As
land hassles stem the flow of NRI investment in Punjab, the Government
takes steps to ease the legal woes of expatriates.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
Whether
one deals in Sahanpur viticulture chisels or Moradabad alloys, Indian folk
art has a ready market abroad, writes India Today's Anshul Avijit. ART
OF BUSINESS
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE JUNE 30, 2003
HERITAGE: ANTIQUE SMUGGLING
Past Master
Till the Jaipur Police arrested him last week
Vaman Narayan Ghiya was one of the world's most notorious antique thieves
who smuggled priceless items for auction houses
By Rohit
Parihar
He
liked Versace suits, wore Rolex watches and carried Mont Blanc pens. He
sported Italian shoes and stayed in luxury hotels. His frequent flier miles
were rivalled only by the number of antiques he had stolen-20,000. Till
the police arrested him from his swanky house in Jaipur last week, Vaman
Narayan Ghiya, hitherto known only as the owner of a local, nondescript
handicrafts showroom, was one of the world's topmost antique thieves. Ghiya's
activities were chronicled in Peter Watson's Sotheby's: The Inside Story
which was the equivalent of a stink bomb on the pricey auction house. Ghiya
was so wary of being caught that he would often switch hotels if he saw
someone staring at him in the lobby for more than a heartbeat.
MURKY DEALINGS: Ghiya in police custody in
Jaipur. His role in an international smuggling ring was first exposed
in a book on Sotheby's.
Ghiya was the mini mogul of a murky world where vases were illegally
excavated from graves in Italy and temple carvings stolen in the middle
of the night from under the nose of sleeping priests in India. When the
Jaipur Police searched his home on June 7, they found 34 catalogues each
of Sotheby's and Christie's on Indian and South-east Asian art listing
thousands of Indian antiques. When Ghiya was asked to flag the pieces
he had smuggled for these auction houses, he marked nearly 700. And that
included Khajuraho pieces that fetched Rs 6 crore and paintings by Old
Masters worth Rs 1 crore, not to mention ancient idols and figurines.
Though Ghiya now faces up to seven years in jail for running an antique
smugglers' gang, no one has counted him out. So it was not surprising
that he was aggressive and insulting when Anand Shrivastav, sp, Jaipur,
went to haul him in after a year-long undercover operation that began
with the recovery of antiques from a small gang in June last year.
STOLEN & AUCTIONED
THE BIG STEAL: Thanks to Ghiya's network,
Indian antiques would often end up in the catalogues of Sotheby's
and Christie's
JAIN TIRTHANKAR IDOL: In 1999, the idol
went missing from a site in Baran, Rajasthan, protected by the Archaeological
Survey of India. A year later, it surfaced in the Sotheby's September
2000 catalogue and was ready to be auctioned. Its reserve price is
between $25,000 and $35,000.
VARAHA: The five-quintal stone figure
was stolen from Attru in 1988. Dealers refused it because of its weight.
In 1998 it was sent abroad. It is now in the private museum that belonged
to Dr R. Russek of Switzerland.
MOTHER AND CHILD: This was one of several
idols scattered in Tanesar, a tiny village near Udaipur. It surfaced
in Sotheby's September 1997 catalogue. Other sculptures from this
group are in the collections of the MoMA in New York and the Cleveland
Museum of Art.
NATRAJ: The statue stolen from Barauli
in Chittorgarh in February 1998 is now with J. Kasmin, a private collector
in London. When there was a public uproar after the idol's disappearance,
Ghiya got a replica made in Paharpur stone for Rs 15,000. The fake
is in an ASI godown since 2000.
This is not the first time that Ghiya is in trouble. In 1986, the CBI
investigated a customs seizure of a consignment of his antiques in Mumbai-but
then the court acquitted him. Ghiya is so slippery that he had Brendan
Lynch, head of Sotheby's oriental antiquities section, hiding in his cupboard
when the CBI conducted a surprise raid on his home later in the year.
In 1988, the income tax authorities could not even make him reveal his
bank account numbers. Later when Watson came down to look into his crimes,
the investigative journalist ran out of funds and had to concentrate the
narrative only on the Sham brothers (Esa and Fakrou), two of the biggest
antique dealers in Mumbai.
Now that he is in jail, Ghiya has every intention of making life difficult
for the investigators. "He beats the hardest of the criminals when
it comes to stubborn silence," says Ram Singh Shekhawat, a young
inspector on the job. Ghiya pretends pain, refuses to eat and rarely volunteers
information. In the court, however, he shouted that he had been framed.
Knowing well that once in custody Ghiya would be a tough nut to crack,
the police worked overtime to gather enough evidence against him. Ajit
Singh Shekhawat, dig, Jaipur, sent a team of 20 officers in civvies to
crucial spots in several cities-sometimes they even spent many nights
there. In Jaipur, Shrivastav and others would analyse information that
came in on a day-to-day basis. They would scan the Internet, read books
and scour research papers besides going through firs of all antique thefts
in Rajasthan. The American Institute of Indian Studies, Gurgaon, Haryana,
turned out to be a major source. Sotheby's: The Inside Story, copies of
which were procured from abroad, also provided an insight into how auction
houses worked, besides providing names of many buyers and sellers.
Ghiya was the mastermind of a complex smuggling network. Antique pieces
disappeared from tiny villages in India to repeatedly surface in the collections
of the super-rich in Manhattan penthouses and London lofts. In 1999, an
idol of a Jain tirthankar went missing from Krishna Vilas in Baran, Rajasthan,
an ASI protected site. A year later it emerged-in Sotheby's September
catalogue, where it was tagged at a reserve price of $25,000-$35,000 (between
Rs 12 lakh and Rs 16.5 lakh). Similarly, a five-quintal stone figurine
of Varaha was stolen from Attru, Rajasthan, in 1988. It now rests in a
private museum in Switzerland that belonged to one Dr R. Russek whose
representative has confirmed it to the Jaipur Police. He has also said
that Russek bought half of his 500-strong Indian collection from Ghiya,
in what is just the tip of his antique empire.
Ghiya's is a trash to treasures story. Born to a studio photographer
in old Jaipur city in 1947, he graduated in science from Maharaja College,
Jaipur, before marrying in 1970. By that time, he was into selling Rajasthani
paintings in Jaipur and Mumbai. In Mumbai, one of his bulk buyers introduced
him to a Frenchwoman Arien Fye who initiated him into the antiques trade
as a middleman. Making contact with the Sham brothers, he soon set up
handicraft outlets in five-star hotels in metros and displayed goods at
international exhibitions to build contacts with private collectors around
the world. They became his major buyers and by the mid-'80s, Ghiya had
emerged as a force to reckon with, using 10 export companies as his conduits.
He set up at least three firms in Switzerland: Cap Lion Logging, Artistic
Import Corporation and Megavena. In London, Ghiya was provided space in
the house of James Hodges of Sotheby's to store the loot. Ghiya would
travel round the globe to regularly meet Sotheby's dealers and kept an
eagle eye on a flourishing network of dealers. In 1997, after the arrest
of his close rival Giacomo Medici in Italy, he probably became the very
best in the business.
In James Ivory's Hullabaloo Over George and Bonnie's Pictures, a wonderful
take on the world of antique thieves, Saeed Jaffrey's huckster wants to
relieve Victor Banerjee's raja of his priceless miniature paintings. The
princess Aparna Sen wants the lovely money but the raja cannot understand
the fuss: for him art is nothing more than a lot of naked women. Clearly,
Ghiya thinks differently