As
mainstream America discovers the goodness of tea, a variety of Indian
brews entice the market.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
2
Mall Avenue, the residence of former chief minister Kalyan Singh heading
the Rashtriya Kranti Party (RKP) is buzzing with activity these days. His
supporters, not to mention bureaucrats, are making a beeline here for coveted
postings. Having played an important role in the oust-Mayawati campaign,
Kalyan Singh evidently is in much demand now. But despite his busy schedule,
he spoke to India Today's Farzand Ahmed. Excerpts: INTERVIEW
KALYAN SINGH
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
South Asia's most influential and mostly read newsweekly presents the second Conclave India Tomorrow 2003: Global Giant or Pygmy?
Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE SEPTEMBER 22, 2003
THE NATION: SANGH PARIVAR
Temple Temptation
The BJP's failed alliance with Mayawati spurs
the RSS to stir the Ayodhya pot. Armed with the ASI report, the VHP is
set to launch a public agitation.
By Rajeev Deshpande
When Prime
Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee assured mourners at the funeral of Mahant
Ramchandra Paramhans that all "impediments" in the path of building
a Ram temple would be removed, he could hardly have anticipated just how
soon he would be asked to redeem his pledge.
WEDDED TO THE CAUSE: The VHP offensive has
the RSS' whole-hearted backing
Vajpayee's dramatic announcement made on the banks of the Saryu was not
quite a precursor to action. The mahant had been the leading figure in
the Ram Janmabhoomi movement and his flock had to be kept in good humour.
But since the mahant's cremation on July 31, the political landscape in
Uttar Pradesh has changed beyond recognition. The BJP is reeling from
a bitter divorce with the BSP and after an eight-year exile, Mulayam Singh
Yadav is again the chief minister. There are other developments also that
have stirred the political cauldron. An Archaeological Survey of India
(ASI) report on excavations at the disputed site at Ayodhya says there
are remnants of a temple. The findings have been challenged, but the controversy
has energised the VHP.
The developments have lent themselves to differing interpretations.
But there is unanimity that the BJP has ended up as the net loser. Not
only is the Samajwadi Party (sp) in power, the BJP's calculations for
a grand alliance with the BSP for Elections 2004 have gone awry. While
the BJP lurched from crisis to crisis, the RSS has been a quiet but not
an inactive observer of the events. It had viewed the BJP's stuttering
16-month alliance with Mayawati with alarm. While the BJP put forward
a brave face and sought to soothe its hurt by clandestinely teaming up
with the sp, the RSS had its eyes on the future. The problem is easy to
diagnose: if the BJP does not recover ground in Uttar Pradesh how will
it present a credible challenge to Sonia Gandhi's bid for power?
SAFFRON HEADACHES
AYODHYA: Negotiations
with the Muslim Personal Law Board are stalled and legal proceedings
are slow. The ASI report provides the only talking point.
UTTAR PRADESH: The honeymoon
with Mulayam Singh Yadav is unlikely to last, confrontational politics
cannot be avoided. The BJP organisation is in poor shape.
ELECTIONS 2004: Tie-up with
the BSP was central to the BJP strategy to retain power at the Centre.
The erosion of NDA support in cowbelt will be difficult to compensate.
VHP: The temple proponents
have accused the BJP of betraying the Ram Janmabhoomi cause. Leaders
like Ashok Singhal have accused the PM of doublespeak.
SONIA GANDHI: The Congress
president is seen to have gained political stature. The RSS is worried
that the BJP is being complacent in underestimating her.
The RSS knew that the BJP's options were limited. It could play the Opposition
against the Mulayam Singh Government but in Uttar Pradesh's caste-ridden
polity the BJP was caught between the BSP and the SP. With cracks appearing
in the NDA in Bihar as well-the exit of Ram Vilas Paswan has benefited
Laloo Prasad Yadav-the BJP's Lok Sabha tally of 184 simply does not look
defensible. The RSS has long held the view that only a recourse to Hindutva
issues can reinvigorate the BJP. The ASI report provided the trigger that
the RSS had been looking for and its consultations with the VHP soon bore
fruit. "The ASI report has proved those who argued against the existence
of a temple at the disputed site, absolutely wrong," says RSS spokesperson
Ram Madhav.
While the RSS prepared for consultations with the BJP, the VHP was already
changing gears. The VHP's most visible and controversial face Pravin Togadia
has been touring western Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand.
Though the meetings are part of the VHP's Sutra Sankalp programme, Togadia's
message presages things to come. Speaking at Noida's Sanatan Dharma temple
last week, Togadia cleverly mixed the political with the religious. "The
excavations have revealed pillars of a temple. I can see them and so can
you, but Sonia Gandhi and Mulayam cannot," he declaimed.
The VHP's plans will be formally revealed at the meeting of the organisation's
Marg Darshak Mandal (steering committee) on September 14-16. The demand
will be direct: a Central legislation that will hand over the disputed
site at Ayodhya to the VHP-controlled Ram Janmabhoomi Nyas for the construction
of a Ram temple. The VHP will then launch a public agitation with the
focus on Uttar Pradesh. Togadia has been hinting at it, asking his audiences
to "await the directions of the sants".
There are many in the BJP who are not averse to the VHP's plans. BJP
Uttar Pradesh chief Vinay Katiyar says, "I was silenced all those
days when Mayawati was the chief minister. Now we will take up the Ram
temple issue in full earnest." The BJP central leadership is not
fully convinced. While it does not see a problem in the state unit raising
the pitch on the mandir issue, the party is more careful when it comes
to openly backing the VHP's plans. The temple troopers in the Sangh Parivar
have demanded a legislation earlier also. Now it has the RSS' backing
and the latest gamble on Ayodhya takes place in the run-up to next year's
general elections.
"TOGADIASPEAK"
"The ASI report demolishes the argument
that the Ayodhya issue is merely a property dispute." "Sants will authorise a public agitation."
"The VHP steering committee will demand
a legislation for the land to be given to the Nyas."
"We will force political parties to take
a stand. Those who oppose us will suffer."
"BJP workers will participate in the stir."
Senior BJP office-bearers said while the party's rhetoric would be strong,
it would stop short of announcing its support for or participation in
the VHP's planned agitation. The BJP is aware of its NDA compulsions and
knows that its allies have in the past been chary of Ayodhya. Yet, BJP
leaders are more than a bit tempted. They are all too aware of the fact
that their options in combating caste politics in north India are limited
and Ram Janmabhoomi sounds like a reassuring theme. Even in discussions
involving Vajpayee, Deputy Prime Minister L.K. Advani and party brass,
it has been felt that the temple may yield some results. "ASI report
ka kafi asar ho sakta hai (This report can have big ramifications),"
Vajpayee is understood to have remarked.
The BJP leadership has also been frustrated by the failure of the Kanchi
Shankaracharya's negotiations with the All-India Muslim Personal Law Board.
In June, there were tantalising prospects of a breakthrough but the RSS
and VHP's refusal to give up claims to the Kashi and Mathura shrines in
return for a deal on Ayodhya scuttled the talks. "The negotiations
are at a standstill," says Kamal Farooqie of the Muslim body.
Not surprisingly, RSS chief K.S. Sudarshan's meeting with Advani on
September 7 touched on the Ram temple. Sudarshan was accompanied by RSS
General Secretary Mohan Bhagwat and Joint General Secretaries H.V. Seshadri
and Madandas Devi. The VHP's plans were discussed and the BJP was advised
to prepare a response. It is expected that the BJP, adopting a cautious
posture, will first wait to see how the VHP's plans proceed. The VHP often
feels that the BJP has been cynical in utilising the Ram card. Once again,
the political gains of Hindutva beckon, but a partnership with the VHP
always has a downside. The BJP has to decide whether the price is worth
it.