As
mainstream America discovers the goodness of tea, a variety of Indian
brews entice the market.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
Emerging
out from the black gown of a lawyer, Mohammed Kutty, better known as Mammootty,
has come a long way in Malayalam cinema. "This throne I have earned
out of my blood and sweat. I am not going to leave it for anyone,"
he says in a lighter vein. He takes a trip down memory lane with India Today's
Senior Copy Editor P.K. Sreenivasan.. MOHAMMED
KUTTY
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
South Asia's most influential and mostly read newsweekly presents the second Conclave India Tomorrow 2003: Global Giant or Pygmy?
Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE SEPTEMBER 15, 2003
COVER STORY: SEX SURVEY
Sex and the Indian Woman
INDIA
TODAY-AC NIELSEN ORG-MARG SEX SURVEY: India's
first ever, comprehensive, all-female survey that looks at a woman's basic
instincts involved interviews with unmarried, married and separated women
between 19 and 50 years of age from 10 cities. In Ahmedabad, women placed
sex at 4, the highest in the country, on the 0-5 importance scale. But
for 25 per cent of women nationwide, sexuality is still a problem area,
treating it as they do with inexplicable indifference.
By Shefalee Vasudev
Even
when they are in love, women sleep with multiple partners. Only one of
these is a man. Silence, anxiety, guilt, denial and distrust are the others.
Even as they curl their lips, drop consonants and throw back their heads,
conformism remains emblazoned in their hearts. The good wife or the good
girlfriend must not be uninhibited. At least, that's the message thrown
up by the India Today-AC Nielsen ORG-MARG sex survey, the first such study
conducted in India exclusively among female respondents.
How
important is
sex in your life?
Important
43
Very important
23
Indifferent
25
Not important
09
Figures in per
cent
Something is not right. Weren't the new generation women supposed to
be the leaders and cheerleaders of sexual liberation? The perception,
at least, is of sex-saturated times. Devdas' Paro remained virginal despite
an obsessed lover, but the midriff flaunting girls next door are so different
from their grandmothers who knew their jewellers better than their G-spots.
Even adolescents, fed on diets of raunchy music videos and who-slept-with-whom
soaps, seem with it. Cleavage-clever Page 3 babes, bare-legged models,
bored housewives having phone sex, trophy wives hiring male strippers
for kitty parties, the heady kicks of nightlife-all create an illusion
of women driven by the torment of flesh that carries them beyond their
social identities. The illusion that a sexual revolution is breathing
fire in urban India.
There could not have been a better way to validate this idea than conducting
a survey among women, for female behaviour effectively maps social ebbs
and tides. But as it appears, the idea of a revolution is a false prophecy
for India. The herd remains loyal to lajja (shame)-the most popular word
in the Indian woman's sexual vocabulary. The word that smothers sexual
awakening and makes kissing in public a sin but not breast-feeding on
a bus. Those headaches may well have been for real.
Do
you share your sexual fantasies with your
husband/boyfriend?
Yes
60
No
34
Figures in per
cent
Rest: Don't know/Won't say
Do
you know where
your G-spot is?
Yes
42
No
29
Figures in per
cent
Rest: Don't know/Won't say
Fantasies being flights
of the mind were supposed to be closely guarded secrets. Till women
realised that the only way to give them hues of reality was to share
them with their partners. It is ironic that 34 per cent still keep
the fantasy factory to themselves. The G-spot, on the other hand,
seems to have found a place in the way women recognise their sexual
selves. Supposed to be the point of no return, it is good news that
more women now admit that their jewel is not in the crown. The G-spot
is no longer disowned. A happy discovery.
When a contemporary survey reinvents the traditional approach to sex
it is time to pause and wonder. But such questioning doesn't gather critical
mass because personal interviews with urban women show a sharp contrast
in attitude. There seem to be more avenues for women to talk about sex.
Many love being called sexy, others understand that wearing revealing
cholis doesn't make them sex objects. Quite a few share the sweet-and-sour
bits of their lives-erotic, ecstatic, sometimes deviant, dotted with privileged
and penalised sexual activities. And explain why they want to make extraordinary
choices for meaningful sex.
The disparity is clear: silence or indifference is countered by passionate
rhetoric. But it can't be written off by saying that all women who talk
about sex are the new, few decadent drifters. That they fake smiles and
orgasms. That they are sexual exhibitionists in male imitation. That the
overload of sexual stimuli bombarding us-sexy ideas, sexy ads, sexy films-is
contriving to create sexually confident women. That they may be using
the F-word or buying vibrators in grey markets, but their sexual liberation
is just good old Indian fiction after all.
The conflict is deep and searing. In the boiler room that is the Indian
woman's mind, Vatsyayana, Buddha, Freud, Foucault, Rajneesh, Shere Hite
and Germaine Greer seem to be having a relentless screaming match. And
when they fall silent, Sita and Kali pick up a fight. Sita, in her ever-relenting,
passive form, and Kali, intoxicated with power, blinded by rage and voraciously
sexual. It is too early on the rolls of India-in-transition to expect
the women to resolve this literary-historical-traditional mess entirely
and say, "Yes, we want sex and how".
What
would you do if you were not happy with sex
in your marriage/ relationship?
Talk to your partner
43
Do nothing about it
23
Have an affair on the side
25
Masturbate
09
Don't know/Won't say
09
Figures in per
cent
What
is your preference
in foreplay?
Kissing
55
Massage
16
Looking at body parts
14
Undressing the partner
11
Watching a blue film
06
Don't know/Won't say
27
Figures in per cent;
Percentage does not add up to 100 because of multiple responses
Sure, the modern woman's yearning for liberation feels hollow if she
confuses virginity with chastity. Worse, if she talks about her intimate
life in practised responses, she will only pave the path for her submissiveness,
in and out of bed. The fact, an antithesis to the war-cry of the modern
woman, is that she actually doesn't know what she wants. Even women who
are challenging or negotiating their relationships for better sex, admit
it is not easy to distinguish between promiscuity and sexual freedom,
decency and obscenity.
As experts say, the truth doesn't lie entirely in our survey. Neither
does it lie in the accounts of women who say they have been to orgies,
tried threesomes or swapped spouses. Even the globally lauded Shere Hite
Report on female sexuality found that a large number of American women
felt guilty about masturbation. The 1998 University of Chicago Report,
next in importance to the Kinsey Report, showed that Americans were overwhelmingly
monogamous, with 94 per cent women finding extramarital sex unacceptable.
In this survey too, it is the inconsistencies that spark off the questions.
A large number of women say they find premarital and extramarital sex
and masturbation unacceptable. That heterosexual marriage must be guarded
against alternative sexuality. At the same time, some are willing to tick
the number of partners they have had outside marriage and whether they
had sex in their homes or in hotel rooms. They know where there erogenous
zones are and find oral sex and foreplay essential ingredients of gourmet
sex. Some even masturbate before their lovers and for most, orgasms are
a must for fulfilment.
It doesn't add up. If the modern woman continues to represent her sexuality
as different from what it really is, the fear is she may become a caricature,
more in control of her lingerie than her life. If she wants good sex,
she will have to begin by admitting to that need in clear, unambiguous
terms. Why blame the men? So two cheers for the survey that has pointed
this out. But the third one must be reserved for the Kamasutra that says,
"Of what use is virtue when its results are so uncertain?"
How
important is having
an orgasm for your
sexual fulfilment?
Veryimportant/Important
57
Not important
08
Don't know/Won't say
21
Indifferent
14
Figures in per
cent
How
often do you
feel satisfied after a
sexual encounter?
Always
32
Sometimes
24
Don't know/Won't say
21
Mostly
19
Never
04
Figures in per
cent
Sensitivity and
orgasmic fulfilment, crucial to assessing sex lives, get a high
rating. Despite popular rhetoric that women don't find men matching
up to their sexual awakening, 64 per cent of those polled said
their partners were sensitive to their sexual needs. The tricky
figure is the 24 per cent who find sex only occasionally satisfying.
Do
you think your partner
is sensitive to your
sexual needs?
Yes
64
No
13
Don't know/Won't say
23
Figures in per
cent
What
have you tried?
Oral sex
27
Anal sex
13
Bisexual sex
16
Group sex
06
Don't know/Won't say
41
Figures in per
cent; Percentage does not add up to 100 because of multiple
responses
Bisexuality, an
emerging trend among urban women, got a resounding echo. Surprising
is the 13 per cent who say they have tried anal sex, which till
recently was a male preference.
How
many orgasms
satisfy you?
One
49
Two-Three
14
Multiple
04
Don't know/Won't say
33
Figures in per
cent; Percentage does not add up to 100 because of multiple
responses
METHODOLOGY
Purposive interviews were conducted using a mix of house-to-house
interviews and Central Location Tests (CLTs). The field researchers
encountered severe resistance from respondents in some cities after
they had had a look at the questionnaire. In some cases, people tore
up the questionnaires, in other areas respondents were uncomfortable
with house-to-house interviews. In yet others, they felt awkward about
the CLTs. So a mix of the two data collection techniques had to be
employed to carry out the survey.
RESPONDENTS' PROFILE
Nearly 2,305 women belonging to the middle and upper-middle class
(sec A and sec B) were interviewed across 10 cities. They belonged
to three age groups: 19-24 years, 25-34 years and 35-50 years and
included unmarried, married and divorced/separated women. Some questions
were asked only to those women who said they had had sex (1,814).
Questions on extramarital sex were put only to those who said they
had had relationships outside marriage (119). Two-thirds of the
respondents were graduates/postgraduates; the rest were educated
till senior or higher secondary. Almost all respondents owned a
colour TV, four-fifths owned a house, while 15 per cent owned a
mobile phone and a quarter drove a vehicle.
PREVIOUS SURVEYS
In 1978, a survey conducted by The Social Research Unit of the Indian
Market Research Bureau for India Today, polled 604 college students
in Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai and Kolkata. Two-thirds of the students
found premarital sex unacceptable. A staggering 81 per cent said
the girls who lost their virginity before marriage had "bad
reputations". Contrary to the India Today-AC Nielsen ORG-MARG
survey of 2003, Delhi was the most conservative in 1978 where only
31 per cent students admitted to petting compared to Kolkata where
76 per cent claimed to have done the same. In Chennai, only 11 per
cent admitted to premarital sex.
In 1982, a Chennai survey on sexuality among 9,000 students in
nine colleges found that 52.4 per cent students had had premarital
sex.
In 1994, an India Today-MARG survey among 1,365 undergraduates
from eight cities found that 18 per cent girls accepted premarital
sex, 15 per cent didn't mind using sex appeal to get ahead and 34
per cent were amenable to having a fling even while going steady.
In 1996, an Indian Council of Medical Research survey studied
sexual behaviour of 5,000 adolescents in the 10-14 years age group
in six Indian states. It concluded that both premarital sex and
teenage pregnancies were rapidly growing trends.
How
often do you have sex?
More than once a week
29
Once in two weeks
23
Once in two months
29
Daily
08
Never
11
Figures in per
cent
Frequent sex doesn't translate into better sex, say women:
only 8 per cent have sex daily. Masturbation and extramarital
sex, associated with guilt across the world by women, find
few takers in India.
Do
you masturbate?
No
75
Don't know/Won't say
16
Yes
09
Figures in per
cent
Have
you had
extramarital sex?
No
81
Don't know/Won't say
12
Yes
07
Figures in per
cent
What
do you
fantasise about?
Different love-making positions
with your partner
66
Watching other people have
sex
09
Orgies/group sex
10
Others
05
Don't know/Won't say
14
Figures in per
cent; Percentage does not add up to 100 because of multiple
responses
What
would you do if
you were sexually attracted to a colleague?
Never confess to such an
attraction
61
Keep the affair out of office
04
Don't know/Won't say
28
Kiss and pet/Have sexual
rendezvous
03
Drop hints
04
Figures in per
cent
ANALYSIS
Dr Madhu Sarin, Psychoanalyst
INTIMATE MASKS
It
has always been hard to puzzle out Indian attitudes on sexuality.
Indians are affectionate and sensual, though their philosophical
aspirations tend to valourise asceticism and renunciation. So it
isn't surprising that the India Today-AC Nielsen ORG-MARG survey
paints women as conservative and cautious.
In traditional cultures, much that is socially taboo is implicitly
accepted as long as it is not explicit. Particularly sexuality.
As long as social facade and the traditional family structure-usually
a heterosexual marriage with one male child-is maintained, a blind
eye is turned towards other sexual liaisons. The taboo is not on
sexual conduct but on "outing" it, which may involve a
loss of face or threaten the stability of accepted social arrangements.
In such cultures, women are the safekeepers of traditions and values,
resulting in the strict regulation and control of women's sexuality
to maintain family honour and ensure legitimacy of progeny.
So no matter how "emancipated" today's women are, they
will experience some conflict between their new desires and previously
internalised social expectations. To engage in or talk openly about
their sexuality would generate a sense of vulnerability. This is
clearly reflected in the survey. On the one hand, the frankness
that some women show reflects a newfound sense of power and confidence.
For some, it could be a form of exhibitionism to shock and titillate.
Or, it could be an attempt to gain attention, a kind of Page 3 prestige.
On the other hand, it should be expected that such answers would
be tempered with some anxiety about a potential backlash (internally),
which may lead to a measure of caution or prudence in responses.
Sexuality is always framed by intense fantasies which often get
merged with factual narratives. This leads to distortions in surveys
which reflect some compromise between the self-image and their own
fantasies and desires. For instance, 22 per cent of women surveyed
associate masturbation with an image of being out of control. This
is a common fantasy in India.
Sexuality is a part of a person's experience from birth. The way
a mother handles a baby determines the capacity for sexual excitement.
In India, babies are handled for much longer than in other cultures.
This leads to a stimulation of all kinds of sensuality, including
sexuality. But our joint family system promotes family solidarity
over the conjugal relationship. This inhibits the expression of
sexual fulfilment in marriage, resulting in sexual repression. Sons
and mothers especially have a close relationship, which is overly
eroticised because of the frustration many women feel in their conjugal
relationship. This may lead to the "internal mother" threatening
the son's sense of self and may spill over to other women in his
life, making him inhibited. This creates a vicious cycle of sexually-inhibited
husbands and sexually-frustrated wives.
Although there are many exceptions, a stereotype governs men and
women when it comes to erotic desire and emotional commitment. Men
like to play the field and have an easier time expressing their
sexual desires, while women find it easier to make long-term, monogamous
commitments. Since girls shift their passionate attachment from
mother to father, they develop a better capacity to develop a deep
relationship with an admired and more distant loved one. This promotes
their capability for commitment in sexual and emotional life. Keeping
this in mind, it is interesting to note some of the newer nuances
in this survey. Many women seem to be thinking out of the stereotype.
They say that sexual pleasure, orgasms, frequent and non-traditional
sex are all important. Also, a fairly large proportion say their
husbands are sensitive to their sexual needs and that they are not
bored by sex in marriage. It could mean a variety of things.
Possibly, because of changes in the way women perceive themselves
and the adaptation made by their husbands, they ask for and enjoy
greater sexual satisfaction. Or it may mean that they regard sex
as a significant but not critical part of marriage-that they are
not terribly excited by sex, but not bored by it either. A selective
survey will not answer all these questions.
What
would you do if your friend gave you a blue film?
Return it without watching
it
37
Watch it with your partner
28
Don't know/Won't say
16
Watch it with a group of
women friends
08
Watch it alone in the bedroom
11
Figures in per
cent
How
important is your own pleasure to you while
having sex?
As important as the partner's
52
Less important than the partner's
10
Don't know/Won't say
23
More important than the partner's
09
Unimportant
06
Figures in per
cent
What
would you do if your partner refused to have oral sex with you?
Don't know/Won't say
49
Tell him that it is important
for you
18
Refuse to have sex with him
06
Suppress your urge
11
Refuse to give him oral sex
16
Figures in per
cent
Old hat? Perhaps, but oral sex was for long considered a
man's prerogative and a woman's dream. Now that much of fantasy
is being shared by sexual partners, it is surprising that
49 per cent women say they wouldn't know what to say if their
partner refused to have oral sex with them. Not knowing must
be the toughest choice.
On the other hand, blue films aren't remote anymore. For the
28 per cent who watch it with partners, there is the promise
of a turn-on. But the real thrill-for 11 per cent-is watching
a blue film alone.
Does
your poor body
image reduce your
sexual pleasure?
No
54
Yes
54
Don't know/Won't say
24
Figures in per
cent
Sex with a colleague? Not good, say most. Indirect hints
make for a sexual statement despite the fact that 22 per cent
have had sex in front of a mirror! The best finding is that
women don't let their body image dampen their pleasure.
If
you want sex, do you ...
Suggest it indirectly
40
Make the first move
20
Don't know/ Won't say
27
Suppress it
13
Figures in per
cent
In
which of these places
have you had sex?
Outside the bedroom
40
In front of a mirror
22
In car/train/on beach
10
On the dining table
02
Don't know/Won't say
42
Figures in per
cent; Percentage does not add up to 100 because of multiple
responses
How
many sexual partners have you had outside marriage?
One
58
Few
18
Many
11
Don't know/Won't say
13
Figures in per
cent: Only respondents who admitted to extramarital sex
Women do it too. Look at the numbers: 87 cent of those who
admitted to sex outside marriage even revealed the number
of sexual partners they have had.
Which
is your
favourite position?
Man on top
53
Women on top
10
Don't know/Won't say
25
Sideways
07
Rear entry
02
Sitting
03
Figures in per
cent
Man is still on top. But it isn't necessarily a boring choice.
Off record, women will admit that it is the missionary position
that revs up intimacy the most. Besides motivation and opportunity,
some women also want the other man. But when 22 per cent say
they had had sex with their husbands' friends they also explain
why the same age group is the most sexually attractive.
Would
you exchange sexual favours for a raise
or promotion?
No
83
Yes
03
Don't know/Won't say
14
Figures in per
cent
Predictable. Women wouldn't exchange sexual favours to scale
the success ladder. What isn't so predictable is that 31 per
cent still say they held hands and hugged in the name of sex.
How come 50 per cent don't know what they did?
Before
marriage, which of these did you allow your partner to do?
Holding hands and hugging
you
31
Kissing
22
Stimulating your body parts
06
Having sexual intercourse
05
Don't know/Won't say
50
Figures in per
cent; Percentage does not add up to 100 because of multiple
responses
Who
have you had extramarital sex with?
Husband's friends
22
Relatives
19
Office colleagues
16
Casual acquaintances
13
Don't know/Won't say
38
Figures in per
cent; Percentage does not add up to 100 because of multiple
responses
How
old would you want
your extramarital
partner to be?