As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
The
rampant misuse of the Dalit Act in Uttar Pradesh has a larger malaise behind
it, writes India Today's Subhash Mishra UNDUE
ADVANTAGE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE MAY 26, 2003
COVER STORY: MT EVEREST/BOOKS
Magic Mountain
As the world looks back with all the trappings
of showbusiness at the historic ascent of Everest, the ultimate act of
adventure, two books celebrate the event
By Suman Dubey
On My memory
of it is as clear as if it happened yesterday: Miss Meisenhammer, a kindly
teacher at Welham School in Dehradun, excitedly announcing to assembled
schoolboys, all aged 10 and less, that Princess Elizabeth had been crowned
Queen of England-and Everest had been climbed. That was half a century
ago in the first week of June, and I know which of those two events fired
my imagination more. Nine years later, in a stroke of good fortune, I
too found myself on Mt Everest, a member of the second Indian expedition
of 1962, following in the footsteps-not to the top, alas, but close enough
at the South Col-of Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay, the pair who made
the first ascent on May 29, 1953.
EVEREST: SUMMIT OF ACHIEVEMENT
By Stephen Venables
Roli
Price: Rs 1,975
Pages: 252
HIGH ADVENTURE: OUR ASCENT OF THE EVEREST
By Sir Edmund Hillary
Roli
Price: Rs 395
Pages: 245
Hillary and Tenzing published their accounts of the ascent soon after
and they quickly became classics, along with John Hunt's official account
of the expedition, The Ascent of Everest. Ironically, that ascent meant
the end of serious high-altitude climbing for both Tenzing and Hillary.
Tenzing, who died in 1986, continued his association with the mountains,
not as a climber but as an instructor. A hero in his adopted homeland,
India, he was quickly inducted into the Himalayan Mountaineering Institute
in Darjeeling, set up after the Everest ascent fired imagination in the
newly independent India. Hillary's life went in many directions, most
of them away from actual mountaineering. Over the years he has become
a sort of senior statesman among mountaineers and his energy has gone
into building schools and hospitals in Solo Khumbu, the region to the
south of Everest which is the home of the Sherpas.
Appropriately then, this commemorative year's publishing activity includes
a re-issue of Hillary's story of the climb, High Adventure. Stephen Venables,
a well-known British mountaineer who was seriously hurt during a climb
in Kumaon several years ago, has also edited a volume for the Royal Geographical
Society, London. And there is a third, sponsored by the Mount Everest
Foundation and the Alpine Club and put together by George Band who was
part of the successful 1953 expedition.
Hillary's life story has been told over the years in many volumes, High
Adventure being only the first. In his later years, past 80, he took another
look at his life in View From The Summit, but his first book, published
in 1955, has an immediacy and vividness that can only come from great
adventure. Hillary was lucky to be on the expedition at all. He happened
to be in Garhwal in 1951 when Nepal opened its borders to foreign climbers
and the famous explorer Eric Shipton invited him and fellow New Zealander
George Lowe, largely on account of their reputation and their ready availability,
to join the first exploration of the southern approach to the mountain.
Shipton was at first to lead the 1953 expedition, so Hillary's inclusion
in the team was natural, and John Hunt, who took over the leadership in
a last-minute change, invited him to join. Eventually it was Hillary's
great strength and the solid team he made with Tenzing that led to their
being chosen for the main summit attempt.
WELL-DESERVED REST: Band and Hillary
(first and second from left) after the Everest success; (below) Hillary
cuts a dashing figure
Venables' book, Everest: Summit of Achievement, is a very different sort
of book. All-encompassing, it looks back at various aspects of the Everest
story, the history, the Sherpas, new challenges since 1953 and the mysteries
that remain. And, of course, there are the photographs and illustrations
of memorabilia, which seem to me as being among the best collections to
be put between one set of covers. In particular, there are several dating
back to the early years, the 1920s and '30s in Tibet. There is also a
wealth of contemporary photographs from different expeditions, the historic
ones, such as the one taken by Reinhold Messner at the end of his solo
ascent in 1980 and a spectacular view of the entire massif taken by Leo
Dickinson during his epic balloon flight over the mountain in 1991.
Everest is much written about, and no single subject can withstand the
sort of assault that climbers, photographers and narrators have made on
it and still retain a sense of freshness. Is it possible for a subject
to be over-written, to be over-published? If so, then Everest is surely
a candidate for staleness. Is there anything that still remains to be
addressed? Perhaps mysteries, such as what happened to George Mallory
and Andrew Comyn Irvine, the two climbers who died in 1924 and were last
seen on the way to the summit from their final camp, will always make
interesting reading. There will be new routes, perhaps, and occasionally
a writer or a photographer with a new perspective. Most of all, there
remains space for a book that could answer for the lay reader the questions
that have been asked of mountaineers over generations: Why climb? Why
Everest? Those who have experienced it have their own private answers.
But the one answer that may be common to the thousands upon thousands
of climbers who endure hardship and danger for a pleasure they usually
cannot express remains a mystery.