As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE MAY 05, 2003
STATES: TAMIL NADU
Nail In The Coffer
Despite no clear source of funding, Jayalalithaa
undertakes a grandiose statewide tour, announcing welfare schemes worth
crores of rupees
By Arun Ram
For
the past few months, the skies around the indigent villages of Tirunelveli
district in Tamil Nadu reverberated to copious invocations-pleas for rain.
The heavens remained intransigent till March 13. Amidst a resounding burst
of thunder and through a ripe patch of clouds, a white helicopter descended
to earth. The gods had relented; a goddess appeared.
RAISING HOPES: By the time Jayalalithaa completes
her tour she may have promised Rs 10,000 crore worth of welfare projects
"Karuna thay", as Tamil Nadu Chief Minister and AIADMK General
Secretary J. Jayalalithaa is known among lesser mortals, had come bearing
a bagful of welfare schemes and a tranche of promises. Tirunelveli is
not the only district to be deluged with Amma's magnanimity. With her
Z-category security and official entourage in tow, Jayalalithaa has been
heli-hopping through districts across the state in the past two months,
announcing schemes and promising welfare measures. By the time she had
covered eight districts, the promises added up to Rs 2,300 crore. More
visits will follow the budget session of the Assembly. When the district
tours draw to a halt, Jayalalithaa is expected to have pledged development
and welfare schemes worth more than Rs 10,000 crore. By her own admission,
the chief minister has inherited an empty treasury, and according to the
white paper released last year, the state's total fiscal deficit stands
at Rs 6,000 crore. So how is she planning to finance these schemes?
Says state Finance Minister C. Ponnaiyan: "We will make arrangements.
The tax collection has been looking up and funds are coming from various
agencies. Every scheme will be implemented." The budget Ponnaiyan
presented on March 21, shortly after Jayalalithaa wound up the first leg
of her district visits, listed out the measures to mobilise additional
resources.
The resource mobilisation package, including a levy of 12.5 per cent
on telephone rentals, a compounding tax on cable operators and a green
tax on old vehicles, is expected to bring in additional revenue of only
Rs 430 crore. This will leave an uncovered deficit of Rs 865.15 crore
in the budget. Though Ponnaiyan observed that the Centre had endorsed
the state's request for an economic restructuring loan from the World
Bank, he added, "We had assumed that Rs 1,000 crore would be released
as the first tranche of this support in this budget."
THE PROMISE MAKER
Villupuram, February 27, 2003
Of the Rs 237 cr worth of projects, Rs 58 cr is for drinking water
and Rs 39 cr for development.
Cuddalore, February 2, 2003
Welfare schemes worth Rs 855 cr were launched, including the Rs
720 cr Veeranam water project.
Tiruchi, March 10, 2003
Rs 209 cr was allocated for various schemes, including Rs 104 cr
for construction of bridges.
Dindigul, March 7, 2003
Welfare plans worth Rs 254 cr were announced. These include Rs 91.35
cr for Cauvery project.
Tirunelveli, March 13, 2003
Of the Rs 439 cr worth of schemes, Rs 165.92 cr has been allocated
to development projects.
In other words, nobody knows where the money for Jayalalithaa's pet plans
is going to come from. Senior officials say while some of the schemes
will be implemented as part of Central projects and some disbursements
will be made from the state funds, many projects will remain on paper.
"Which chief minister has not made hollow promises?" asks a
former bureaucrat. "The previous chief minister also made many promises.
Jayalalithaa is doing the same," he adds. Those who have observed
the government function over the years say it has been an accepted practice
to make big promises and do little. "After the initial euphoria,
who is going to remember the big words meant only to create a feeling
of well-being?" says the official.
Whether the promises are fulfilled or not, for now Amma's visits are
creating a big impact. For a woman who has perfected the art of moulding
pomposity into a halo for herself, it is not too much of an effort. True
to her penchant for majestic appeal, Jayalalithaa has been moving from
one district to another in a helicopter. On the ground, red carpets are
rolled out and elephants lined up to salute her. Buntings, banners and
loud speakers sing the praises of "Puratchi Thalaivi Jayalalithaa".
Full-page advertisements have filled up local newspapers with Namathu
MGR, the AIADMK's official organ, listing out the promises in great detail.
In Tirunelveli, the stage from where Jayalalithaa announced Rs 439 crore
worth of welfare measures was equipped with air-conditioners. Elsewhere,
the chief minister bought a woven image of herself for Rs 1,700 from a
woman artisan belonging to a self-help group.
Though many a leader has appreciated the need for such grandiosity to
etch one's image deeper in the hearts of the faithful, Tamil Nadu Congress
Committee President E.V.K.S. Elangovan is not amused. "Even as questions
are being raised about the sources of money for implementing such mega-projects,
she is spending public money for publicity," says Elangovan. The
Congress leader has pegged the total expenditure of the chief minister's
sojourns at Rs 25 crore and plans to file a public-interest petition against
the extravagant spending.
Though the AIADMK leaders are unwilling to go on record regarding the
source of funding for Amma's tour, they maintain that the party units
and well-wishers have contributed to the expenses incurred by the reception
committees in various districts. "The newspaper advertisements were
released by party units and individuals as a show of affection towards
Amma," says a party activist from Tiruchi. Meanwhile, there are allegations
that panchayat presidents were forced to cough up Rs 2,000 each for the
grand reception arrangements.
The mode of Jayalalithaa's transport has also added fuel to Elangovan's
charges. Counters a senior minister: "What's wrong with the chief
minister travelling by a chopper owned by the Government? She would otherwise
have had to travel in an aircraft with the security people and officials,
which would have cost the Government even more. It is not our fault that
the previous government did not utilise the official helicopter."
When the DMK was in power, the auditor-general's report had stated that
the government had incurred unnecessary expenses on the maintenance of
the chopper which remained under-utilised.
Surprisingly, not many questions were raised in the Assembly in the
budget session about the chief minister's promises and the means to realise
them. With Elangovan involved in the infighting in his party and the Assembly
reliving the ugly scenes in 1989 when Jayalalithaa was allegedly assaulted
by DMK leaders, her lofty promises may soon be forgotten.
Not in the villages of Tirunelveli, where people are still praying.
For rain. And for a new god.