As
mainstream America discovers the goodness of tea, a variety of Indian
brews entice the market.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
Gurcharan
Singh Tohra is back at the helm of the SGPC in Punjab. India Today's Ramesh
Vinayak analyses the outcome of the appointement on Akali politics. FULL
CIRCLE
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
South Asia's most influential and mostly read newsweekly presents the second Conclave India Tomorrow 2003: Global Giant or Pygmy?
Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE AUGUST 11, 2003
STATES: MAHARASHTRA
Clash Of Castes
Despite having a Dalit chief minister, the state
grapples with anti-Dalit atrocities in remote villages. But politicians
refuse to see beyond vote-bank politics.
By Sandeep Unnithan
In the searing
May heat, Bhutegaon in Maharashtra's eastern Jalna districta was in a
festive mode. The homes of the upper caste people were brightly lit for
the marriage of Asaram Bhutekar's daughter. At the edge of the village,
in the cluster of mud-walled one-room huts of the Dalits, the Shendges,
who had just returned from Mumbai with their son Dilip, were also making
similar preparations. Two weeks later, the swarthy, strapping 21-year-old
youth, who worked as a plumber in Mumbai by the day and drove an autorickshaw
in the night, was to get married. But fate intervened.
DILIP SHENDGE, Bhutegaon village
The 21-year-old youth who had returned home from Mumbai for his marriage
was burnt to death for daring to hit upper-caste men who reportedly
harassed his sister and prevented her from drawing water from the
village hand pump.
One day, Dilip's sister Lata Kumari came home sobbing. Some upper-caste
boys had harassed and prevented her from drawing water from the village
hand pump. In the slums of Kandivali in suburban Mumbai where Dilip lived,
whoever came first to the water pipe drew water first. But the cosmopolitan
metropolis could well have been located on a different planet. The reality
in the remote village was very different. Dilip reached the spot and exchanged
blows with upper-caste men.
That evening, as the Bhutekars' marriage procession departed, a mob
of over 40 people led by Ramesh Bhutekar, a professor, approached Dilip's
hut baying for his blood. A Dalit had never dared to hit an upper-caste
person in the village's history. They wanted vengeance. Dilip locked himself
inside his tiny hut, which was lined with a dozen dusty calendar portraits
of leaders like Shivaji, Babasaheb Ambedkar, Bhagat Singh and even P.V.
Narasimha Rao, but the mob kicked down the door and pulled him out. "He
challenged them to fight one on one, but they weren't in a mood to listen,"
says his elder brother Ramesh. They poured kerosene over the youth and
set him afire. As his traumatised family and relatives watched, Dilip
turned into a human torch, staggering around wildly trying to douse the
flames. His horrified mother tried to help her son but got burnt in the
process. Dilip died five days later in a nearby hospital.
On the face of it, Maharashtra, the nation's most industrialised state,
appears to be the most socially progressive. For the first time in its
history, it has a Dalit chief minister and a deputy chief minister belonging
to the backward castes. But far from its cities and towns, in the villages
where people travel on rutted roads, caste rules with numbing ferocity.
This is especially true of the backward rain-deficient eastern Marathwada
region. All its eight districts-Aurangabad, Jalna, Parbhani, Nanded, Hingoli,
Beed, Latur and Osmanabad-figure in the Sarma Committee's report of the
100 poorest districts of the country. Jalna district where Dilip lived
registered the highest number of atrocities against Dalits in Marathwada-19
of the 46 cases registered so far.
Four of these clashes have erupted over water, underlining the link
of tradition with necessity. In Murtigaon village, violence again broke
out over the drawing of water from a hand pump. Janabai Thorat, 35, a
Dalit housewife, sustained head injuries when she intervened in a fight
between her husband Ankush and Bapurao Surase's upper-caste family. In
the remote Anvibangla village too caste violence broke out between the
upper castes and the Dalits over who would take water first from a tanker
lorry.
Of course, water is not the only reason for the conflict between the
upper castes and the Dalits. Two months after the Murtigaon incident,
a dozen upper-caste farmers lynched Dadarao Dongre, a 50-year-old Dalit,
in Beed district's Sonakhota village. His fault? He ran, sometimes unfairly,
say some locals, the village's most lucrative source of power and influence-its
sole ration shop. It was something that the upper-caste people resented.
ANKUSH THORAT, Murtigaon village
Most of the caste fights have erupted over water. Thorat and his wife
Janabai sustained injuries during a fight with upper-caste villagers
over drawing of water from a hand pump. Similar incidents have been
reported from across the state.
Shinde's Government which came under fire for these atrocities, not just
from the opposition Sena-BJP combine but from within the ruling party,
announced that such cases would now attract the provisions of the Prevention
of Terrorism Act. But that may not happen at all because a fact-finding
committee headed by Minister of State for Home (Rural) Kripashankar Singh
has attributed these killings to village disputes, and not caste violence.
"Kripashankar Singh is trying to camouflage what are clearly caste
conflicts being engineered by the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) workers
to defame Chief Minister Shinde," says BJP leader Nitin Gadkari.
With the electorate neatly carved up between four parties-the Congress,
NCP, Sena and the BJP, a swing in the Dalit votes could well be the deciding
factor in the next assembly elections. The Shiv Sena knows that. In the
previous assembly elections, it lost 22 seats across the state by margins
as low as 200 votes. That loss has meant a four-year stint in the opposition.
Next year's polls are also being seen as an acid test for the Sena's new
leader Uddhav Thackeray. The Shiv Sena is making all-out efforts to win
over the Dalits and this is reflected in the words of Shivaji Chote, president
of the Jalna district chapter of the Shiv Sena. "Do you know how
difficult it is for us to get votes?" he asks. "There are 35
per cent Muslims and Dalit voters in practically every constituency to
whom we have no access." In Jalna, the Shiv Sena has stepped up its
recruitment drive and this month alone, it opened five shakhas in the
village in a bid to woo the Dalits. So far, it has been only a trickle.
"This is unlikely to turn into a flood because the Dalits traditionally
follow their leaders and so far, all of them, including Prakash Ambedkar
and Ramdas Athavale, have rejected the Sena's attempts to play the Dalit
card,'' says political activist Avinash Dolas.
Politics has already struck deep roots in Bhutegaon's ferment of misery.
A blue flag bedecked signboard of a Dalit party has sprouted near the
Shendges' hut. The district administration has installed a hand pump nearby.
A 12-ft high brick and granite memorial symbolising a sun and a torch,
recently built by an aspiring politician from Mumbai, stands near the
spot where Dilip fell. A granite plaque and a poem commemorating the martyr
is illuminated by a floodlight hooked to an electricity pole nearby. The
irony is inescapable here. None of the Dalit houses in the village have
electricity supply.