of Mayawati's speech was spent abusing
Mulayam and his man Friday, the ubiquitous Amar Singh, SP general secretary.
"Mujhe pata chala hai, Amar Singh Mulayam Singh Yadav ko Mumbai
mauj masti ke liye bhi le jata hai (I believe Amar Singh escorts Mulayam
to Mumbai for pleasure)," went one Mayawati rocket. Rattled by the
SP's release of two CDs-one has Mayawati asking BSP MPs and MLAs to divert
development funds to party coffers and the other has her making allegedly
derogatory remarks about Hindu deities-Mayawati hit back; and hard.
Co-opting the law into political battles is not new to her. In recent
months, she has shackled Raghuraj Pratap Singh, an Independent MLA and
minor Rajput leader, with the Prevention of Terrorism Act. As such, the
136 cases-firs have been lodged in 40 districts, beginning with the Hazratganj
police station in central Lucknow-against Mulayam only follow a certain
(il)logic.
Mayawati has accused him of misusing Rs 3.7 crore. She has also filed
criminal cases for an alleged illegal recording of an internal BSP meeting
in Ambedkar Nagar district. The BSP says the tapes were then doctored
to "defame" Mayawati. The SP holds the tapes to be genuine and,
in fact, chronicle a BSP meeting in Lucknow.
MAYA'S SLEDGEHAMMER
Has accused Mulayam of misusing at least Rs 3.7 crore from the
chief minister's discretionary fund.
Has filed criminal cases against Mulayam for "illegally recording"
a BSP meeting in Ambedkar Nagar and then "doctoring" the
tapes.
By implicating Mulayam in 136 cases and filing FIRs in 40 districts,
she hopes to force him to seek bail in case after case.
Has implicated Amar Singh and other SP leaders in cases. Arrest
of SP workers has begun. The party has moved Allahabad High Court.
Is needling the BJP by targeting the party's Rajput
voters and by warning of large-scale Dalit conversion to Buddhism.
Most damaging are the cases charging Mulayam with misuse of the chief
minister's discretionary fund. As per the rules, every year the Uttar
Pradesh Assembly allocates a certain sum to the chief minister's discretionary
fund. The chief minister is entitled to make disbursements as he likes
provided certain key parameters are adhered to.
For instance, the chief minister may write a cheque of up to Rs 5,000
to a disabled person. A social or cultural body could be helped similarly.
A needy family the earning member of which has died suddenly could be
given Rs 20,000. A non-government educational institution could get up
to Rs 1 lakh.
As chief minister in 1993-94, Mulayam admittedly violated these criteria.
For instance, Rs 61 lakh was distributed among 10 district-level press
clubs and two "journalists". Wooing the "friendly"
press-allocating land to certain editors was another mechanism-was Mulayam's
way of cultivating an influential constituency. When Dhani Ram Verma,
then Assembly Speaker, wanted to take his son along to a Commonwealth
parliamentary conference in Canada, Mulayam was generosity personified.
He gave the Vermas Rs 2 lakh from the discretionary fund.
Mayawati has been quick to highlight such irregularities. She has ignored,
however, that every recent chief minister in Uttar Pradesh has violated
the discretionary fund rules. Mayawati herself is guilty.
When he became chief minister in 1997, Kalyan Singh (then in the BJP)
prompted the Centre to institute a Comptroller and Auditor-General (CAG)
inquiry into discretionary fund disbursements. Kalyan's target was Mayawati,
his predecessor, who was duly indicted in the CAG report for the transfer
of funds towards the grand Ambedkar Memorial in Lucknow.
FUND FURY: Mulayam and Amar Singh are targets;
Vora (below) is collateral damage
Yet the CAG investigators spared none. Between 1991 and 1997, they said,
Rs 33 crore had been disbursed from the discretionary fund by chief ministers
and governors-when the state was under President's rule-and much of the
money had been given away in violation of norms. More than half the sum-Rs
18 crore-had been disbursed by Mulayam. Pro rata estimates would therefore
suggest he bent the rules most often.
Even so, consider that between 1993-94 and 1996-97, Rs 21 lakh was given
as foreign travel "assistance" to 77 individuals. In this period,
Mulayam and Mayawati both served as chief ministers, the BJP backed a
BSP government and a Congress-appointed governor-Motilal Vora-took charge
under President's rule. Not surprisingly, Mayawati has ordered an inquiry
into Vora's disbursements as well.
There is a method to Mayawati's madness. By targeting Mulayam, leader
of the state's OBCs, she is consolidating her Dalit supporters. While
the upper castes may have been the historical oppressors, in contemporary
rural Uttar Pradesh Dalits are directly threatened by the OBCs. OBC aggression
and affluence are a post-1947, agriculture-induced phenomenon.
The SP may be an immediate target but Mayawati's parallel decimation
of the BJP, which ironically supports her government, is very much on.
When Rajnath Singh, BJP general secretary and himself a former Uttar Pradesh
chief minister, criticised her recently, the lady stung back.
At a press conference in Delhi on April 17, she suggested Rajnath "look
into his past". In humiliating this Rajput leader, Mayawati may be
pushing a key BJP backing community into the SP's arms.
At the conference, she also brushed aside the idea of a state law curbing
religious conversions, an issue close to saffron hearts. Earlier, at the
Pardafaash rally, she warned that unless the shankaracharyas reformed
Hinduism expeditiously, Dalits could convert to Buddhism in large numbers.
Many years ago, Margaret Thatcher, another famous woman politico, was
likened to "an iron fist in a velvet glove". With Mayawati,
the gloves are always off.