As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE MAY 12, 2003
FOLLOW-UP: SARS
Ill Defined
Even as panic reigns and more people are quarantined,
the Government declares that India is SARS-free
By Sandeep Unnithan
For 42-year-old
textile engineer Asitabha Purakayastha, a massive heart attack was just
the beginning of his woes. A few days later, he suffered heartache of
another kind. On April 28, he was diagnosed with SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory
Syndrome) and his wife refused to have him at home while the hospital
workers at Kolkata's AMRI Apollo agitated to discharge him. Purakayastha
soon became the pariah of Kolkata. He was not alone.
FIRE FIGHTING: Anti-SARS yagna in Delhi
With victims ranging from a farmer in Punjab to a truck driver in Tamil
Nadu, the dreaded new Chinese virus has gone desi with a vengeance. With
the number of confirmed SARS cases shooting up to 20, India had one more
addition to a long list of diseases. The biggest casualty of SARS, however,
seems to be reason. When the second confirmed patient in Kolkata, Radheshyam
Gupta, was admitted to the Infectious Diseases Hospital, many of its staff,
including doctors, refused to report for duty.
In Pune, the worst hit with 13 confirmed SARS cases, Simon Peter Alhat
had to deal with about a hundred frightened neighbours. He along with
his 11 family members were quarantined after his nephew Stanley D'Silva
was confirmed with the disease two weeks ago. Although the state Government
has given Alhat a clean chit of health, his neighbours have not. "We
really don't have a choice but to live with them," says a neighbour
of Alhat, "but we are angry at the Government for putting us in this
position."
The Maharashtra Government swung from one extreme to another. Mumbai's
first confirmed SARS patient, Bhaskar Murthy, was discharged from the
hospital and even allowed to fly to Delhi before his test results were
confirmed. Union Health Minister Sushma Swaraj has since announced that
designated SARS hospitals should not discharge patients until they got
test reports. Authorities in Pune have now quarantined 50 people. In Siddharth
Hospital, where D'Silva was treated and nine medical staff have tested
positive, fear is palpable. The 21 quarantined patients have no idea which
of them is struck. A weary 22-year-old nurse says, "Luckily I am
not married. The nurses who have children and family are crying all day."
PATIENT WAIT: Elumalai (right) at the Christian Medical
College, Vellore
Fear sometimes borders on the ridiculous. In Delhi, amid traffic fumes,
a group of masked sadhus held an anti-SARS yagna to ward off the evil.
Add to it the confusion about whether India has SARS at all. After reviewing
a high-level meeting on May 1, Swaraj declared that "as on date,
India can be called a SARS-free country as none of these cases fall within
the purview of the who definition". The World Health Organisation
(WHO) defines SARS according to clinical symptoms-fever, bodyache and
X-ray showing pneumonia in the lungs-along with whether the patient has
visited a SARS country or come close to a SARS patient. None of the Indian
victims fits this definition though they have tested positive for the
SARS virus in a DNA-based test, the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Although
who points out that "laboratory test result criteria for confirming
or rejecting the diagnosis of SARS remain to be defined", its website
has a contradictory statement: "Positive PCR results are specific
and mean that there is genetic material of the SARS virus in the sample."
A person of Indian origin has died of SARS in Singapore but most Indian
SARS victims appear remarkably resilient, raising theories about Indians
being genetically more resistant to the disease. "It could be more
acute in certain ethnic groups," says immunologist Narendra Mehra.
Many are asymptomatic. Some showed mild symptoms and recovered. None of
them have shown pneumonia patches in X-rays. At Vellore's Christian Medical
College, Elumalai, 44, Tamil Nadu's first SARS patient, is a picture of
normality but for the mask he wears. "I feel good," he says,
"but bored and lonely."
If the Government's confused handling of the situation is any indication,
Elumalai will find himself with plenty of company.