CURRENT ISSUE  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
INDIA TODAY
    CURRENT ISSUE NOVEMBER 29, 2004
 
   COVER STORY: THE RELIANCE FEUD
 
Ambani Vs Ambani

The feud between Mukesh and Anil Ambani could get messier as the battle for control of India's biggest private-sector enterprise threatens the future of the house that Dhirubhai built
 

On Dalal Street, there is this old joke that the evolution in the Indian economy is symbolised by the transition from self-reliance to Reliance. It is a joke that has more than a touch of reality. There is a mystical aura that surrounds this Rs 90,000 crore empire, a Midas touch ensuring that virtually every project it launches turns to gold. The house that Dhirubhai Ambani built almost from nothing has gone on to become the darling of investors, an all-powerful entity that had, as its legend grew, the power to change governments and ministers. It is not just India's biggest private-sector entity but the burnished showpiece of Indian enterprise. No other private corporation has managed to straddle the old and the new economy with such awesome success. Reliance is, in almost every which way, a corporate fairy-tale. Till last week, that is.

  PICTURE SPEAK
RIVALRY UNLIMITED: The impasse between the brothers could prove to be the costliest mistake

The long-running Reliance saga has now taken an ugly, even sinister turn. The simmering rivalry between Dhirubhai's sons, Mukesh, 47, and Anil, 45, threatens to rock the empire to its foundations and throw up some very dirty linen in very public spaces. Last week's remark by Mukesh, chairman and MD of Reliance Industries Limited (RIL), the Group's flagship company, that there were "ownership issues" brought into the open what was suspected ever since Dhirubhai's death in July 2002: that the battle for control of the spoils that afflicts most Hindu undivided families, when a powerful patriarch passes away, had visited itself on India's most admired and professionally run corporation.

The stakes are massive: ranging between Rs 50,000 crore and Rs 78,000 crore in assets for whoever controls the five key pillars of the empire (see chart). A split, unofficial for now, yet inevitable after last week's developments, will cast a shadow over the Reliance empire and raise uncomfortable questions about its future. The current battle extends beyond the two main protagonists. It involves the future of the stock markets, millions of shareholders, a major chunk of government revenues, the confidence of Indian industry, some 80,000 employees and the very image of Reliance as a dynamic, hugely successful corporation that symbolised the can-do spirit of Indian entrepreneurship more than any of its rivals.

Empire in Turmoil

Why the market panicked when the foundation of Reliance shook

  PICTURE SPEAK
THEN: Dhirubhai with Anil and Mukesh

Last week as Mukesh Ambani's soundbites on ownership issues echoed on Dalal Street, the Reliance counters saw heightened trading worth Rs 200 crore. As the RIL share price dropped from Rs 545 to Rs 527, Rs 3,400 crore of market capitalisation was shaved off. Interestingly, among the losers were the Ambanis who notionally lost over Rs 1,500 crore. Mercifully the markets calmed down but nervousness persists.

The tremors are justifiable. Reliance Industries is not just any other company. This September its sales touched Rs 43,680 crore and net profit was Rs 3,189 crore. Its annual sales are in the region of Rs 90,000 crore, and daily sales are around Rs 240 crore with profit earnings of Rs 18 crore a day. RIL is virtually a behemoth that not only provides livelihood to over 80,000 employees but also accounts for over 3 per cent of the nation's GDP and 10 per cent of the revenue collected. Its empire stretches from well heads to plug points, thanks to its ownership of four mega corporations: Reliance Energy, Reliance Capital, Indian Petrochemicals and the telecom juggernaut Reliance Infocomm valued at Rs 45,000 crore.

The devil is in the details. The ownership is vested not in individuals but in a maze of companies. Thanks to an obscurantist taxation system and a resource-scarce economy, Indian companies are rarely owned by a single entity and the ownership rests with investment companies owned by families. RIL is no exception to Indian practices. It is owned by a clutch of 14 companies which in turn are owned by a complex web of investment outfits, the control of which extends to over 1,400 entities. Unravelling this maze could be both legally complex and time consuming. In an economy where lending against shares was seen as sinful, promoters had to create vehicles which fuelled their growth ambitions. Therefore, divisions in Indian companies are mostly an issue of control. Much of the corporate landscape operates on the principle that possession (in this case management control) is nine parts of law.

  RELIANCE: TAKING STOCK
CLICK HERE TO SEE THE GRAPHIC

Dhirubhai Ambani's empire is also constructed on a similar architecture and typically of the tycoon its complexity is unparalleled primarily because of its size. Unlike other business scions who inherited empires, the Ambani brothers have been part of Reliance's growth. While Mukesh joined the business in 1981 when RIL turnover was Rs 300 crore, Anil joined the business two years later when sales crossed Rs 500 crore.

In a sense the two brothers are as much architects of Reliance's complexities as their father was. Any physical change in the structure would affect the highly integrated business. RIL, for instance, has an internal synergy with IPCL. It owns stakes in gas fields which would be used to feed the power plants of Reliance Energy.

So when many discussed the pitfalls of a potential split, investment bankers and legal pundits wondered if that was possible at all. Every part of the Reliance Group is interconnected like a giant server where RIL acts as the motherboard. There is speculation about an imminent settlement. The options are negotiable. The timing, though, is dependent on events.

-By Shankkar Aiyar

 

 

Next Page

 

CURRENT ISSUE
DECEMBER 06, 2004
 IN THIS ISSUE
COVER STORY

AMBANI VS AMBANI
 
OTHER STORIES
 

The Sacred And The Political

Quelling Fires Of Discontent

Death of a Slogan

Learning Curve

Bound To That Midnight

Talk The Walk

Price of Freedom

Bolt From The Blue

It's All Business

A Green Promise

Living On The Edge

Losing the Race

Well-Oiled Machine

Big Fat Weddings

Storm in a Teahouse

Poison Ivies

 
CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY