As
a champion of the developing world, the newly-appointed IMF chief
is set to spearhead a radical change.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
A
year in prison under POTA charges, disheartened MDMK cadres and damaging
allegations—Vaiko is having his worst time ever, observes India Today's
Arun Ram. DISCERNABLE
DOWNSLIDE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
South Asia's most influential and mostly read newsweekly presents the second Conclave India Tomorrow 2003: Global Giant or Pygmy?
Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE JULY 21, 2003
HERITAGE: MUSEUMS
Shelf Destruct
Over 40 years after it opened its doors to visitors,
the National Museum is only now in the process of documenting its collection
of over two lakh artefactsr
By Kaveree
Bamzai
Consider
this. Even 42 years after it came into being, the National Museum in Delhi
does not have photographs of all its artefacts. Only two reports of its
collections have been prepared so far-one in 1935 by F.H.Andrews of the
Central Asian antiquities donated in 1921 by the British explorer Sir Aural
Stein, and the other in 1987 of just 51 objects in the jewellery section.
What's more, the only comprehensive verification of the objects undertaken
so far has been going on for four years, that too under the directions of
the Delhi High Court. During this time, two experts have died-B.R. Grover,
who was examining the Persian antiquities, and R.S. Saini, who was studying
the Sanskrit manuscripts-and the chairman of the physical verification committee,
former culture secretary M. Varadarajan, has undergone a bypass operation.
Yet the report is far from written.
Hyderabad
SALARJUNG MUSEUM TOnly 12,200 of the curious collection of 48,000 objects are showcased
for want of sufficient space. It includes art objects, books and manuscripts
that were put together by Salar Jung III, prime minister to the Nizam.
The Veiled Rebecca, a delicate marble statue of a woman draped in
a transparent veil, and Mephistopheles and Margaretta, a wood carving
done in 1876, are among the items on show.
It comes as no surprise to anybody then that a pistol stolen from the
museum last month was wrongly listed as the one Lt-General A.A.K. Niazi
surrendered to his Indian counterpart Lt-General J.S. Aurora in 1971-the
real McCoy is actually safe at the Indian Military Academy in Dehradun.
The museum revels in bad labelling-witness its display of its most treasured
object, the bronze dancing girl from the Indus Valley, which has no caption
at all-and in quixotically keeping its treasures away from public gaze.
So a series of prized objects has never or very rarely been on display:
the trimohar of Akbar, the only gold coin of its kind; a rare copper plate
from Nalanda acquired from the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI); manuscripts
such as the Duwal Rani Khizrkhan; and the collection of one of the country's
greatest anthropologists, Verrier Elwin. Ask
R.D. Choudhury, director-general of the museum since 1998, and he can
only say, "We have no centralised data on the objects. The curator
of each department is supposed to know."
Delhi
NATIONAL MUSEUM
Stylised painted wooden mask of human skull: Any anthropology enthusiast
will be unable to distinguish the collection of Verrier Elwin from
the National Museum's other acquisitions. A staffer says it cannot
label Elwin's collection because the "existing format does not
allow it".
TRIMOHAR OF AKBAR, DATED BETWEEN 1556 AND 1605: The National Museum
has this priceless gold coin (front and back views) but it has never
displayed it. "It is extremely rare," says a staffer.
"We have shown it only once in 1983 at a temporary exhibition."
SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB, DATED 1839: The National Museum has two
copies of the sacred book, one of which was acquired in 1961. It
is significant for scholars as well as believers but it has never
been exhibited.
DUWAL RANI KHIZRKHAN: Earliest known illustrated manuscript dating
to Akbar's time, it deals with the love affair between Prince Khizrkhan,
the son of Sultan Alauddin Khilji, and Princess Devaldi. Written
by Amir Khusrau, it is a storehouse of information on the 13th century
but has never been exhibited.
If the curators know, they are not telling. The staff has no clear idea
of how many visitors the museum gets every day and how much of its collection
is actually displayed: the figure varies from 5 per cent of the total
items to a tiny 2 per cent. With the staff busy organising exhibitions
internationally and at the museum (over 20 a year), there is little time
for the institution to fulfil its actual role of public awareness. As
a result some artefacts have deteriorated with time and neglect. The manuscripts
especially, says a senior museum official, are "crying out for attention".
It has been enough to agitate intach, which is in the initial phase
of drafting a management plan for the museum. But the bigger question
really is the state of museums nationwide. Take a look at just two that
are under the aegis of the Ministry of Culture. At Kolkata's Indian Museum,
most of the 1.5 lakh objects are in the reserve collection though director
Shyamalkanti Chakravarti and his staff have tried to revolutionise the
20-odd storage areas from a disorganised dump to rows of 12-ft-high shelves.
But time may have effected a lot of damage. At the Salar Jung Museum in
Hyderabad, for instance, when the collection moved from its original home
in Dewan Deodi to its present building in 1968, a lot was lost. Ahtram
Ali Khan, grandnephew of Salar Jung III, prime minister to the Nizam of
Hyderabad, whose collection was acquired by the government by an Act of
Parliament in 1961, admits as much. "Some objects were obviously
stolen and others perhaps replaced in the early days. But there is no
way of checking, for there was no proper inventory," he says.
Lack of documentation is the biggest problem facing the custodians of
our heritage. This has led to rampant thefts even from protected monuments.
A list submitted by the Ministry of Culture to the Lok Sabha in April
this year details as many as 23 cases of theft in the past two years,
one of them from Hampi, a World Heritage Site, and two from the open sky
museum in Patan. Such thefts hit the headlines all over again last month
when the Jaipur police arrested Vaman Narayan Ghiya for allegedly smuggling
as many as 700 pieces for the auction house Sotheby's alone.
The situation may not be so alarming at the National Museum, though
it is surely unusual for a pistol to disappear from a gallery when as
many as 96 personnel of the Central Industrial Security Force and 28 museum
security guards keep watch at the premises. But it is clearly in need
of professional reorganisation and more importantly, a passion for the
past with a wish to store it for the future. As former director-general
of the ASI, M.C. Joshi, who is the chairperson of the museum screening
committee for international exhibitions, puts it, "The state of the
museum is apparent from the fact that not a single catalogue has been
published. I think the staff is overwhelmed by holding exhibitions. Where
is the time for first-hand research?" Or for the lofty values of
cultural awareness and scholarly research?