As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
Whether
one deals in Sahanpur viticulture chisels or Moradabad alloys, Indian folk
art has a ready market abroad, writes India Today's Anshul Avijit. ART
OF BUSINESS
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE JUNE 30, 2003
COVER: CHINA GUEST COLUMN: CHANDRASEKHAR
DASGUPTA
Two in Tango
In charting a course to becoming world power,
India and China must realise that their basic interests are complementary,
not competitive.
It can be
safely predicted that China and India, two of the most populous countries
and fastest growing economies in the world, will emerge as great powers
in this century. It would also not be unreasonable to predict that China
will attain that status before India. These trends will influence the
foreign policies of both the countries as well as their mutual relations.
Reflecting their aspirations to a powerful status, both India and China
maintain that international relations are currently in transition from
a unipolar to a multipolar system. These statements should be seen simply
as a theoretical exercise in identifying future trends. It would be a
mistake to invest them with any operational significance. Neither country
has any interest in actively opposing unipolarity, or American hegemony,
on any issue where its national interests are not directly involved. China's
low profile in the Security Council debates on Iraq is a lesson in pragmatic
diplomacy. Both countries realise that their economic goals cannot be
achieved without good relations with the US. Besides, India's US policy
is reinforced by political factors and close civil society ties.
The fact that they both subscribe to the multipolarity thesis does not
mean that they necessarily have the same vision of a multipolar order.
China expects to be recognised as a great power relatively early and has
shown no particular interest in holding open the door to others thereafter.
It has not opposed India's claim to a permanent seat in the Security Council,
but neither has it endorsed it.
The relations between the two rising powers will reflect competitive
as well as complementary interests. Both countries should recognise, however,
that their basic interests are complementary in character. In the economic
sphere, their rapidly expanding markets offer new opportunities that far
outweigh the challenges of competition. In the political sphere, sustained
internal stability in China is of very real importance for India and other
neighbouring countries, as an unstable China could pose a big danger.
Likewise, India's continued adherence to an independent and self-reliant
foreign and defence policy is in accord with China's interests. If India
were ever to lose confidence in its ability to defend itself against a
regional power, it would have no option but to turn to a global superpower
for help.
In general, India-China relations are moving on the right track. Though
the boundary issue is yet to be resolved, border conflicts have been averted
by the Agreement on Maintenance of Peace and Tranquillity along the Line
of Actual Control. Confidence-building measures have been implemented
and military contacts have been deepened. Bilateral trade rose from $3
billion in 2001 to $5 billion in 2002 and saw a spectacular increase of
over 70 per cent between January and April this year, compared to the
same period last year. This augurs well for achieving the $10 billion
target indicated by former premier Zhu Rongji during his visit to India
last year. Besides, direct flights have been introduced and India has
been included as an approved destination for Chinese tourists. Most importantly,
regular high-level visits have provided the necessary impetus for strengthening
the bilateral ties.
To further strengthen these ties, China and India should be sensitive
to each other's legitimate concerns. China is the only country that does
not recognise Sikkim as an integral part of India. On its part, India
should continue to be sensitive to legitimate Chinese concerns over the
activities of Tibetans in India. Though most of these Tibetans are law-abiding,
a few troublemakers do not hesitate to defy the law, especially during
visits by Chinese leaders. On several occasions, India has had to take
firm action to prevent such unlawful activities as are prejudicial to
its national interests. At the same time, India cannot prevent anyone
from exercising his or her legal right to freedom of expression and China
should realise this fact.
These issues will doubtless figure in A.B. Vajpayee's talks with the
Chinese leaders. The Ministry of External Affairs has made careful preparations
and there is every reason to believe that the visit will have a positive
outcome. Speculation over what might emerge on specific issues will not
help the negotiators. Instead, it will raise public expectations and pressurise
the negotiators to show their hand in advance or ensure "success"
by making inappropriate concessions. We must remember that the goal of
diplomacy is to arrive at open agreements through confidential negotiations.
The author is a former Indian ambassador
to China and is currently associated with the Observer Research Foundation.